Englewood woman waits to be deported: We ‘cried through the whole night’


Every Monday, Englewood resident Fatiha Elgharib must report to federal officials to find out when she will be separated from her family and deported to Morocco.

Elgharib had filed for a 1-year stay in her deportation proceedings so she could remain with her 15-year-old son Sami, who has Down syndrome and other health problems, and for whom Elgharib is the primary caregiver.

She also has two daughters who have fought to keep her in the country with, among other things, an online petition signed by more than 80,000 people.

MORE: Englewood mom not alone as more locals face deportation, attorney says

“All of our time and our effort and the tears and the no sleep literally just went out the window because they (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) didn’t care, they didn’t acknowledge it,” said her 18-year-old daughter Wafaa Hamdi, who organized the petition.

On Oct. 23 ICE officials told the family that she will be deported within a month, and she must check in every Monday until they have the final date. She was fitted with an ankle bracelet to prevent her from trying to flee.

“She cried the whole day,” Wafaa said. “We were holding each other and cried through the night.”

Her 27-year-old daughter Sara Hamdi noted that they have never tried to hide from ICE. Elgharib came to the country legally 22 years ago and said she was ordered deported without her knowledge after she overstayed her visa.

MORE: Fairfield mother of four deported back to Mexico

Her attorney, Shahrzad P. Allen, said the decision to remove Elgharib is a direct result of the presidential election. President Donald Trump’s administration did away with ICE’s policy under the Obama administration of granting leniency in such cases, she said.

“There is no difference in (Elgharib’s) case today than there was last year or two years ago, so the only difference is the change in administration,” Allen said. “Their directives have changed.”

Elgharib, sitting in her Englewood home, said she understands she broke the law in overstaying her visa.

“I hope for people to care about me,” she said in an interview Tuesday evening, “just to give me a chance and to let me stay with my kids.”

MORE: I-Team analysis: Deportations dropped in Ohio under Obama; here’s why

When she leaves, law dictates that she will not be allowed back into the United States for 10 years.

Elgharib says she will have to leave Sami here because Morocco doesn’t have the medical facilities he needs.

“I don’t want to, but they force me to,” she said of leaving Sami.

ICE had been lenient with Elgharib for years because she was paying taxes, obeying the law – other than her immigration issue – and caring for Sami. The late Sen. George Voinovich once interceded to help her, and current Sens. Sherrod Brown and Rob Portman both say they are looking into her case.

ICE officials, when asked why her request for a stay was denied, re-issued the same statement they put out in August.

“Over the last decade, Ms. Elgharib’s immigration case has undergone exhaustive judicial review at multiple levels of the nation’s courts… (which) have uniformly held that Ms. Elgharib does not have a legal basis to remain in the U.S,” the statement says.

“In an exercise of discretion, the agency has allowed her to remain free from custody while timely finalizing her departure plans, rather than be detained and deported.”

Wafaa, who is a freshman at Wright State University, will have to care for Sami. Both she and her brother are U.S. citizens because they were born here.

“I still don’t believe it,” Wafaa said. “I am in shock.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Sewing studio to move to new location in Beavercreek
Sewing studio to move to new location in Beavercreek

A local sewing studio will move to a new location in Beavercreek by the end of the month. Needle, Ink and Thread, a local sewing studio, announced it will move by the end of January. A portion of the recently closed Antiques Marketplace of Beavercreek at 3491 Dayton Xenia Road, will be the studio’s new home. Currently located at 4005 Dayton-Xenia...
Elwell: Another eclipse is on the way, featuring a ‘blood moon’
Elwell: Another eclipse is on the way, featuring a ‘blood moon’

A super blue blood moon? Yes! It is happening on the last day of this month. A blue moon typically gets its name when it occurs as the second of two full moons in one calendar month. But something very special will happen to the moon on this date. The full moon will pass through the Earth’s shadow during the early morning of Jan. 31 to give us...
Power outages reported in Montgomery County 
Power outages reported in Montgomery County 

Nearly 120 Dayton Power & Light customers are without power in Montgomery County. Power is expected to be restored around 11 a.m., according to DP&L. Power went out around 5:48 a.m. The day is starting frigid with temperatures in the single digits.  The outage is southwest of the Dayton Mall, close to Interstate 75, according to DP&L. It&rsquo...
JUST IN: New bakery specializing in pies — yes, pies — to open near UD
JUST IN: New bakery specializing in pies — yes, pies — to open near UD

A new bakery specializing in pies is in the works near the campus of the University of Dayton. If all goes well, the bakery to be named “Partial to Pie” could open as early as this spring, founder and owner Marie Clark told this news outlet. The bakery will be located at 200 Shroyer Road, at the Wilmington Pike/Shroyer Road intersection...
West Liberty still healing 1 year after school shooting
West Liberty still healing 1 year after school shooting

Saturday will mark one year since a gunman opened fire inside West Liberty-Salem High School, rocking the small community where many thought something so violent could never happen. “I was in disbelief,” said Jacob King, whose wife owns a store on Detroit Street — the main road through the village of less than 2,000 people. &ldquo...
More Stories