Apology by doctor can’t be used in lawsuit, rules Ohio Supreme Court


Apologies by doctors or nurses that express fault or admission of liability cannot be used against health care providers in civil lawsuits, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled this week in a lawsuit against a Southwest Ohio doctor over a woman’s suicide death.

The court ruling in the case, related to a medical malpractice suit against a Clermont County doctor, resolved a split among Ohio appeals courts over the state’s “apology statute” and whether the term “apology” excluded a provider’s apology that included an admission of fault.

The court unanimously agreed that Ohio’s law shields apologies that include admissions of fault. However, two justices concluded that doctor’s statements were not an apology and the trial court should have allowed his comments to be presented in the case.

RELATED: Take a look at Dayton Children’s new patient tower

The Supreme Court stated that the majority decision, written by Justice Sharon L. Kennedy, affirmed rulings by lower courts not to admit the statements of Dr. Rodney E. Vivian in a medical malpractice lawsuit brought against him by the family of a woman who committed suicide in 2010. The woman was under Vivian’s care at Mercy Health-Clermont Hospital.

The court ruled that “a statement expressing apology” means a statement expressing a feeling of regret for an unanticipated outcome of the patient’s medical care, and may include an acknowledgment that the patient’s care was substandard.

RELATED: $380 million Springboro development moves ahead

The Court heard oral arguments on the matter at an April off-site court hearing in Morgan County.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Piqua man accused of rape is competent for trial, judge decides
Piqua man accused of rape is competent for trial, judge decides

A Piqua man charged with felony rape has been found competent for trial, a Miami County Common Pleas judge ruled. Stanley Fraley, 61, is charged in a case involving an adult woman who told Troy police she was raped with force.  Fraley had pleaded not guilty and not guilty by reason of insanity. Tuesday, Judge Jeannine Pratt said the report...
Cash registers marry artistry and commerce‘It’s like a jewelry store’

The cash registers manufactured by Dayton’s National Cash Register Company were not just tools of business — they were also objects of art. Lined up at Carillon Historical Park in gleaming order, the machines, made of warm woods and glittering metals, shimmer in a marriage of artistry and commerce. “It’s like a jewelry store...
ECOT appeals in fight to stay open; emails show state fight
ECOT appeals in fight to stay open; emails show state fight

The Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow on Tuesday announced it is appealing the decision of its sponsor, the Educational Service Center of Lake Erie West, to close the embattled online school. ECOT officials called it “a final attempt to keep the doors open through June,” saying in a press release that the school’s contract provides...
Male shows up at hospital, tells police someone in passing car shot him
Male shows up at hospital, tells police someone in passing car shot him

A victim of a shooting turned up at Grandview Medical Center on Tuesday afternoon and Dayton police are working to determine what happened. The male victim told police he was walking with friends on Otterbein Avenue, near Newton Avenue, when a car approached them and someone fired shots from that car, according to notes from police officers to Montgomery...
Huber Heights police mourn retired officer’s death
Huber Heights police mourn retired officer’s death

The Huber Heights Police Division announced retired officer Robbie Redcross died Tuesday of health complications. Redcross died at Hospice of Dayton, according to the division’s Facebook account. He served in Huber Heights for 25 years before retiring in 2006, according to the post and archival news coverage. RELATED: Services set for late Huber...
More Stories