Dayton school board struggles with division, confusion

Board just gave administrator $200K to leave, dealt with chanting crowds fighting layoffs and confusion over votes.

Dayton’s school board has had many heated and confusing meetings in the past year — with chanting crowds opposing layoffs, uncertainty over proper procedure, plus outbursts and arguments between audience members and the board.

Tuesday night’s meeting debate over administrator David Lawrence’s resignation illustrated the sideshow-like feel that some meetings of Dayton’s divided board have taken on.

RELATED: School board gives administrator $200K to walk away

The school board first argued Tuesday over whether they should even vote on the Lawrence settlement, which had been the subject of numerous executive sessions in recent months, resulting in an agreement that Lawrence had signed two days earlier.

Once they decided to proceed, the board didn’t realize where Lawrence’s resignation was on the agenda, coming seconds away from approving it unnoticed as part of a larger human resources agenda.


Tests are free, but controversy swirls over ACT/SAT plan

Dispose of a body? Sure if it cancels my student debt

Cursive handwriting could be required for Ohio students again

After they caught the issue, they withdrew their original motion, and began a long, emotional disagreement on the Lawrence settlement.

That discussion violated the very first numbered item of the six-page Lawrence settlement, which says, “Employee’s letter of resignation shall be accepted by the Board, without public comment, at its next regular meeting …”

“This (division) has been a characteristic of this board for the last two years,” board President Robert Walker said Wednesday. “I think that’s one of the shortcomings we try to overcome. As much as we’re there to work as a collective (for the community), we’re still learning how to do that.”

RELATED: Chanting crowd gets impatient with school board

Lawrence was not at the meeting, but at one point while the board was bickering over his future, local activist David Esrati was on his cell phone with Lawrence, streaming video of the meeting to him, while urging Lawrence to be quiet so the board couldn’t hear him.

Esrati interrupted the board with multiple complaints from his seat in the audience, until DPS assistant security chief Richard Wright confronted him and asked him to remain under control.

Even before the Lawrence debate, there were problems at Tuesday’s meeting. Board President Robert Walker misunderstood the vote on a teacher resignation and had to rescind and reverse his vote — the second time that happened to a board member in the past month.

“We just need to become more familiar with our agenda before it comes to the board,” Walker said. “Part of it is we’re still trying to work out a rhythm to get info to board members, so we can be fully aware of what we’re going to be asked to act on, with advance notice.”

Immediately after Walker’s reversal, the board was confused about the vote on another teacher resignation. Board member Adil Baguirov explained that a “no” vote meant the board would not release the teacher’s license to the state or another district.

RELATED: DPS board meeting gets heated over police, racial issues

But the teacher in question had just explained to the board moments earlier that she didn’t have a license at all. Board member John McManus eventually asked district attorney Jyllian Bradshaw for clarification, and she explained that the license wasn’t at issue at all.

Shortly after that vote, Dayton teachers union president David Romick left the meeting shaking his head, saying he would watch the rest of the proceedings on TV.

“We have to strengthen our meeting process so we provide a more cogent message to the public,” Walker said.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

A return of flying sergeants? Air Force says no despite too few pilots
A return of flying sergeants? Air Force says no despite too few pilots

The Air Force will launch a high-tech training experiment testing both officers and enlisted airmen to prepare pilots for the cockpit faster. But, despite a growing shortage of aviators, it won’t be a return to the wartime days of flying sergeants – at least for now, according to the Air Force. The six-month initiative at a military reserve...
Babies evacuated after smoke reported at Miami Valley Hospital
Babies evacuated after smoke reported at Miami Valley Hospital

Several babies had to be relocated at Miami Valley Hospital after an overheated motor generated smoke. Dayton District Fire Chief James Rose said nine or 10 babies in the Berry Women’s Center were moved to another part of the hospital due to smoke. He said most of the smoke was was contained and did not make it into the air handling system for...
Snakes die as a result of Englewood garage fire
Snakes die as a result of Englewood garage fire

Snakes are among the animals that died after a garage fire occurred in Englewood early Monday morning. Crews responded to the 4500 block of Roblar Hills Drive around 1 a.m. on a fully involved detached garage fire, per initial reports. The garage, which was used as a work station, had animals, a vehicle, and propane tanks inside, which were all lost...
WPAFB Monday Weather: Possible afternoon shower, snow to move into Tuesday
WPAFB Monday Weather: Possible afternoon shower, snow to move into Tuesday

WRIGHT PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE—More clouds are expected on Monday, and while it will be a notch warmer, it’s still going to be below the normal high for this time of the year, according to Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Brett Collar. We’ll see highs in the upper 30s. Some models hint at a passing light shower north of I-70 this afternoon...
‘Miracle baby’ takes first steps after surviving double-fatal crash
‘Miracle baby’ takes first steps after surviving double-fatal crash

A 14-month-old, the lone survivor of a crash that killed two family members, escaped the wreckage with only a few scrapes. The baby, Harlyn, was in her car seat when a pickup truck went off State Route 380, flipped, and slammed into a tree on a local campground. Her grandfather, 49-year-old Carl Perry and great grandmother, 73-year-old Linda Davis...
More Stories