Man admits guilt, avoids death penalty in Hamilton drive-by shooting


Tony Patete, the Newark man who fired the shots in a Hamilton retaliation shooting that killed two people, has admitted guilt to avoid the death penalty.

Patete, 24, pleaded guilty Monday in Butler County Common Pleas Court to two counts of aggravated murder and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole by Judge Greg Stephens.

Patete is convicted of the drive-by shooting deaths of Orlando Gilbert and Todd Berus in August 2016.

MORE: Wife doesn’t want jury trial in Warren County murder case 

That leaves just one defendant, Michael Grevious II, facing the death penalty. Grevious is charged with aggravated murder and felonious assault for a shootout in July 2016 at Doubles Bar. His trial is scheduled to begin in April.

string of violence in the summer of 2016 began with a shootout at the former bar on the city’s west side that killed one person and wounded seven others. That shooting sparked retaliation violence on the afternoon of Aug. 3, 2016, that left Gilbert and Berus dead.

According to prosecutors, Grevious, one of the men involved in the shootout at Doubles Bar, hired Zachary Harris, of Columbus, to kill Gilbert for $5,000.

On the afternoon of Aug. 3, 2016, a Chevrolet pickup truck driven by Melinda Gibby pulled up next to a black Ford Mustang occupied by Gilbert and Berus. Patete, the front seat passenger of the truck, opened fire with an AK-47 multiple times, killing Gilbert and Berus, according to court documents.

MORE: Ohio’s medical marijuana users won’t be able to have firearms

Patete made no statement before pleading guilty, but did turn and face the victim’s family members in the front row when asked to do so by Gilbert’s stepfather, Leroy Brown.

“My wife just wants you to look at her … just look at them, that is all I am asking,” Brown said.

Patete turned and faced the front row, but showed no emotion.

“Those are the people whose lives were affected,” Brown said. “Your life is in God’s hands now. God bless you.”

MORE: Attorney honored for work helping Butler County’s most vulnerable

Prosecutors and the judge read letters from Berus’ mother, grandmother and sisters.

Berus’ aunt Mollie Berus stood just a few feet from Patete and read a statement.

“On Aug. 3, 2016, without any thought to the consequences of your actions and with disregard for human life, you took a gun, leaned out the window and opened fire,” Mollie Berus said. “You not only shot and killed your intended target, but you also struck and killed an innocent bystander, my beloved nephew Todd. As the police told us, he was just in the wrong place at the wrong time.”

Mollie Berus said her nephew never got to meet his young daughter.

“Because of you, our family is broken and we cannot pick up the pieces,” she said.

MORE: Ohio Supreme Court to hear local man’s death penalty appeal

In October, Harris pleaded guilty to two counts of aggravated murder, just minutes before his two-week trial was scheduled to being and was given two life sentences.

Gibby pleaded guilty to aggravated murder with an agreed to sentence of 30 years to life. She will not be formally sentenced until after Grevious’ trial, where she has agreed to testify.




Next Up in Local

Greater Dayton RTA buses could be rid of cash fares by 2020
Greater Dayton RTA buses could be rid of cash fares by 2020

The Greater Dayton Regional Transit Authority hopes to modernize its payment system and get rid of cash fares by 2020, officials said Wednesday. More than half of RTA riders have migrated to passes, including monthly and weekly passes, said Mark Donaghy, CEO of the agency.  The agency will work to become the first major transit authority in the...
Pastor: Community ‘in shock’ after news about Good Samaritan closing
Pastor: Community ‘in shock’ after news about Good Samaritan closing

Hours after Good Samaritan Hospital officials announced Wednesday that the facility will close later this year, reaction about the community impact has been wide ranging. "It's devastating news, I was shocked" said Daryl Ward, pastor of Omega Baptist Church in Dayton.  His church is just down the street from Good Samaritan Hospital,...
2 males sought in Kettering home invasion robbery
2 males sought in Kettering home invasion robbery

Police are continuing to look for two males who committed a home invasion robbery on Hazel Avenue.  Investigators don't know what led the invaders to pick the home they did Wednesday afternoon, Kettering Police Patrolman John Jung said.  According to the preliminary investigation, the two males forced their way inside just before 4 p.m.,...
Job outlook is promising for Good Samaritan employees, official says
Job outlook is promising for Good Samaritan employees, official says

After Wednesday’s announcement that Good Samaritan Hospital will shut its doors for good at the end of the year, many in the Miami Valley are wondering what will happen to the facility’s 1,600 employees. The hospital’s parent company, Premier Health, said its goal is to offer jobs to all those employees at its other facilities in...
Ann Curry speaks out about Matt Lauer sexual harassment allegations in new interview
Ann Curry speaks out about Matt Lauer sexual harassment allegations in new interview

Ann Curry has remained tight-lipped since the news broke of Matt Lauer’s alleged sexual misconduct, but she spoke about the scandal on “CBS This Morning.” The 61-year-old journalist and producer appeared on the program Wednesday to discuss her new PBS docuseries “We’ll Meet Again” and she was asked to speak...
More Stories