Parenting with Dr. Ramey: What’s dangerous about the Golden Rule

The Golden Rule advising that you should behave towards others as you’d like to be treated seems reasonable — but in fact, represents a dangerous and wrong way of thinking about the world.

Lee Ross and his social psychology colleagues have called this blunder in thinking “naive realism.” Avoiding this error will make you a better parent and person.

More parenting with Dr. Ramey: Smart phones, problem kids?

The Golden Rule assumes everyone thinks, feels and behaves as you do. Naive realism reflects our tendency to think that our perceptions of the world are accurate and unbiased. If others think or feel otherwise, they are either ill-informed or prejudiced. If I was raised in a home with little praise and affection and turned out fine, I’m inclined to assume that approach would be best for everyone because it worked with me.

Naive realism is a powerful psychological blunder that affects our daily behavior. We tend to think that others are like us. We fail to realize that our view of the world is influenced by our values, feelings and previous experiences.

Here’s how this naive realism plays itself out in my office.

1. Kids with problems in social interactions. Children, particularly preteens, have a difficult time recognizing the diversity of thoughts and feelings. Kids who are bullies or have few friends are particularly susceptible to this thinking disorder. One preteen boy told me he routinely ridiculed a student because the boy wore clothes that "no normal kid should wear."

RELATED: 7 ways to connect with your child

I do lots of role-playing in my office. This exercise is excruciatingly difficult for children. Many cannot imagine that others may feel and think in different ways.

2. Parents and teens. If you want to be a better parent, recognize and fight against the error of naive realism with your teenager. Your young adult experiences the world in very different ways than you do. Your dismissive and sanctimonious attitude that such thinking is immature, illogical, biased, and unrealistic prevents you from understanding your child. Recognize that you (and your child) bring certain biases into any interaction that affect your communication.

In family sessions, I use a very simple technique. You can’t express your point of view until you can accurately summarize the thoughts and feelings of the other person.

Believing something doesn’t make it true. Our kids can be frustrating in their misperceptions, hasty judgments, and unrealistic expectations. It’s important for us to help kids recognize those errors, but we first must demonstrate an understanding of their viewpoint.

Maybe the Golden Rule needs to be updated in light of years of psychological research. Let’s behave towards others in a way that is compassionate and empowering, rather than simply reflects our biased perceptions.

Next week: A personality trait that is connected with significant mental problems.

Dr. Ramey is the Executive Director of Dayton Children’s Center for Pediatric Mental Health Resources and can be contacted at Rameyg@childrensdayton.org.

About the Author