Pike County murders: ‘There will always be a scar on this town’


Highlights

Eight people connected to the Rhoden family were murdered in Pike County on April 22, 2016.

Things are quiet in Pike County nearly a year later, with some signs indicating an investigation continues.

Gone are the hazmat suits, police cars, helicopters and mobile home crime scenes. Now, silence surrounds the sites of the Pike County murders — until the crows call overhead.

It’s noon and nearly a year after the eight-person massacre. Occasionally, a pickup truck catches gravel and spits it to the side of Union Hill Road, where seven of the deceased were found in three homes. A metal mailbox in the shade of blooming redbud trees bears the name of a lost family: Rhoden.

Their voices cannot be heard, but their faces are everywhere.

Nailed into the tree outside the home of a still-grieving father, posted on the church bulletin board opposite the Ten Commandments, and spread high on a billboard above the Pike County Sheriff’s Office, reward posters with eight faces each beg an unanswered question.

“Do you know who murdered us on April 22, 2016?”

MORE ON PIKE COUNTY
» DeWine says case remains priority
» Watch: A year in Pike County, from murders to community grief to rebuilding
» Pike County shooting victims: A closer look at the 8 who died

The posters bear a tip line number checked each morning by Sheriff Charles Reader, and they boast a modest reward of $10,000 — just less than $1,500 per person killed. By way of comparison, the reward for the so-called Facebook Live killer this week in Cleveland exceeded $50,000.

Had the Pike County executions been a few hundred yards west, they’d be the concern of the Adams or Scioto County sheriffs. But now, the deaths on Union Hill Road and nearby Left Fork Road haunt Reader daily.

“I see the look of disappointment when I speak with the family, and I look into their eyes and the grieving they still have,” Reader said at a recent media availability with Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine.

He wishes there will one day be a press conference to announce the arrest, but for now he begs for would-be tipsters to come forward.

Reader’s deputies and the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation tracked down more than 800 tips in the 12 months since the execution-style shootings.

NEWS HOW YOU WANT IT
» REAL-TIME ALERTS: Download our free apps for breaking news
» IN YOUR INBOX: Sign up for email newsletters on topics you love

The continuing hunt for answers is referred to by the local newspaper, the News Watchman, as the “Rhoden/Gilley” investigation. It’s a reference to Hannah Gilley, the 20-year-old fiancee of Frankie Rhoden, who also died at that age.

Stephanie Stanley, the paper’s assistant editor, said the small newsroom does its best to keep residents updated.

“I know that people are anxious to hear who did it,” Stanley said, “to have that come through on the front page headline and have it over with and out of their lives.”

Because of the marijuana found at the scenes, many here still believe the cartel is behind the deaths, while others are confident locals among them fired the shots. No one — including investigators, apparently — knows for sure.

Spared from the slaughter were three children and the Rhoden family dogs. Christopher Sr., 40, Christopher Jr., 16, Dana, 37, Gary, 38, Hanna, 19, and Kenneth, 44, also died in what became Ohio’s largest criminal investigation.

One of the new reward posters appeared this week on the door of the Riverside Restaurant. It’s Sloppy Joe’s day at the Piketon eatery, where opinions are mixed on if the case will ever be solved.

“People don’t talk about it anymore because it was so sad,” said a woman tending a dish of cottage cheese. Added another patron, fighting to be heard over a loud television, “If you knew somebody killed somebody, why wouldn’t you say something?”

MORE ON PIKE COUNTY
» Timeline: The shocking events of the Pike County shooting
» Photos: Scenes from Pike County six months after a massacre
» DeWine on Pike Co. shootings: Someone involved ‘knew the territory’
» Ohio covers funeral costs for Pike County murder victims

Though the killer or killers remain at large, people in Piketon are walking down the sidewalk and sitting on their porches again, said Morty Throckmorton, who manages the Smart Mart store.

She sells the “unique and unusual” — overstock furniture, some hardware and infomercial-type products from the likes of J.C. Penney, Sears and QVC. It’s one of a handful of stores in Piketon, and about sixty percent of her business is layaway.

“I wouldn’t want to meet my maker that way,” she said of the killings, pausing to tell a father and son she just sold the last tap and die set. Another shipment might come soon, she said, resuming her thoughts:

“There will always be a scar on this town.”

» HAVE A NEWS TIP? Contact our 24-hour line at 937-259-2237 or newsdesk@cmgohio.com

NewsCenter 7’s Jim Otte contributed reporting.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Site selection called ‘monumental step’ in schools proposal
Site selection called ‘monumental step’ in schools proposal

The Troy City Schools Board of Education’s agreement to purchase land just west of the city limits for a proposed elementary schools complex was called a “monumental step forward” by Doug Trostle, board president. The purchase of 58.67 acres off Ohio 55 and Nashville Road in Concord Twp., OK’d by the board Aug. 14, was contingent...
Superintendent finds home away from home
Superintendent finds home away from home

As Brad Ritchey explored school superintendent job options in 2016, he was hoping to find something that would remind him of home. “I was interested in being someplace where you could wrap your arms around a district. It was someplace where you are one of the crowd and have a fighting chance of getting to know people,” he said. He thinks...
Don’t boil tomatoes alive. Water early or late in the day
Don’t boil tomatoes alive. Water early or late in the day

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — This tomato plant was a goner. Thinking I was helping, I only hastened its rapid demise. How? I watered in the late afternoon. It was a hard lesson on “proper irrigation.” During a recent triple-digit heat wave, this particular tomato vine wilted badly. On an after-work visit to my community garden plot, I was...
Here’s a quick upgrade for your kitchen
Here’s a quick upgrade for your kitchen

Q: Dear Ed: I enjoyed your recent column about installing an air freshener toilet seat for a quick bathroom upgrade. But what about the kitchen? I think we would all enjoy your advice for a quick kitchen upgrade as well. — Beth, Michigan A: Plumbing accessories for the bathroom and kitchen are a hot topic, so there’s no shortage of ideas...
Home has plenty of room for the kids AND an outdoorsy collection
Home has plenty of room for the kids AND an outdoorsy collection

SEATTLE — And now, A Western folk ode to some newish Western folks: OH, GIVE ME A HOME … The first space Steven Rinella and Katie Finch shared didn’t have much space at all: an 800-square-foot apartment in Brooklyn, outfitted with “hand-me-down furniture, from stoop sales,” Finch says. Her job with Amazon blazed their...
More Stories