Federal judge hints West Chester could lose rehab center lawsuit


The federal judge in the lawsuit against West Chester Twp. about the drug rehab center moratorium essentially told the township it likely won’t win if it continues to fight the case.

In an unusual move, Judge Timothy S. Black of the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio, placed a notation on the docket that basically tells the township it needs to work out a resolution with Dr. Mohamed Aziz.

Aziz filed sued the township on Sept. 23, alleging that a temporary ban trustees placed on facilities like his Professional Psychiatric Services violates the Americans With Disabilities Act.

Black wrote: “The court has held two initial telephone conferences involving counsel for plaintiffs and for defendant. During these conferences, the court reminded both parties of the consequences that could result if the court finds that the Americans with Disabilities Act and/or the Rehabilitation Act have been violated by defendant, or not.”

“After reviewing the complaint and the motion for temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, and while acknowledging that these documents reflect only the position of plaintiffs and not the defenses that could be raised by defendant, the court has advised defendant that it would be wise to work with plaintiffs to find a potential resolution to this matter outside of the litigation process,” the judge wrote.

The lawsuit indicates PPS paid $650,000 for the old nursing home and an additional $200,000 for an adjacent property so they can properly address a “storm water retaining bowl” issue.

Residents have been at every meeting since April 12 protesting the controversial center because it sits across the street from the Pisgah Youth Organization ballfields, next to a daycare center and in front of a residential neighborhood.

“PPS’s future patients are considered people with disabilities under the ADA and the Rehab Act and are therefore a protected class,” the lawsuit reads. “Under the ADA and the Act, laws that apply only to individuals with disabilities are facially discriminatory.”

Aziz’s attorney Chris Finney said while it is not unheard of for judges take this preemptive action, it is unusual and was a very “deliberate” thing for Black to do.

“In some ways it’s a kindness to the defendant to be clear how you feel about something rather than blindside them later on,” Finney said.

The township’s law director Scott Phillips said he cannot discuss pending litigation.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Fire in vacant Dayton house under investigation as suspicious
Fire in vacant Dayton house under investigation as suspicious

A fire that caused significant damage to a vacant house in the 1600 block of Weaver Street in Dayton is being investigated as suspicious, Dayton fire personnel said.  Crews were dispatched just after 5:30 p.m. on a report of a possible structure fire with smoke and flames showing. The dispatch was upgraded minutes later to a working structure...
Demonstration at Wright State sparks debate over campus free speech
Demonstration at Wright State sparks debate over campus free speech

College administrators across the nation are being questioned on their decisions that some say bar free speech from campuses. Wright State University found itself at the center of the ongoing debate about campus free speech Wednesday when questions emerged over how the school handled an anti-abortion demonstration. The issue of free speech at colleges...
Guilty plea accepted in Tipp City home robbery for stolen drugs
Guilty plea accepted in Tipp City home robbery for stolen drugs

The last of four people indicted on charges stemming from the robbery of a Tipp City home to retrieve stolen drugs pleaded guilty to a lesser felony in a Troy courtroom on Wednesday. Carlos Gomez, 23, now of Baldwin Park, Calif., was returned to Ohio to face the charge from a November incident in which Tipp City police said one person was injured. ...
Indiana Task Force 1 heads to WPAFB for Hurricane Maria deployment
Indiana Task Force 1 heads to WPAFB for Hurricane Maria deployment

Indiana Task Force 1 is holding an impromptu press conference at 9 p.m. outside their Beavercreek hotel. The task force will be leaving from Wright Patterson Air Force Base for Puerto Rico after it was hit by Hurricane Maria. The task force has not been told when they would be deploying. Indiana Task Force 1 is preparing for deployment to Puerto Rico...
Clark Howard: Your guide to paying off credit card debt
Clark Howard: Your guide to paying off credit card debt

There are several steps you should take to get out of credit card debt. Paying off credit card debt that’s several thousand dollars or more takes time, so you must discipline yourself. The key is to make debt a priority. I usually find setting a goal of paying down debt in 36 months or less works best for people. If the end goal is any further...
More Stories