Fairborn city manager accused of inappropriate comment against resident

Council will meet at 5:30 p.m., then go into executive session to investigate accusations that were made against McDonnell by residents Matt and Eva Stidham during public comment at Monday night’s city council meeting.

Matt Stidham claims McDonnell told city employees during a private meeting that “(Eva) is a troublemaker. She had a heart attack last year and maybe she will have another one and die.”

“That is a completely false statement. I never said those things,” McDonnell said to the Stidhams. “Whoever told you that is flat-out lying.”

Following Matt Stidham’s accusations, council went into emergency executive session in the middle of Monday’s meeting for about 40 minutes. Mayor Tom Nagel said tonight’s discussion is necessary in order to bring in other people who were not present Monday.

It is unknown if action will be taken after the executive session.

“It depends on the result of the information and what we’re able to establish as fact as opposed to fiction,” Nagel said.

McDonnell — Fairborn’s city manager since May 2007 — said Tuesday she has the “ultimate respect” for the Stidhams.

“That’s why I’m shocked that someone would say I’d wish ill will on her,” she said. “I never would.”

The Stidhams, who live on East Dayton-Yellow Springs Road, alleged McDonnell made the statement in regards to the city potentially making changes to that road. Matt Stidham said those changes would decrease the value of their home by $40,000.

Eva Stidham said she had a stroke last year and has made a 99 percent recovery.

“Mrs. Stidham is one of the finest citizens in Fairborn. She does not tell a lie,” Councilman Jim Hapner said. “I had a private breakfast with a senior staff member, and they verified exactly what Mr. and Mrs. Stidham have accused the city manager of. I’m tired of it. I’m tired of (McDonnell) lying.”

Hapner made the motion to go into executive session, and it was seconded by Councilman Robert Wood. It passed 5-2. Hapner did not return a message seeking comment Tuesday.

Also during public comment, several other residents expressed their displeasure about a city memo dated Aug. 9 related to mediation services in which McDonnell said Fairborn’s “culture is based in Appalachia traditions” and that on “measures of culture,” residents wouldn’t seek to use a mediation service.

“I’m sorry if you were offended, but there was no offense intended,” McDonnell. “I love Fairborn. I didn’t grow up here, but I love it.”

Prior to going into executive session, Wood told McDonnell that “it’s clear, despite your rationalization, you don’t appear to be a good fit in this city.”

“I’m going to recommend that you search the Internet for a new position, contact a realtor and prepare a resignation letter,” he continued.

Wood said Tuesday he stands by what he said.

“If we can bring some closure to divisive statements made by this employee, maybe we can have some healing in our city begin,” Wood said.

Council unanimously approved a four-year contract for McDonnell in May 2012, which included an increase in salary and vehicle allowance.

“By and large, she has done an admirable job as the city manager,” Councilman Dan Kirkpatrick said. “She’s played a major role in the financial soundness of the city. Do I have confidence in Debbie? Yes.”

Reader Comments

Next Up in News

Pedestrian hit by RTA bus in Harrison Twp.
Pedestrian hit by RTA bus in Harrison Twp.
Deputies and medics have been dispatched to reports of a pedestrian strike involving an RTA bus in Harrison Township.
Carillon Brewing takes a bow in the spotlight of ThinkTV’s ‘Our Ohio’
Carillon Brewing takes a bow in the spotlight of ThinkTV’s ‘Our Ohio’
The spotlight has been shining brightly on Carillon Brewing Co. lately, and the country’s only fully functioning brewery inside a museum is now...
Obama speech and long golf weekend with Tiger Woods costs $3.6 million
Obama speech and long golf weekend with Tiger Woods costs $3.6 million
If you’ve ever wondered how much it costs taxpayers when presidents go on golfing getaways, the U.
Dayton traffic from the WHIO Traffic Center
Dayton traffic from the WHIO Traffic Center
Check this page for a full list of crashes, disabled vehicles, construction projects and other hazards impacting your commute.
7 things to know now: 'Grabbing a musket;' new ISP rules; 'Afghan girl' arrested; Michael Phelps
7 things to know now: 'Grabbing a musket;' new ISP rules; 'Afghan girl' arrested; Michael Phelps
Here's a roundup of news trending across the nation and world today. What to know now: 1. Grabbing a musket: A former member of the House of...
More Stories

You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myDaytonDailyNews.com.

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of free premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


Welcome to myDaytonDailyNews.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myDaytonDailyNews.com.