Dayton man sentenced to 25 years in double homicide

A Dayton man was sentenced to 25 years in prison after being convicted of involuntary manslaughter and other charges in connection with a double homicide in November 2016.

Davion L. Lyons, 26, had been indicted on six counts of aggravated murder among 24 total counts in the Nov. 29, 2016 shooting deaths of John Dixon, 40, and Donald Nesbit, 56, in a Victor Ave. residence.

On Nov. 1, 2017, Lyons and prosecutors reached a plea deal in which he pleaded guilty to aggravated robbery, felonious assault and two counts of involuntary manslaughter. The other counts were dismissed, according to court records.

Al Law, Nesbit’s nephew, called Lyons’ involvement a “hideous, heartless act of double homicide.”

RELATED: Plea deal reached in double homicide case

Law asked that Lyons someday apologize to the victims, including Dixon’s “children, who hid as the very gunshots they heard killed their precious father.”

Dixon’s ex-wife, Olivia Key, and wife, Natalie Deselms, both made statements to Montgomery County Common Pleas Court Judge Barbara Gorman.

“Every morning, when they wake up, they know that they’re not going to hear his voice,” said Key, who shared four children with Dixon during their 17-year marriage. “They know that they can’t call him on the phone.”

Deselms, who had two children with Dixon in eight years together, held a picture of Dixon and told Lyons, “You came in my house and you took mine. You took mine away from me. Look at it. Look.

“Do you see that? Do you know what you’ve done to those kids right there? That little boy, he made it to the kitchen to see his dad on the floor.”

SOCIAL MEDIA: Follow Mark Gokavi on Twitter or Facebook

Deselms told Lyons, “Six children don’t get to hug their dad on Christmas. They don’t get to call their dad on his birthday.”

Given a chance to address the court, Lyons said, “With all due respect to the victims’ families, I’m not unsympathetic. I’m not standing here like I just don’t care.

“But since Day 1, I said I didn’t do this. Whatever closure that brings, what justice that brings, I don’t know, but the person that really did this is still out there. That’s all I’ve got to say.”

Gorman sentenced Lyons to 11 years apiece on the involuntary manslaughter counts and three years for firearm specifications for 25 years total. The other counts of aggravated robbery (11 years) and felonious assault (8 years) were to run concurrently to the manslaughter counts.

Lyons earned 335 days of jail-time credit. He also was ordered to pay restitution of $7,780.28 for Dixon’s funeral costs and $6,000 for Nesbit’s funeral costs.

MORE: Read other stories from Mark Gokavi

“To stand here today after listening to the victims’ family and say you didn’t do it, is a total act of cowardice,” Gorman said. “Think about that while you’re in prison.”

A second suspect, Lavelle Broadnax, aka Ryan Keith Thompson-Curry, was arrested in connection with the double homicide, but was released from jail. The Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office said there was insufficient evidence to charge Broadnax.

Dayton Police Lt. Andrew Gillig said after the shooting that a woman also was shot during the incident and transported to Miami Valley Hospital.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Local state House seat drawing lots of candidates for competitive district
Local state House seat drawing lots of candidates for competitive district

The Dayton region’s most competitively balanced Ohio House district is getting plenty of attention with the filing deadline less than three weeks away. Republican Clayton Councilman Kenny Henning on Friday formally announced he is running for the 43rd House District seat, which is split almost 50-50 between Democrats and Republicans. “I...
The CUTEST birthday party of the year features Fiona the Hippo
The CUTEST birthday party of the year features Fiona the Hippo

The Cincinnati Zoo has unveiled how it will celebrate a big birthday for its famous hippo, Fiona, who turns 1 on Jan. 24. The zoo isn’t waiting until then to start the celebration, as the public can attend a huge event from 10 a.m. until 3 p.m. tomorrow (Saturday, Jan. 20). From authors who have penned books on Fiona to caretakers who have watched...
Paralyzed woman: Life ‘a living hell’ without stolen van
Paralyzed woman: Life ‘a living hell’ without stolen van

For the last two weeks, a paralyzed Middletown woman has been without the van that used to drive her to doctor appointments. Shirley English, 77, paralyzed from the waist down after an auto accident in 2007, said her 2003 tan Dodge Caravan was stolen from her residence on Crawford Street earlier this month. English said she allowed a former homeless...
Higher water, sewer rates in effect for Montgomery County customers
Higher water, sewer rates in effect for Montgomery County customers

Customers who receive water and sewer services through Montgomery County can expect to see rate increases reflected in their first bills of the year. The county announced in November that the combined water and sewer rate would go up by about an average of 14 percent this year. Rates will jump another 5.6 percent on average starting in 2019 and each...
Flu virus spread by breathing, study finds
Flu virus spread by breathing, study finds

Most people believe that the influenza virus is spread through the coughs and sneezes of infected people, but new research published Thursday suggests that the flu virus is spread more easily than previously thought. Medical professionals believe that the virus is spread most often by “droplets made when people with flu cough, sneeze or talk...
More Stories