You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myDaytonDailyNews.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myDaytonDailyNews.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myDaytonDailyNews.com.

With few options, U.S. doesn't rule out talks with North Korea


North Korea may have refrained from detonating a nuclear device and botched another missile test this weekend, easing tensions in Asia. But it is unclear whether President Donald Trump has found a way around the limited options against North Korea that constrained his predecessors and put it on the path to becoming a nuclear power.  

Trump essentially has three choices: a military strike that could ignite a full-blown war; pressure on China to impose tougher sanctions to persuade the North to change course, an approach that failed for his predecessors; or a deal that could require significant concessions, with no guarantee that North Korea would fulfill its promises. 

 Thus far, Trump has tried to signal both resolve and ambiguity, suggesting at various times that he is open to all three options. The question is whether his apparent willingness to consider both war and a deal may be enough carrot and stick to persuade China to change its approach and apply enough pressure to bring the North to the table. 

 Pence calls for ‘peaceable means, through negotiations’

Vice President Mike Pence, during a visit to South Korea, raised the possibility Monday that the Trump administration could pursue talks. No one should mistake the U.S. resolve, he said, also noting that Washington was seeking security “through peaceable means, through negotiations.” The phrasing was unusual for a senior U.S. official discussing the Korean Peninsula with U.S. troops in the background. 

 Talks have long been China’s preference, and now that Trump seems to be relying on Beijing to an unprecedented degree, Pence may have been signaling that the United States was open to negotiations. China’s chief objective is to get talks — of any kind — started to avoid conflict so close to home. 

China’s nightmare

War on the peninsula is a nightmare for China that could lead to at least 1 million casualties, according to some estimates, ravage North and South Korea and set back Beijing’s climb to global pre-eminence. 

 In his most flexible language yet, China’s foreign minister, Wang Yi, appealed again Friday for negotiations. 

 “As long as it is a talk, China is willing to support it: either it is formal or informal, one-track or dual-track, bilateral, trilateral or quadrilateral,” Wang said in Beijing. “We are also willing to stay open-minded and accept the good advice from others.”  

North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong Un, already has enough fissile material for 20 to 25 nuclear weapons and may be able to produce sufficient fissile materials — plutonium and highly enriched uranium — for six to seven new weapons a year, according to Siegfried S. Hecker, a former director of the Los Alamos National Laboratory. 

Concerns about a ‘nuclear catastrophe’

Should the North conduct its sixth nuclear test, it would move closer to having a hydrogen bomb, or a two-stage thermonuclear weapon, Hecker said, with up to 1,000 times more power than the Hiroshima-style weapons that Kim has detonated so far.  

With that level of firepower, Hecker said he worried about a “nuclear catastrophe” on the peninsula resulting from either “escalation of military activities” or poor security around the North’s nuclear arsenal. Talks are needed immediately, he said, just to deal with the immediate threat to Japan and South Korea, both U.S. allies.  

The logic for diplomacy should be compelling to the Trump administration, Chinese experts say, even as Washington stakes out a policy of “maximum pressure” and has deployed a naval flotilla led by the aircraft carrier Carl Vinson to the coast of the Korean Peninsula. 

 China’s peace proposal

In a formal proposal last month, China said that talks should be framed on the basis of North Korea suspending its nuclear testing, and the United States and South Korea suspending their military exercises off the peninsula.  

Such suggestions were a non-starter for the Obama administration, which insisted that Pyongyang had to give up its weapons first, and the conditions, as proposed by Wang last month, were immediately rejected by senior Trump administration officials.  

Washington needs to understand North Korea’s point of view, argues China, which fought on the North’s side against the United States during the Korean War, losing an estimated 300,000 soldiers. 

 30,000 U.S. troops in S. Korea

As nearly 30,000 U.S. troops are stationed in South Korea and frequent U.S. military exercises occur on land and at sea, North Korea has complained that it is threatened by a “ring of American fire.” The United States is still technically at war with the North because a peace treaty was never signed at the end of the Korean War in 1953.  

A major purpose of any new diplomacy would be to halt the North’s nuclear program. The longer the country is allowed to test its weapons, the more lethal they become. Capping the arsenal at its current stage is one of the more palatable among several unpalatable options, U.S. and Chinese experts say.  

The North’s freedom to conduct underground tests gives it the chance to significantly improve its weapons by using less fissile material per weapon and producing greater explosive yields, said David Albright, a physicist who oversees the Institute for Science and International Security in Washington. 

