SPECIAL REPORT: Hospital closing latest blow to city’s west side

Community leader: ‘That’s just a devastating feeling.’


The recent onslaught of bad economic news has residents in the west side of Dayton feeling picked on.

First the grocery store ALDI announced in December it is closing its location on West Third Street, making it harder for residents in what is already a food desert to get affordable, fresh food.

LATEST NEWS: Pastors lead protest against Good Sam closing

Weeks later, Dayton Public Schools announced declining enrollment could force them to shutter schools. No decision has been made yet, but the eight schools listed as most under-enrolled, all are in west Dayton.

This month came perhaps the biggest gut-punch of all: the announcement that Premier Health will close Good Samaritan Hospital this year, impacting medical care for west Dayton residents and sucking 1,600 jobs out of northwest Dayton.

“Whether this is right or wrong, what it feels like is they’re taking our health care, they’re taking our jobs, they’re taking our schools, and that’s just a devastating feeling when all those assets start to leave at once,” said Darryl Fairchild, a community leader in the Dayton View Triangle neighborhood just south of Good Sam.

RELATED: Dennis Kucinich says Dayton should sue to stop Good Sam closing

Fairchild was at a small gathering Tuesday evening of area residents at Omega Baptist Church who came to vent frustration and discuss next steps over the hospital closure.

Sarni Bensman, who lives in the Mount Vernon neighborhood, said residents need to make their voices heard.

“I think the people, the community of the west side, these people need to wake up, smell the coffee. Start protesting, start getting in all the meetings,” Bensman said. “The city council meetings, go to the school board meetings and say, ‘No, you’re not doing this to our side of town.’” 

Population, value declines

West Dayton’s problems have been decades in the making. The closure of manufacturing plants dealt devastating blows. Many people with money moved to the suburbs, leaving a smaller, poorer population.

The declining population accelerated the problem. ALDI blamed its decision to close on diminished traffic. Dayton Public Schools says eight schools in west Dayton have half the students they were built for. Wogaman Middle School was designed for 780 kids, but only has just 218.

RELATED: Not clear what will replace Good Samaritan Hospital

Property values in some northwest neighborhoods have decreased. The most recent three-year review by the Montgomery County Auditor’s Office nudged median values down from $44,350 to $40,390 in the College Hill neighborhood, with Santa Clara median values dropping to as low as $30,970.

“There’s this perception there’s this huge, massive, ongoing disinvestment in west Dayton,” said Dayton City Commissioner Chris Shaw. “It gives you a sense of the frustration and the fear that is going through the community.”

One of those fears, expressed by many at the Omega Baptist Church meeting, is that there is an intentional abandonment of west Dayton.

“We live in brick houses, well-maintained brick houses. We are well-educated. We are not thugs,” said Katharine Schaefer.

“These are educated people who purchased a home to raise a family and now we feel like we’re being pushed out on all sides.”

RELATED: Most kept in dark about Good Sam closing

Setback to recent success 

What makes the hospital’s closure particularly painful, Shaw and others said, is it guts an area that appeared to be on the mend. Tens of millions of dollars have been investment near the hospital, largely through the city- and hospital-backed Phoenix Project.

A Phoenix Project policing initiative led to an 11 percent drop in crime in the area from 2008 to 2017, including a 43 percent drop in drug crimes, according to the city.

Dayton View Triangle saw median values edge up slightly, from $52,305 to $52,680.

“To be real candid that area is really one of the only areas that had recent development,” said Branford Brown, executive director of the Miami Valley Urban League, of the area around the hospital.

“That part of the community was being built up, so snatching that out of the community is going to have a devastating impact on economic development in this area.”

Brown said it’s key that the community be involved in what replaces the hospital.

“If it’s going to be another Family Dollar store I’m not excited,” he said. “It seems all we have left now are barber shops, beauty shops and churches and everybody else is abandoning the community.”

