Dayton wants more diverse city workers, but mayor proud of effort

Dayton leaders say they want the city government’s workforce to reflect the diversity of the community. But that’s easier said than done.

More than 70 percent of workers employed by the city are white, and an even larger share of the workforce are men, according to city data obtained by this newspaper.

MORE: Numbers don’t lie: Downtown Dayton had a very big 2017

In the city of Dayton, 40 percent of residents are black and more than half are women.

But the city’s racial diversity is actually pretty good considering Dayton no longer has a residency requirement for employees and its workforce comes from across the region, which is overwhelmingly white, said Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley.

Some departments have struggled to achieve diversity goals, such as safety services. About 93 percent of the fire department is white men.

“I’m really proud of that 70-30 number because we are pulling from the entire region for our workforce,” Whaley said. “We really want to work on are the departments that don’t have diversity.”

RELATED: Dayton has least diverse police class in a decade

The city of Dayton employs 1,997 people, which includes part-time workers and supervisors.

Demographics vary by department.

But white men hold 1,146 jobs with the city (57 percent of the total positions), city data show. White women occupy 269 jobs (13.5 percent of the total).

The city’s workforce includes 519 employees who are black, 18 who are Hispanic or Latino, 17 who identify as two or more races, 17 who are Asian or Pacific Islander and 11 who are American Indian or Alaska native, according to city data.

The city’s newest hires are sticking to these trends. The city hired 190 new employees in 2017 across a wide a range of departments, according to city data. Almost seven in 10 last year were Caucasian, and three in four were male.

Some city departments are quite diverse.

RELATED: Too many officers with Dayton Police Department are white, report says

About 43 percent of public works employees and nearly 29 percent of water department workers are minorities. More than one-quarter of airport employees are people of color.

Dayton’s male-to-female employee ratio is pretty typical of most cities, because of the type of work government historically performs, like street paving and public utility operations, Whaley said.

Whaley said she always pushes for increasing women’s access to jobs. But, she said, she’s proud women hold executive positions with the city, including city manager, deputy city manager, law director and director of finance.

Challenges remain.

Dayton’s most recent police recruit class was the least diverse in in at least a decade. Nine in 10 sworn police officers are white and nearly as many are men.

RELATED: $5M downtown Dayton music pavilion is a go

The fire department employs 29 women and 307 men. There are 22 male fire employees who are minorities. The other 285 are white.

But Dayton’s Civil Service Department says this year it will focus on improving diversity in the fire department.

One goal is for at least 25 percent of candidates for the upcoming EMT class to come from diverse backgrounds, officials said.

“It’s no secret that the city of Dayton’s safety forces have tried to improve diversity for a very long time,” said Jeff Lykins, the fire department’s deputy chief.

Lykins said his research indicate that as far back as 1965, Dayton struggled to have safety forces’ workers mirror the community they serve.

The biggest challenge is getting qualified candidates who are minorities to apply for open positions, he said, but the city has created a safety services diversity team to work on an prospective recruitment and selection practices to better achieve diversity goals.

“This isn’t just a city of Dayton problem,” he said. “Fire departments across America are finding it exceedingly difficult to diversify their forces.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Court tosses most claims in suit against Butler County judge
Court tosses most claims in suit against Butler County judge

Most of the allegations by the former Butler County magistrate, who claims she was fired for being Jewish, have been dismissed from the federal lawsuit she filed against Judge Greg Stephens and Prosecutor Michael Gmoser. Kimberly Edelstein filed a $1 million lawsuit against Stephens, Gmoser and Assistant Prosecutor Dan Ferguson in May, claiming Stephens...
Woman threatens to ‘blow off’ head of Dayton postal worker
Woman threatens to ‘blow off’ head of Dayton postal worker

Federal postal workers in Dayton were threatened by a woman whose mail they will no longer deliver. Dayton police are investigating an aggravated menacing complaint from 1:45 p.m. Friday at the U.S. Postal Service office in the 4300 block of West Third Street. The female suspect is accused of spitting at the postal office supervisor and being belligerent...
Dayton fast food workers threatened with knife
Dayton fast food workers threatened with knife

Police here are investigating after a man with a knife threatened Burger King workers.  The incident happened at the Burger King, 1401 N. Keowee Street, around 8:50 p.m. Saturday.  Dayton police are investigating the aggravated menacing complaint after workers said a man in the drive-through window was waving a knife and yelling about chicken...
Panhandler gets 20 cents, followed by court summons from police
Panhandler gets 20 cents, followed by court summons from police

Police here issued a summons to appear in court for a panhandling offense.  The Dayton police report states a 62-year-old man stepped off a curb and into the roadway to accept 20 cents from a vehicle around 4:30 p.m. Sunday in the 600 block of South Jefferson Street near U.S. 35 East. He was issued a summons to appear for a charge of distribution...
Forum: Solutions to Ohio opioid crisis should be ‘self-sustaining, repeatable’
Forum: Solutions to Ohio opioid crisis should be ‘self-sustaining, repeatable’

Dozens of people who are personally impacted by the opioid crisis gathered Sunday in Wilmington to discuss the issue in a unique forum hosted by Your Voice Ohio.  The conversation inside the municipal building on North South Street involved medical professionals, first-responders, parents who have lost children to opioid addiction and recovering...
More Stories