Court program makes women earn their second chance


The women lining the benches of Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Mary Wiseman’s courtroom all had drug offenses and were hoping for a second chance.

On this day most showed they were sticking to a program for recovery, but some of the others got an escort to jail.

They had failed drug tests, been caught with drugs, skipped rehab or otherwise failed to live up to the rules of Wiseman’s Women’s Therapeutic Court, a specialty docket for women who’ve pleaded guilty or been convicted of drug-related offenses.

“I’m going to take you into custody right now because you are in active addiction,” Wiseman told one woman. “I want to keep you alive.”

>>RELATED: Pregnant inmates have local jails scrambling to provide care

Another woman offered up excuses for why she was missing appointments and still smoking marijuana, telling Wiseman her life is stressful and smoking the occasional joint is no big deal.

Wiseman didn’t buy her story.

“If you think it’s hard to obey authority and keep appointments now, wait until you wake up in (prison) in Marysville,” she said. “If you get a felony you can talk to these (other) women about how hard it is to get a good job.”

To the ones who were doing well, Wiseman handed out praise and advice.

“Keep up the good work. You are doing great,” she told a 23-year-old pregnant woman who was successfully staying drug free.

>>RELATED: Women living with babies inside Ohio prison

The specialty docket, which the county began in 2014, provides an extra layer of support and treatment for drug addicted women who the court believes are amenable to help.

“If we can intercede and intervene on their substance abuse, then we can stop their ongoing process of criminal behavior,” Wiseman said. “What you see when you go to drug court is a massive cognitive behavioral program. It has rewards for positive behavior and consequences for bad behavior.”

Montomery County Common Pleas Court - criminal cases initiated - by gender 2012-2016

YearFemaleMaleUnknownTotal
2012 776 3,288 35 4,099
2013 861 3,375 28 4,264
2014 994 3,631 45 4,670
2015 1,019 3,303 44 4,366
2016 1,027 3,345 47 4,419

Source: Montgomery County Clerk of Courts

About 140 to 180 women are involved at any one time. The county has a separate drug court for men.

Women on Wiseman’s docket are required to go to therapy and rehab, submit to regular, random drug tests and are supervised by the probation department and caseworkers. Wiseman reviews their progress before each weekly session.

 >>RELATED: 5 things local leaders are doing to battle heroin and opioid addiction

Those who complete treatment, test negative for drugs for at least six months, have a job or a pending Social Security disability application, and have paid their fines get to graduate from the program. Some are rewarded with expungement of their felony convictions, while others get to stay out of jail and be freed of supervision by the criminal justice system.

“We believe that our recidivism rate is better than the general (court) population and our ability to keep people clean and sober is better than the general population,” Wiseman said. “I am 100 percent convinced this is where the rubber meets the road and we are changing lives and getting people out of addiction and into sustained recovery.”

>>RELATED: Mom feels blessed to have her child with her in prison

>>RELATED: More potent drugs raise stakes in Ohio’s fight against opioids

>>RELATED: Opioid crisis persists despite funding burst

ABOUT THIS PROJECT: See our story about the impact of rising numbers of incarcerated women, some pregnant and addicted to drugs, on Ohio’s county jails and prison system.  And some women are raising their young children in prison.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Cold morning, but temps in 40s expected this weekend
Cold morning, but temps in 40s expected this weekend

QUICK-LOOK FORECAST Cold, dry morning Warming up into the weekend Rain showers by Sunday Today: It will be a quiet and cold morning, said Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Kirstie Zontini. Most will start off in the upper single digits. It will be a nice afternoon with sunshine and temperatures around 30, which is closer to normal. ...
Driver backs into Dayton police cruiser 
Driver backs into Dayton police cruiser 

A driver was ticketed after backing their car into a Dayton police cruiser early Thursday morning. The crash happened around 2:15 a.m. on Watervliet Avenue near Smithville Road.  A witness told our crew that a passenger got out of a black car and started walking away. The driver put the car in reverse and backed up in an attempt to get his passenger...
Another meteor? Reports come in of bright flash across Ohio, Ind. night sky
Another meteor? Reports come in of bright flash across Ohio, Ind. night sky

Another meteor may have lit up the sky late Wednesday night. Several reports have come into our newsroom of a bright flash that shot across the sky just before midnight. People from Englewood, Marysville and Randolph County, Ind. have said they saw the bright flash, with some saying it was bright blue or blue/green. The American Meteor Society received...
Dayton traffic from the WHIO traffic center
Dayton traffic from the WHIO traffic center

Traffic issues can be reported by calling our newsroom at 937-259-2237 or tweeting @WHIOTraffic . Traffic conditions are updated every six minutes on AM 1290 and News 95.7 FM. No incidents to report No incidents to report Ongoing Construction & Other Closures  Live look at highways on our traffic cameras here. Latest...
Good Samaritan Hospital closing: Community angry, devastated, concerned
Good Samaritan Hospital closing: Community angry, devastated, concerned

The closing of Good Samaritan Hospital will be a crippling blow to the west Dayton community and raises several concerns going forward, said three people who represent the hundreds of residents living near the 86-year-old facility.  "We're behind the eight ball," Minister Daria Dillard Stone, 66 and a member of the Mount Carmel Missionary...
More Stories