Premier Health has pledged to provide $10 million toward the redevelopment effort and to make the property “shovel-ready” for a future developer. The hospital network is also working with CityWide Development, the city’s development arm, and Planning NEXT of Columbus on a repurposing plan. Planning NEXT is the same design firm that rolled out a proposal for the fairgrounds property last week.

But some residents fear a ripple effect from the hospital closing.

“How many other businesses are going to close right here next to it, that were being supported by Good Samaritan Hospital?” Dayton View Triangle resident Steve Burden said.

RELATED: Mayor says city not told the truth about Good Sam closing

‘It’s going to be our turn’

Not everyone is pessimistic about the future.

Jule Rastikis, president of the community group Salem Avenue Peace Corridor, said the means are there for a revival. He noted that a recent study found people living in a three-mile radius from the corner of Salem Avenue and Grand Avenue spend $300 million a year outside of their community.

“We know the potential for viability on Salem is huge,” Rastikis said. “”The biggest problem we have is a perception problem.”

Larry Ramey, president of the Salem Avenue Business Association, admitted there is an image problem but said changes in the past couple of years have made a positive impact. For example:

  • The Dayton Metropolitan Library put its largest non-downtown branch a block from Good Sam.
  • The Gem City Market — with financial support from Premier Health — is looking to build a co-op grocery on lower Salem.
  • Kettering Health Network recently invested in Grandview Medical Center.
  • P3 Secure, parent company of 4EverReady Home Care and Transportation, is moving to a larger facility in the Salem corridor after growing to more than 100 employees in three years.
  • Production Design Services Inc. of West Carrollton, an equipment manufacturer, is moving 110 jobs to Dayton’s Five Points neighborhood.

Rastikis sees a day when west Dayton gets the building investment downtown is currently seeing.

“It’s going to be Salem Avenue’s turn soon,” he said. “It’s going to be our turn.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Semi swerves to avoid deer, ends up in mud off state Route 503 in Preble County
Semi swerves to avoid deer, ends up in mud off state Route 503 in Preble County

UPDATE @ 8:20 p.m.: A trucker on his way from Lewisburg to Middletown to pick up a load of steel swerved on state Route 503 North to avoid several deer to end up stuck in the mud off the right side of the highway, the Ohio State Highway Patrol said.  The semitrailer hit utility poles and trees, and brought down phone and cable lines on its way...
Family: Attempted robbery led to fatal shooting of Springfield teen
Family: Attempted robbery led to fatal shooting of Springfield teen

The Springfield Police Division is investigating the city’s first fatal shooting of the year and family said they believe an attempted robbery might have led to the killing. Cobey E. Etherington, 19, of Springfield, was pronounced dead at the scene. Officers were in the area of West Pleasant and South Yellow Springs streets when they heard a...
Dayton school board, facilities task force both to meet Tuesday
Dayton school board, facilities task force both to meet Tuesday

Dayton Public Schools will have a full day Tuesday, as the district’s facilities task force meets at 9:30 a.m., the school board holds its monthly business meeting at 5 p.m., and students and teachers return from a four-day weekend. The facilities task force is studying possible closure of multiple Dayton schools because enrollment declines have...
Springfield nursing home cited 31 times on health inspections
Springfield nursing home cited 31 times on health inspections

A Springfield nursing facility accused of allowing a patient to overdose after accessing unsecured narcotics has a much higher number of health citations than the state average — a total of 31, according to a federal website. Eaglewood Care center also received a statement of deficiency from the Ohio Department of Health after a patient died...
Want to be a substitute teacher? Northmont seeking help
Want to be a substitute teacher? Northmont seeking help

Finding substitute teachers is harder than usual, Northmont City Schools leaders said. The district is currently accepting applications for substitutes for all grades, pre-Kindergarten through grade 12, with a bachelor’s degree in any subject. Northmont serves the Clayton area and has seven schools total, with a learning center. The district...
More Stories