West Chester says doctor can’t prove harm in drug rehab fight


West Chester Twp. lawyers fighting a lawsuit about a proposed drug rehab clinic said the doctor who filed the suit does not qualify for a preliminary injunction.

The township offered a federal judge a litany of reasons why a preliminary injunction is inappropriate, chief among them that Dr. Mohamed Aziz is not a disabled person protected by federal law and that he can’t prove irreparable harm has come to him.

Aziz sued the township in federal court in September, claiming the township denied his drug- and alcohol-addicted clients — people who are considered disabled under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act — services when the township placed a temporary moratorium on drug rehab facilities. The township made the move to study the impact the facilities have on communities surrounding them and then launched zoning amendments for those and several other business types.

Law Director Scott Phillips and his associates filed a response to the injunction motion late Monday night. They said Aziz cannot satisfy the four-prong test required with such an “extraordinary” legal remedy.

“Plaintiffs are not likely to succeed on the merits of their claim, because there is nothing unlawful or discriminatory about the action taken by the township. Plaintiffs also will not suffer any irreparable harm without the moratorium …,” the lawyers wrote.

The response also cautioned the judge that granting an injunction would set dangerous precedent.

“As such, awarding preliminary relief to plaintiffs would impose a far greater burden upon the township by undermining its authority to regulate land use and forcing it to disregard the administrative processes of its zoning resolution,” the township lawyers wrote.

“Granting preliminary relief on the eve of the moratorium’s expiration would set a harmful precedent that would incentivize a disregard for administrative remedies, while causing confusion among residents, business owners and developers about the most appropriate means to achieve their land use goals.”

Last month, in an unusual move, Judge Timothy S. Black of the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Ohio placed a notation on the docket that basically tells the township it needs to work out a resolution with Aziz.

Black wrote in part: “The court has advised defendant that it would be wise to work with plaintiffs to find a potential resolution to this matter outside of the litigation process.”

The property at the heart of this dispute is an old nursing home facility on Ohio 42 across from the Pisgah Youth Organization (PYO) ball fields, next to Hickory Dickory Tots daycare, and it fronts a residential neighborhood. Neighbors and members of the PYO came to every trustee meeting for about seven months, mainly pleading with their elected officials to stop Aziz’s plans.

Gene Drozd, treasurer of the PYO, was at every meeting, usually clutching a petition with hundreds and hundreds of signatures on it.

“We again are in a position where a bunch of folks are totally against the location. We understand the need of the community, we understand the doctor probably does very good work, but we are just totally opposed to that location,” Drozd told the trustees in August.

Phillips said the doctor has also misplaced blame in other areas of the lawsuit.

“Any other allegations of discriminatory action in the complaint relate either to citizens addressing the township trustees — whose public comments cannot be imputed to the trustees where a rational basis for the legislative action exists — or relate to a result that has not yet occurred and that plaintiffs have no reasonable basis for assuming — permanent denial of zoning approval under the soon-to-be-effective amendments to the zoning resolution,” the reply brief reads.

The trustees recently passed zoning text amendments that take effect in mid-December that would make institutional care facilities, like drug rehab centers, conditional uses subject to zoning board scrutiny but only in commercial and manufacturing districts. One of the things the Board of Zoning Appeals must consider is “whether the essential character of the neighborhood would be substantially altered or whether adjoining properties would suffer a substantial detriment as a result of the variance.”

Lastly, Phillips agreed the ADA does provide some protections for businesses like Aziz wants to operate but says he is missing a key element.

“In order to pursue relief to address injuries suffered solely by those individuals (e.g., injunctive relief arising from a lack of available treatment), plaintiffs should first be required to demonstrate that such individuals exist, that they will indeed be injured, and that claims are being brought on their behalf,” the reply reads. “Plaintiffs have not done so here.”

Aziz’s attorney Chris Finney said he could not comment on the case.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Woman hurt after falling down escalator at Dayton airport
Woman hurt after falling down escalator at Dayton airport

An elderly woman was reportedly injured after falling down an escalator at the Dayton International Airport.    A 70-year-old Lima resident suffered lacerations to her right leg after losing her footing at the top of the concourse escalator early Monday morning, according to a police report. The woman fell down most of the length of the down...
Old-fashioned candy shop to open in heart of Oakwood
Old-fashioned candy shop to open in heart of Oakwood

An old-fashioned candy shop will open in the heart of Oakwood next month, its owner told this media outlet. Katherine Wright, a Kettering resident, is working to open The Oakwood Candy Shoppe at 2541 Far Hills Ave. in Oakwood sometime in August. She said there is no set date for the opening, and she is still working with the county to secure permits...
Springfield man accused of fighting with deputy
Springfield man accused of fighting with deputy

Clark County jailers alleged a man fought with deputies and wouldn’t obey their commands. Brooks Nawman, 33, was in the Clark County Jail on Sunday, July 23, on a charge of obstruction when he allegedly began kicking the window to his cell. CRIME: Springfield woman accused of driving drunk, crashing SUV with 4 kids “As Deputy Moses Young...
Identity sought of woman who used stolen credit card
Identity sought of woman who used stolen credit card

Centerville police are asking for help to identify a woman who used a stolen credit card at a Fifth Third Bank ATM in June.  The victim’s credit card was used at a Fifth Third Bank ATM at 2255 Shiloh Springs Road in Trotwood around 10:18 a.m. on June 16, Centerville police said in a media release.  Police describe the suspect as a black...
Joint investigations net drug, weapons arrests in Dayton
Joint investigations net drug, weapons arrests in Dayton

Dayton police made several drug and gun arrests recently.  Three recent investigations have concluded with arrests.  On June 28, Julian Valentine and Dashawn Smedley were arrested.  Valentine had felony warrants and was reportedly found to be in possession of a stolen firearm and fentanyl, according to Dayton police. Smedley was arrested...
More Stories