You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myDaytonDailyNews.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myDaytonDailyNews.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myDaytonDailyNews.com.

breaking news

Tornado watches issued for several counties

Study: Majority of women with breast cancer get unnecessary treatment


Brought to you by

Kettering Breast Evaluation Centers

More than half of breast cancers newly diagnosed in the United States are likely cases of mistaken identity that subject women to needless anxiety, treatment and expense, researchers reported Wednesday in the New England Journal of Medicine.

The study also found that the value of mammograms as a life-saving tool has been significantly overstated. Instead, the introduction of more effective treatments should get most of the credit for improving survival rates among women diagnosed with breast cancer, the researchers concluded.

The findings cast fresh doubt on the value of universal breast cancer screening for women over 40 with no family history of the disease. They also underscore that breast cancer — the most common form of cancer among American women — is a far more complex disease than initially believed.

The hope that early detection would consistently save women’s lives accorded with scientists’ limited understanding of cancer in the mid-1970s. Experts believed that a small breast lump was almost always a harbinger of a tumor that would, with time, grow and spread.

Catch and treat it early, their reasoning went, and you will see one less woman coming in later with a large and aggressive cancer.

But medical researchers have come to recognize that a tumor’s genetic make-up, as well as the interaction between tumor and host, are better predictors of its progression than the tumor’s size upon discovery. One woman’s tumor might reach 2 centimeters and then stop growing for many years. Another’s might progress from undetectable to a dangerous 5 centimeters in a matter of months.

It was a new, more complex picture of breast cancer. And it undercut the idea that early detection and early treatment were essential to save lives.

“The mantras, ‘All cancers are life-threatening’ and ‘When in doubt, cut it out,’ require revision,” Dr. Joann G. Elmore, a physician and epidemiologist at the University of Washington, wrote in an editorial that accompanies the study. The “well intentioned efforts” of doctors, she wrote, are exacting “collateral damage.”

As breast imaging became widely available in the early 1980s, physicians told women that catching tumors early, before they could be felt by hand, was key to their survival.

Advocates quickly began pushing for universal screening programs. By the mid-1980s, an American Cancer Society awareness campaign told women over 35, “If you haven’t had a mammogram, you need more than your breasts examined.”

It’s now clear that physicians, activists and the media “quite simply have overstated the value” of mammography, said study leader Dr. H. Gilbert Welch, one of the first researchers to raise questions about overscreening.

Whether motivated by true belief, commercial gain or fear of litigation, he said, those forces have been slow to accept that when all women get mammograms, some will respond to scary findings in ways that do more harm than good.

In 2016, physicians in the United States are expected to diagnose 246,660 new cases of invasive breast cancer, along with 61,000 new cases of non-invasive breast cancer (sometimes referred to as ductal carcinoma in situ, or DCIS).

The analysis of data from the National Cancer Institute suggests that the majority of abnormalities picked up by screening mammograms would likely never become deadly if left alone. Still, patients and their physicians routinely attack small lump with biopsies, diagnostic work-ups and treatments that can be risky and debilitating.

Welch, who teaches community and family medicine at Dartmouth University’s Geisel School of Medicine, and his team tallied the number of breast cancer findings and the size of the tumors found in women over 40 who were diagnosed with breast cancer between 1975 and 1979, before screening mammography became widely available.

They compared those figures with breast cancer findings between 2000 and 2002, when screening was widespread.

For both groups, they tracked how women were treated and whether they were still alive 10 years after diagnosis.

The team observed that as more women got routine mammograms, more breast cancers were diagnosed. The additional cancers tended to be smaller, or to be confined to spaces, such as milk ducts, where they had not invaded normal tissue.

If catching tumors while they were still small were a way of nipping large, aggressive tumors in the bud, then widespread screening should have reduced the number of large tumors discovered on mammograms. But the rate at which large and aggressive tumors were found remained “essentially unchanged” between 1975 and 2010, the researchers found.

“The introduction of screening mammography has produced a mixture of effects,” the authors explained. To a modest extent, mammography screening was having the desired effect of finding dangerous tumors before they had grown large. For those women — estimated to be about 20 percent of those whose small tumors were detected by screening mammography — early treatment was potentially life-saving.

But the other 80 percent of women likely would not have died of breast cancer had their tumors never been detected in the first place.

Ironically, as mammography became more widespread and technically better, screening was doing a better and better job of finding these harmless tumors: while lumps smaller than 2 centimeters represented 37 percent of mammogram-detected abnormalities in the early years of the study, they represented 67 percent of a much larger pool by 2010.

By comparing changes in mortality rates over time for women diagnosed with tumors of various sizes, the researchers calculated that improvements in breast cancer therapy were responsible for at least two-thirds of the reduction in deaths, according to the study.

Welch acknowledged that the new findings will do little to clarify who should get mammograms, and how often.

But they should prompt patients and their doctors to consider that aggressive treatment of a small lump will not always lead to better health. Women should know that just as with prostate and lung cancer, deferring treatment until a tumor reveals its aggressive nature “is a choice,” he said.

And because small lumps are almost exclusively found on mammograms, the study is an important reminder that “indiscriminate testing can be a recipe for being made sick,” he added.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

83 arrested in Middletown warrant sweep
83 arrested in Middletown warrant sweep

More than 80 people were arrested today in Middletown when police and the Butler County Sheriff’s Office, assisted by U.S Marshals, conducted a warrant sweep throughout the city. Eighty-three people were arrested and 99 warrants were served, according to Middletown Police Chief Rodney Muterspaw. “We are really happy with the success of...
Social media reacts to news of Anthony Grant’s hiring at UD
Social media reacts to news of Anthony Grant’s hiring at UD

Just before noon on March 30, the University of Dayton announced Anthony Grant will be the new men’s basketball coach.  UD will hold a press conference on Saturday at 1 p.m. to formally announce the university’s 19th basketball coach.   The Flyers community took to social media after the news broke to express their thoughts...
NEW BEER: Sam Adams pays homage to Cincy with debut of ‘513’
NEW BEER: Sam Adams pays homage to Cincy with debut of ‘513’

The Samuel Adams brewery — which, despite its Boston-centric reputation, has multiple ties to Cincinnati — is poised to introduce its newest regional draft, the first-ever Cincinnati-inspired “Samuel Adams 513.” The new beer will be available on draft year-round, exclusively in Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky, according to a Samuel...
Miracle League opening day parade set for Saturday
Miracle League opening day parade set for Saturday

The Joe Nuxhall Miracle League will kick off its 2017 season with a parade, starting at Sacred Heart Church and ending at the fields on Groh Lane. The route kicks off at 10 a.m. and heads out Sacred Heart’s parking lot, crossing River Road and down Mississippi Drive. The parade then heads north on Groh Lane until it reaches the Miracle League...
Teen admits guilt in Middletown church arson
Teen admits guilt in Middletown church arson

A 16-year-old teen accused of setting fire to a Middletown church and vandalizing a gas station has admitted guilt in both crimes. The Middletown teen pleaded true, the equivalent of guilty in adult court, to vandalism and arson today in Butler County Juvenile Court. MORE: Facebook post led to arson arrest in Middletown church fire The boy was charged...
More Stories