Story highlights a painful choice for dog lovers


What do you say to people who subject helpless dogs to pain and death in the name of medical research? Do you say “stop it?” “Find another way?” “You’re horrible people?”

The question arises as a result a recent story in the (Cleveland) Plain Dealer about controversial animal testing practiced at Veterans Administration medical centers that “involve inflicting significant pain and distress” on dogs.

In a Richmond, Va., facility, the story reported, heart attacks are being induced in puppies. In a Cleveland VA center, 30 dogs were purchased in a year at a cost of $38,000. Twenty-seven of them wound up being killed in the experiments.

“They are wasting money on torturing dogs in experiments that are not helping anybody and are resisting being transparent about what they’re doing, why and what it costs,” declared an official of an organization that is urging Congress to defund the research on dogs; a bipartisan group in Congress supports the effort.

As a lover of virtually any dog that isn’t sinking its teeth into my leg, stories like that horrify me. I can’t even bear to watch those public service announcements that show sad-eyed puppies in cages that will have to be euthanized if they aren’t adopted. I actually had trouble getting past the first few paragraphs of that story when it appeared last week in the Dayton Daily News.

But I forced myself to read the rest of it.

“Cleveland’s experiments on dogs examine ways to prevent potentially fatal lung infections in veterans living with spinal cord injuries, paralysis from stroke, or amytrophic sclerosis (ALS),” a spokeswoman for the Northeast Ohio VA Healthcare System declared. Because those veterans have a weak cough, they can develop severe respiratory complications, leading to disability and death. She said the research requires “study of living animals in which the spinal cord is similar in size to a human spinal cord” and that “This means species other than canines (cute little mice, for instance) will not do.”

I don’t know enough about medical research to know if there is, perhaps, another way. And I can only assume that the researchers who say there isn’t an alternative aren’t horrible people and would take it if there were. Until there is an option, though, I have to accept that the current research is the only hope for easing the suffering or saving the life of a grandfather who is a Vietnam vet. A father who fought in Iraq. A son or daughter coming home from Afghanistan.

And if funding is, indeed, discontinued, what do you say to them?



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Stabbing victim flown to hospital; Springfield crews search for suspect
Stabbing victim flown to hospital; Springfield crews search for suspect

Springfield police are searching for a suspect after a man was stabbed in the chest, according to Springfield Sgt. Michael Curtis. Crews were dispatched to the 1100 block of Water Street around 11:40 p.m. Friday on a report of a stabbing.  Officers arrived to find the victim coherent and unable to recall the events leading up to the stabbing,...
Pennsylvania man accused of urinating on toys on store shelf
Pennsylvania man accused of urinating on toys on store shelf

A Pennsylvania man is accused of urinating on toys and other items in a store.  Police said David Pacoe, 74, was captured on surveillance video urinating on a shelf inside Playthings, Etc. in Butler on Nov. 2.  “It's not very nice at all and it's a toy store. You shouldn't have to worry about having security and guards or...
Ohio woman burned by coffee in break room spat
Ohio woman burned by coffee in break room spat

An Ohio woman suffered “significant burns” when another woman threw a cup of hot coffee on her in a break room at the YWCA, according to a Dayton Police report.  Officers and a medic were dispatched to the YWCA in Dayton at 5:25 p.m. Thursday on a report of an aggravated assault.  The two women involved in the altercation...
Louisiana veteran entertains motorists with saxophone
Louisiana veteran entertains motorists with saxophone

A Vietnam War veteran has become a fixture for music lovers in his Louisiana town. Donald Givens plays saxophone for several hours daily in his gazebo at his Monroe residence. His yard is located near the corner of two overpasses and commuters can listen to his daily jam sessions, the News-Star reported. Strangers pull up to his home and ask Givens...
One in critical condition as Dayton homicide detectives investigate shooting
One in critical condition as Dayton homicide detectives investigate shooting

A man is in critical condition following a shooting in Dayton Saturday morning, correcting earlier reports from dispatchers.  Dayton Lt. Steven Bauer told our crew police arrived on scene to find a male victim with several gunshot wounds.  Police said the unidentified victim suffered life-threatening injuries and was taken to Miami Valley...
More Stories