GOP senators urge Trump to stay in NAFTA

Lawmakers argue U.S. businesses and consumers have benefited from the accord.


A large group of Republican senators including Majority Leader Mitch McConnell , R-Ky., wrote to President Donald Trump on Tuesday urging him not to withdraw from the North American Free Trade Agreement.

The letter signed by 36 GOP senators was released just hours before Trump is to deliver his State of the Union address to Congress. It served notice that whatever Trump's message is on trade, many in his party will not stand with him if he makes good on his threats to withdraw from the accord between the U.S., Canada and Mexico. 

The letter comes one day after the latest round of talks to renegotiate the trade pact ended in Montreal. It is carefully worded to appeal to Trump's successes, pointing to them as a reason to stay in the trade deal. 

"Mr. President, your leadership has jump-started our economy. The recent tax reform bill is already leading to economic success across all industries and the stock market is at record highs," the senators wrote. "The next step to advance the economy requires that we keep NAFTA in place, but modernize it to better reflect our 21st century economy. We look forward to working with you and your administration to make that modernization a reality and bring Americans even greater economic success." 

The letter also notes that "a wide range of industries in the U.S. have benefited from this agreement and American consumers are reaping those benefits, too." 

Trump campaigned on promises to withdraw from NAFTA, deriding it as a terrible deal that had cost U.S. jobs and destroyed manufacturing. Despite pressure from GOP lawmakers and business leaders, he's kept up the criticism since taking office. Earlier this month, Trump tweeted that NAFTA was a "bad joke" and vowed to use the bargaining over a trade deal to make Mexico pay for a wall along the U.S. southern border. 

Trade is an issue with the potential to divide the GOP, since most congressional Republicans, especially in the Senate, support free trade and oppose the protectionist policies espoused by Trump. A number of lawmakers voiced opposition last week when the administration imposed tariffs on imported solar panels and washing machines. 

Sen. Patrick Toomey, R-Pa., one of the signers of Tuesday's letter, said in an interview that "I am not aware of a single Republican senator who wishes for the United States to withdraw from NAFTA." 

Toomey said he found the tariff decision "very disturbing" and it contributed to the urgency to send a message on NAFTA. 

"Among Republican senators there's very, very strong support for staying in NAFTA. I think most of us believe there are things that can be improved upon, there are certainly things that can be updated to reflect economic and technological changes," Toomey said. "But this has been a very, very good trade agreement for the United States and certainly Pennsylvania, and we wanted to communicate that because in part, let's face it, the president has at times expressed a lot of skepticism about NAFTA." 

A sixth round of talks aimed at reaching a new North American trade deal ended in Montreal on Monday having made only limited progress. Trade officials agreed on a new treaty's anti-corruption provisions and narrowed the gaps over customs issues. But on the main U.S. proposals, including a bid to restructure auto industry supply chains, they remain far apart. 

Negotiators from the three countries have been meeting since August in hopes of rewriting the 24-year accord, which the president has repeatedly assailed as unfair to his working-class base. 

But despite his vow that the negotiations could be used to make Mexico pay for a border wall, Mexican officials say privately that the wall has not been discussed in the talks. 

U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer told reporters on Monday that the administration wants to encourage the return of manufacturing jobs to the United States and to eliminate incentives for corporations to move their operations offshore. Many economists say those jobs are gone for good. 

In recent weeks, NAFTA supporters have flocked to the White House in an effort to educate the president on the downside of giving up on the deal. Republican senators and representatives of affected industries and agricultural groups have stressed that walking away could push down stock prices and lead to the loss of export jobs tied to Mexico and Canada. 

Political concerns were not far from negotiators' minds in Montreal. A congressional delegation including Rep. David Reichert, R-Wash., the chairman of the House trade subcommittee, met with Lighthizer to show congressional backing for the deal. 

Lighthizer is pushing negotiators to accelerate their efforts between now and the next round of talks, scheduled for late February in Mexico.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

U.S. may put tarriffs on China, other steel-producing countries
U.S. may put tarriffs on China, other steel-producing countries

U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross on Friday urged President Donald Trump to impose steep tariffs on China and other steel-producing countries, contending they are illegally dumping steel into U.S. markets. In a 262-page report that was praised by many Ohio lawmakers, Ross charged that imported steel products are priced “substantially lower&rdquo...
The new Hamilton fire chief has many to thank for his career, including his mother-in-law
The new Hamilton fire chief has many to thank for his career, including his mother-in-law

Some people, when they’re sworn in to a new city government position, bring a few family members with them. When new Hamilton Fire Chief Mark Mercer was sworn in on Wednesday, he brought a few … and a few more. They all gathered at the front of Hamilton City Council Chambers for the swearing-in ceremony. There was even one from New York...
Springboro to spend $200,000 on land for new park
Springboro to spend $200,000 on land for new park

The Springboro City Council authorized the city manager to pay $190,000 for 5.8 acres of residential property on Lytle-Five Points Road and shift $200,000 in city funds to pay for the land. The votes during Thursday’s council meeting came on two legislative items added to the agenda and approved on first readings. Supporters say the new park...
President Trump to visit Florida school shooting area today
President Trump to visit Florida school shooting area today

President Donald Trump says he leaves for Florida Friday to “meet with some of the bravest people.” Trump’s tweet did not elaborate on his plans. But White House officials are working to arrange a visit to Florida in the wake of this week’s deadly school shooting. Trump writes that he’ll meet with “people whose lives...
With McCain’s retreat, some look to Romney to carry traditional GOP torch
With McCain’s retreat, some look to Romney to carry traditional GOP torch

In more ways than one, followers of traditional Republican orthodoxy are facing an emotional inflection point this week.  Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., at home battling an aggressive form of brain cancer, will not attend this weekend's Munich Security Conference, an annual gathering of foreign policy leaders from NATO nations that has become a central...
More Stories