Read a local judge’s plea for leniency for Brock Turner

Local judge: ‘I believe a prison term will serve no useful purpose in Brock’s case’


Oakwood Municipal Court Judge Margaret Quinn is one of several area leaders and residents who wrote letters to Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Aaron Persky pleading for leniency in the sentencing of Brock Turner, a former Oakwood swimmer convicted of sexually assaulting a woman at Stanford University in California.

Here is Quinn’s full letter:

Dear Judge Persky,

April 28, 2016

As I know many others have, I am writing to you concerning the upcoming sentencing of nineteen-year old Brock Turner from Dayton, Ohio. I have known Brock’s parents, Dan and Carleen Turner, and their three children Brent, Caroline, and Brock, for the past fifteen years through Holy Angels parish organizations, through our childrens’ elementary and high school activities, and as neighbors.

I am a retired federal prosecutor, mom of five and foster mom to many. Since my retirement I have been involved in programs which assist felons in the very difficult task of reintegration. As I know you are aware, the collateral consequences of a conviction are staggering. The immediate consequences of Brock’s convictions go far beyond expulsion from Stanford or loss of a swimming scholarship. While shameful to a nineteen-year-old freshman, those consequences pale when measured against the requirement of continued registration as a sex offender, or the very limited job opportunities that will be available to Brock.

It is evident, especially within the last few years, that sexual misconduct is a growing concern on college campuses; it is a very real problem. This rising concern has encouraged many college campuses to put sexual misconduct at the forefront of the discussion table. More and more universities are implementing mandatory workshops aimed at educating incoming freshman on the importance of consensual sex, effective communication between partners, healthy relationships, and safe drinking practices on college campuses. These educational programs for incoming students are effective; a comprehensive approach to educating students on the dangers of excessive alcohol consumption and sexual misconduct is the most effective way to combat these issues that are all too relevant on college campuses.

If the Court saw fit, perhaps Brock could better serve his future development and that of other young men, in counselling them, speaking to them, warning them about the devastating consequences of a single decision. Brock could have the unique opportunity to mentor students on this complex issue that young people from all over the country will undoubtedly face in their lifetime.

I met with Brock and his family last week. They are devastated. Brock himself is despondent; he is broken. There is no doubt Brock made a mistake that night — he made a mistake in drinking excessively to the point where he could not fully appreciate that his female acquaintance was so intoxicated. I know Brock did not go to that party intending to hurt, or entice, or overpower anyone. That is not his nature. It never has been. This unfortunate series of events has left Brock in despair. Rather than strip him of any chance to rectify this situation, I hope his punishment enables him to educate young people on the importance of safe alcohol consumption, and effective communication between two consenting individuals.

I believe a prison term will serve no useful purpose in Brock’s case. He is forever changed by the events of that night. Judge please consider other options to prison — options which will serve the purpose for which a sentence is imposed, and options which will leave a future for this very scared young man. Probation could include heavy reporting requirements, counselling, community service in multiple ways, including speaking out about the dangers of excessive alcohol consumption, college partying, and the “hook-up” culture on college campuses throughout the United States.

I ask the Court to consider Brock’s future, or lack thereof, when implementing his sentence. I wholeheartedly believe that good can come from this unfortunate chain of events by salvaging Brock’s future and allowing him to mentor other young people in promoting a culture of responsible drinking practices, effective communication, and overall safety on college campuses.

Thank you Judge, for your consideration.

Sincerely,

Margaret M. Quinn, Esq.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Police: Florida woman kills husband, hides his duct taped body in closet
Police: Florida woman kills husband, hides his duct taped body in closet

A 65-year-old Florida woman was arrested and accused of murdering her husband and then hiding his duct-taped body behind a brick wall she built inside a closet.  Barbara Wozniak, of Shalimar, was charged with second-degree murder Friday night while she was already in the Okaloosa County jail on another charge of tampering with evidence...
5 things to know about Middletown’s holiday drive-through display
5 things to know about Middletown’s holiday drive-through display

Here are five things to know about Light Up Middletown at Smith Park in Middletown: 1. Hours of operation The 19th Light Up Middletown is open from 6 to 10 p.m. every night from Thanksgiving through New Year’s Eve. RELATED: Light Up Middletown adds more attractions for its 19th season 2. What to expect...
‘Cosby Show’ actor Earle Hyman dead at 91
‘Cosby Show’ actor Earle Hyman dead at 91

Earle Hyman, the actor best known for playing Russell Huxtable, Bill Cosby’s wise father on “The Cosby Show,” died Friday. He was 91. Hyman died at the Lillian Booth Actors Home in Englewood, N.J., his nephew, Rick Ferguson, told The Hollywood Reporter. Hyman played Othello on stage, was a regular on Broadway and received a Tony...
Foo Fighters, Guns N’ Roses pay tribute to AC/DC’s Malcolm Young
Foo Fighters, Guns N’ Roses pay tribute to AC/DC’s Malcolm Young

The Foo Fighters and Guns N’ Roses paid tribute to Malcolm Young, the AC/DC rhythm guitarist who died Saturday at age 64. Both bands dedicated songs during their respective concerts to Young, who died three years after being diagnosed with dementia. The Foo Fighters opened its concert in Mexico City’s Corona Capital Festival with a blistering...
German Christmas market coming to Hamilton
German Christmas market coming to Hamilton

Hamilton’s Christkindlmarkt is an authentic German Christmas market held Dec. 1-3 at Courtyard by Marriott, 1 Riverfront Plaza. Hours are from 6 to 10 p.m. Dec. 1, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Dec. 2, and 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. Dec. 3. MORE: There’s plenty of local holiday events to fill your calendar. Find more here The Christkindlmarkt follows in the...
More Stories