West Chester drug rehab suit continues despite judge’s settlement note


Motions continue to be filed and hearings set in federal court despite the judge’s notation that states West Chester Twp. and a Mason drug rehab specialist must settle a lawsuit. Here’s why:

After months of wrangling at trustee meetings over a proposed drug rehab facility that would go into the old nursing home across from the Pisgah Youth Organization ball fields, Dr. Mohamed Aziz filed suit in federal court on Sept. 23. He alleged that a temporary ban trustees placed on facilities like his Professional Psychiatric Services (PPS) violates the Americans With Disabilities Act.

Last month, in an unusual move, Judge Timothy S. Black of the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio placed a notation on the docket that basically tells the township it needs to work out a resolution with Aziz.

Black wrote in part: “The court has advised defendant that it would be wise to work with plaintiffs to find a potential resolution to this matter outside of the litigation process,” the judge wrote.

So one might ask why the township had until today to file a response in the case and a hearing has been scheduled for mid-December. Legal experts and plaintiff’s attorney Jennifer Branch — who successfully got a preliminary injunction against the state for Planned Parenthood — said the judge is keeping the case schedule in tact as the parties work on a settlement, so the talks don’t dismantle.

“The judge is most likely continuing to hold the parties to a scheduling order because that’s what puts the pressure on the parties to settle,” she said. “Because if there is no scheduling order and they don’t have to file anything, people aren’t going to talk to each other and try to settle the case. The goal would be defense attorneys, instead of spending 100 hours drafting and putting on witnesses at the hearing in defending the litigation, spend your time trying to settle it.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Ohio court justice deletes Facebook post on sexual history
Ohio court justice deletes Facebook post on sexual history

From the Associated Press:
Lakota West High School gets Scandinavian makeover by Ikea
Lakota West High School gets Scandinavian makeover by Ikea

An international retailer gave Lakota West High School a Scandinavian makeover this week with $11,000 of donated furniture, lamps and decorations from the region’s Ikea store. And yes, some assembly was required but done expertly by Ikea workers. It was all worth it, said grateful Lakota school officials, to transform Lakota West’s 20-year-old...
Documents: Montana congressman misled investigators after assaulting reporter
Documents: Montana congressman misled investigators after assaulting reporter

A Montana congressman misled investigators about his assault on a reporter the day before he was elected in May, claiming that “liberal media” were “trying to make a story,” the Bozeman Daily Chronicle reported Saturday, citing audio and documents. U.S. Rep. Greg Gianforte, a Republican, told an officer in an audio interview...
5 things to know about the new Holtman’s Donuts in Butler County
5 things to know about the new Holtman’s Donuts in Butler County

An award-winning, family-owned doughnut shop chain with a devoted Greater Cincinnati fan-base recently debuted its first Butler County location. Holtman’s Donuts, which also has locations in Over-The-Rhine, Loveland and Williamsburg, located its fourth storefront at 9558 Civic Centre Blvd. in the Streets of West Chester shopping center. We spoke...
Garth Brooks’ donation helps K99.1FM raise $310,000 for hospital
Garth Brooks’ donation helps K99.1FM raise $310,000 for hospital

Garth Brooks and his fellow county music entertainer wife Trisha Yearwood helped K99.1FM’s “Cares for Kids” Radiothon gather a record $310,713 in its 20th year raising money for Dayton’s Children’s Hospital. Brooks’ and Yearwood’s matching of funds meant each dollar in that hour was quadrupled leading to a...
More Stories