 Clear and present danger

For Trump — and China and its neighbors — this means a much graver threat than the Obama or Bush administrations faced, Hecker wrote in The New York Times in January.  

“Pyongyang can most likely already reach all of South Korea, Japan and possibly even some United States targets in the Pacific” with its nuclear weapons, he wrote.   

“Today the most important point is to avoid the use or detonation of a nuclear device on the Korean Peninsula,” he said this weekend as the world waited to see whether the North would detonate a weapon. “Any use of nuclear devices of any sort on the Korean Peninsula is what I call nuclear catastrophe.” 

Tillerson says it’s time to act

 During a visit to South Korea last month, Secretary of State Rex W. Tillerson rejected China’s push for talks as a way of buying time to halt North Korea’s testing program. Negotiations could begin only after the North gave up its weapons, Tillerson said, a condition that Pence did not mention Monday. 

Chinese experts say they detect an opening for negotiations. 

 “Mr. Trump said something interesting during his campaign — that if necessary he could meet with Kim Jong Un and have a sandwich with him,” said Yang Xiyu, a former diplomat from China who led his country’s delegation to the so-called six-party talks on North Korea in the mid-2000s. “We can see that as a shortcut to solve the issue in a peaceful manner.” 

The idea of a Trump-Kim summit 

The idea of a meeting between Trump and Kim, who has been treated with obvious disdain by Xi Jinping, China’s president, is not so far-fetched, Yang said. 

 Before Kim came to power in 2011, North Korea participated in the six-party talks with China and the United States, but the North always sent an official who lacked the power to decide on substantive issues. 

 Now was the time to remove that obstacle and go to Kim directly, Yang said.  

“There is only one person who has the authority to make a fundamental decision — yes or no — and that’s Kim,” Yang said. “China can facilitate a three-way dialogue among the top leaders of China, North Korea and the United States so we can at least try the shortcut.” 

Can Kim really be persuaded?

Kim would have to be persuaded that the United States would not attack the North if he gave up his weapons, Yang said. The fate of the Libyan leader, Col. Moammar Gadhafi, who was driven from power and then killed after he gave up the components of his nuclear weapons program, was foremost in Kim’s mind, Yang said. 

 Robert Carlin, a U.S. expert who served in the Clinton administration and favors talks as a way to control the North’s weapons development, contends that negotiations based on the premise of the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula are possible. 

 In 2016, North Korea’s official spokesman, one of the “highest on the North’s ladder of authority,” spoke of denuclearization as “the steadfast will of our party, army and people,” Carlin wrote in suggesting that the opening should be seized.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

JobsOhio ad mistakenly claims John Glenn ‘orbited the moon’
JobsOhio ad mistakenly claims John Glenn ‘orbited the moon’

The state’s JobsOhio program bought a full-page advertisement in The Economist magazine that included a mistake stating former astronaut John Glenn orbited the moon According to Cleveland.com, the insert touting the state’s private economic development program mistakenly touted, “From the Wright brothers inventing powered flight...
Ohio sues to recoup $604K it spent on tainted Enon water cleanup
Ohio sues to recoup $604K it spent on tainted Enon water cleanup

The Ohio Attorney General’s Office has sued the owner of a manufacturing plant’s estate to recoup more than $604,000 it spent cleaning up contamination that got into the village of Enon’s drinking water source more than 20 years ago. The Ohio Environmental Protection Agency spent the money to oversee and supervise the cleanup of the...
Warren County arts community vote settles zoning case
Warren County arts community vote settles zoning case

When Warren County commissioners approved rezoning 20 acres for a proposed arts community, they also ended a zoning violation case. On Tuesday, commissioners approved rezoning of Theatre 42 property at 2752 U.S. 42 in Union Twp. for a planned development by Ramesh Malhotra, an entrepreneur also involved in redevelopment of two sites in Franklin as...
White House frustration grows with Tillerson over jobs for Trump allies
White House frustration grows with Tillerson over jobs for Trump allies

The White House is becoming increasingly frustrated with Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and a close-knit circle of aides over the slow pace of hiring and a chokehold on information and access to Tillerson, according to senior Trump administration officials and others familiar with the rift. Tillerson, a former Exxon Mobil chief executive with no...
Trump signs law making it easier to fire bad VA employees
Trump signs law making it easier to fire bad VA employees

President Donald Trump signed a bill into law Friday that would expedite the process for top officials to fire problematic employees at the long-troubled U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. The aim of the accountability legislation is to make it easier to root out the bad apples who have helped contribute to the cascade of scandals at the VA, harming...
More Stories