Tape of Bellefontaine mom’s alleged confession shown in court


A taped police interview where a Bellefontaine mother allegedly confesses to killing her sons was shown in open court Tuesday for the first time since her arrest last year.

The video was shown in a Logan County Common Pleas Court as part of a hearing to consider the defense’s motion to throw out Brittany Pilkington’s alleged confession.

Pilkington, 24, has pleaded not guilty to three counts of aggravated murder in the deaths of her three sons over 13 months and faces the death penalty.

>>MORE DETAILS: Abuse, isolation alleged in Bellefontaine case

The three Pilkington boys died within 13 months of each other. Infant Niall died in July 2014, 4-year-old Gavin Pilkington in April of last year, and then 3-month-old Noah four months later in August 2015.

Logan County Common Pleas Court Judge Mark O’Connor reviewed Tuesday a two-hour long, video-taped interview with Pilkington at the Bellefontaine Police Division. It was recorded on Aug. 18, 2015, just hours after Noah’s death.

In the tape, she could be heard telling police she was sleeping with Niall in her bed and she woke up on top of him. She also could be heard saying she held a blanket over Gavin’s face.

A second interview at the Logan County Sheriff’s Office recorded the same day will be reviewed when the hearing resumes on Wednesday.

>>RELATED: Bellefontaine mom charged with killing 3 sons not opposed to testing

The tape should be excluded from the trial for several reasons, Pilkington’s lawyer Marc Triplett said.

Police pressured Pilkington into the confession, Triplett told the judge, and violated her 5th and 14th Amendment rights in the process.

“They knew her lack of mental acuity,” Triplett said.

Bellefontaine police followed the law advising Pilkington of what was happening at the police station during the interview, Assistant Logan County Prosecutor Eric Stewart said.

“It was not coerced,” he said.

The trial is scheduled to start Feb. 27, 2017.

The motion to exclude the taped interview is one of several the judge will decide on before the trial begins. Other motions from Pilkington’s lawyers include a request to remove the death penalty, to sever the charges and hold three separate trials, and to move the trial out of Logan County, according to court records.

>>LEARN MORE: Donated stone marks graves of 3 Bellefontaine boys

Brittany Pilkington’s husband, Joseph Pilkington, was charged with felony sexual battery and arrested in September 2015 for allegedly starting a sexual relationship with then Brittany Cummins while she was a minor and he was a step-father figure living in her home.

He pleaded guilty earlier this year to a lesser, misdemeanor charge of sexual imposition, according to Logan County court records. He must register as a Tier One sex offender for 15 years and he received no jail time as part of his sentencing.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

New assistant city manager makes leap
New assistant city manager makes leap

The city’s new assistant city manager already is a familiar face in the local government. Amber Holloway assumed her new duties Jan. 2 following the departure of Greg Shackelford. She previously was employed as the Vandalia city planner since March 2015. ››RELATED: Nonprofit’s new leader likes community spirit...
With no deal on shutdown, GOP accuses Sherrod Brown of flip-flop
With no deal on shutdown, GOP accuses Sherrod Brown of flip-flop

As a possible shutdown grew nearer on Friday, Republicans took aim at Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, accusing him of a flip-flop over a temporary measure to keep the government open for four weeks. Brown on Thursday appeared set to back the Republican-backed four-week plan because it extended a program known as CHIP that provides health insurance for...
White supremacists responsible for most extremist killings in 2017, ADL says
White supremacists responsible for most extremist killings in 2017, ADL says

Far-right extremists – particularly white supremacists – were responsible for more than half of the deaths attributed to extremists in the United States last year, according to a report issued this week by the Anti-Defamation League. Twenty of the 34 extremist-related killings in 2017 were carried out by far-right extremists, more than...
Local state House seat drawing lots of candidates for competitive district
Local state House seat drawing lots of candidates for competitive district

The Dayton region’s most competitively balanced Ohio House district is getting plenty of attention with the filing deadline less than three weeks away. Republican Clayton Councilman Kenny Henning on Friday formally announced he is running for the 43rd House District seat, which is split almost 50-50 between Democrats and Republicans. “I...
The CUTEST birthday party of the year features Fiona the Hippo
The CUTEST birthday party of the year features Fiona the Hippo

The Cincinnati Zoo has unveiled how it will celebrate a big birthday for its famous hippo, Fiona, who turns 1 on Jan. 24. The zoo isn’t waiting until then to start the celebration, as the public can attend a huge event from 10 a.m. until 3 p.m. tomorrow (Saturday, Jan. 20). From authors who have penned books on Fiona to caretakers who have watched...
More Stories