Loss of tax incentives would be ‘devastating’ for Dayton


A growing chorus of local developers, preservationists and elected leaders are calling on U.S. lawmakers to preserve a federal tax incentive program that has helped redevelop dozens of historic and iconic buildings in Dayton, resulting in an estimated $270 million in investment.

Federal historic tax credits — which are at risk of being reduced or eliminated as part of the GOP’s sweeping tax reform proposals — provides tax credits that close financing gaps to revive historically significant properties.

Since 1981, the program has made about 64 tax credit awards that have helped redevelop functionally obsolete and vacant buildings in Dayton that otherwise had little to no hope of being revived, the city said.

In an interview this week with CNBC, Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley said for mid-sized cities like Dayton, historic tax credits are not one avenue — they are the only avenue — to rehab many outdated and empty buildings.

“This would stop what we are trying to do,” Whaley told this newspaper.

RELATED: Popular tax incentives could be history: What it means for Dayton

In November, the Dayton City Commission approved an informal resolution urging the Trump Administration and Congress to continue the federal historic tax credit program, which dates back to the Reagan Administration.

The resolution was sent to U.S. Sens. Sherrod Brown and Rob Portman and U.S. Rep. Mike Turner, R-Dayton.

Supporters of the program across Ohio and the nation have been sending letters and calling their lawmakers urging them to protect the incentive.

The GOP’s tax reform proposals seek to simplify the tax code and supporters say they will provide significant and important tax cuts for many Americans and businesses.

But the House bill passed on Nov. 16 would eliminate the federal historic tax credit, and a Senate bill reduces the value of the credit, according to the National Trust for Historic Preservation.

The federal program currently allows developers who restore historic buildings to get a 20 percent credit on qualified restoration expenses.

Dayton is home to a significant number of aging and functionally obsolete buildings that sit empty or underutilized and, like so many “white elephants” in urban areas, they are not financially feasible to restore and are expensive to maintain or demolish, according to Dayton officials and developers.

The Dayton Daily News reported this week that downtown Dayton’s office vacancy rate is one the highest in the nation, according to real estate firm Colliers International.

RELATED: Dayton area office vacancy remains high

According to the city, federal tax credits helped rehab or develop the Biltmore Hotel, the Cannery Loft Apartments, the downtown Dayton YMCA, the old post office, the Hawthorne School Apartments, the Delco Lofts, the Dayton Arcade and the Salem and Grand building and plenty of other structures.

Projects that have benefited from the credits have invested about $270 million in the city, and the program “plugged important financing gaps” that would have prevented the projects from moving forward, the city said.

Cities of all sizes across the state and nation have projects that were supported by the program. Rust Belt cities, with aging and decaying former industrial and commercial facilities, have especially benefited from the credits.

In downtown Dayton alone, historic tax credits are key funding sources for six current projects and many more in pre-development, representing more than $200 million in investment, according to the Downtown Dayton Partnership.

The partnership has urged citizens to contact lawmakers to protect the program.

Adaptive reuse projects are more expensive than building new structures, and the credits provide a way to tap into a funding source that reduces the extra costs of renovation, said Dayton City Manager Shelley Dickstein.

Losing the financing tool would put urban areas with aging buildings at a disadvantage compared to underdeveloped “greenfield” sites, said Jason Woodard, principal of Woodard Development and one of the developers of the Water Street District.

“Historic buildings with significant character likely could not be restored, which is unfortunate aesthetically if not economically,” said Woodard, who used federal tax credits to help create the Delco Lofts by Fifth Third Field.

Building new is not better but is cheaper, and demolishing the old and obsolete structures to make way for new ones also can be very expensive and cost prohibitive, officials said.

The historic tax credit program is a tax expenditure with a public cost: It cost the U.S. Treasury about $25.2 billion between 1978 to 2016, according to a report by Rutgers University and the National Park Service.

During that period, however, that cost supported $131.8 billion in historic renovation investments, generating about 2.5 million new jobs and billions of dollars in direct and secondary economic gains, the report states.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Anger over effort to free convicted killer: ‘He beat my sons to death’
Anger over effort to free convicted killer: ‘He beat my sons to death’

Even after 32 years, the trauma of finding her mother, sister, niece and two young sons slaughtered and three more children left for dead never leaves Tia Talbott. “I just keep wishing it wasn’t real — that it was a dream or bad nightmare and I would wake up and this is all not real,” she said. Talbott is having to relive it...
How Dayton changed the Bombecks — and how the Bombecks changed Dayton
How Dayton changed the Bombecks — and how the Bombecks changed Dayton

Growing up in Dayton left an indelible imprint on Bill and Erma Bombeck – and they, in turn, now leave an enduring legacy in their hometown. Bill Bombeck died Jan. 12 in Phoenix, Ariz., and he soon will be buried alongside his wife in Dayton’s historic Woodland Cemetery. But the couple will live on in the hearts of many friends in the Dayton...
Drug crisis in Ohio: What solutions are making a difference?
Drug crisis in Ohio: What solutions are making a difference?

During a year of record deaths from drug overdoses in Springfield and across Ohio, glimmers of hope also exist as organizations and local governments have begun to find solutions that might make a difference. More than 30 news organizations statewide have partnered to share those solutions and help communities think about which ones might be adaptable...
Drug crisis in Ohio: What solutions are making a difference?
Drug crisis in Ohio: What solutions are making a difference?

During a year of record deaths from drug overdoses in the Miami Valley and across Ohio, glimmers of hope also exist as organizations and local governments have begun to find solutions that might make a difference. More than 30 news organizations statewide have partnered to share those solutions and help communities think about which ones might be adaptable...
John Legend blames Trump for government shutdown, calls him racist
John Legend blames Trump for government shutdown, calls him racist

Grammy and Oscar-winning singer John Legend is claiming that President Donald Trump and his team’s alleged racism are behind the government shutdown. Legend, who has vocally criticized Trump Sr. and Jr. both in the past, tweeted the following just after midnight Saturday: “The reason the government shutdown is that Trump...
More Stories