Opinion: CNN ought not to ‘punch down’ at GIF creator


CNN is not wrong that the president of the United States ought to stop behaving like a clown. But they overshot this week.

As someone who has about the lowest possible tolerance for Trumpian vulgarity, I thought the imbroglio over the CNN logo gif was overwrought. This was an invitation to violence? The original WWE clip was a joke. Superimposing the CNN logo on the face of Vince McMahon was a joke on top of a joke. It was bad taste, but not incitement.

CNN, not unlike Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough, laughs all the way to the bank when Trump tangles with them. Like him, they’re in the eyeballs business. They might even subscribe to his philosophy that “all press is good press.” When he takes aim at them, it provides fodder for hour after hour of self-promotion disguised as news analysis.

The deep investigative report into the origins of the GIF, however, makes CNN look vindictive and petty. Just as Trump ought not to “punch down,” neither should CNN. The network claims that the GIF’s originator had also posted racist and anti-Semitic material in the past, and then issued a statement saying that out of concern for the man’s safety, they were withholding his identity. They added that the decision was subject to change if he didn’t behave himself.

Perhaps the GIF-maker is a racist moron. So what? Are they going to police Reddit now? Maybe that would be good public hygiene, but CNN is going down a rabbit hole here. In order for this to reflect on Trump, they would have to somehow demonstrate that the president was familiar with the previous offensive posts and retweeted the user anyway, which might be true, but seems unlikely and impossible to prove.

The point, surely, is that the president of the United States spent God only knows how much time scrolling through internet garbage to find this GIF.

With Donald Trump as president, we are living a reality TV show. He is doing what he has always done. A staggering percentage of what he says, and instructs his minions to say, is false.

The CNN logo GIF was a joke, but his attacks on anyone who criticizes him are not. His defenders call him a “counterpuncher.” But the president of the United States is not a tabloid celebrity trading jabs with other shallow publicity hounds willing to say anything to keep their ratings up.

If Donald Trump the TV star lashes out at Rosie O’Donnell, it’s entertainment. When the president of the United States launches a consistent campaign to delegitimize any news outlet that criticizes him as “fake news,” that’s corrosive. He has power now. It’s the job of the press to criticize him. Respect for the free press is American etiquette, not to mention law. And yes, of course Republicans get more biased coverage from most outlets than Democrats do, but Trump should be able to shrug that off with a joke and a smile. As only Sen. Ben Sasse has had the integrity to say, Trump is “weaponizing distrust” in an era when we are already crippled by mutual suspicion.

There is a seemingly inexhaustible well of antipathy toward the “MSM” (mainstream media) in the conservative world. But I just cannot see that Trump’s hostility toward the “failing New York Times” and the rest has anything to do with conservatism. It’s all personal. He almost never knocks them for biased reporting on health care or regulation or even immigration.

And so, while CNN did itself no favors this week, the president who cannot see past his own nose has little standing to protest.

Writes for Creators Syndicate.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Opinion

FRESH IDEAS: Murder Inc.

From The American Scholar: “Have you ever thought about killing someone? I have, and I confess that it brought me peculiar feelings of pleasure to fantasize about putting the hurt on someone who had wronged me. I am not alone. According to the evolutionary psychologist David Buss, who asked thousands of people this same question and reported...
OPINION: Can our divided history bring us together?

As a late-blooming Civil War buff, I have mixed feelings about the recently renewed national push to remove Confederate monuments across the nation. On one hand, the removal of hundreds of Confederate and related statues bears a troubling resemblance to efforts by Soviet dictator Josef Stalin or the Islamic State to selectively erase inconvenient history...
COMMENTARY: When did education become about narrowing horizons?

It’s 2017, just another year of experts sounding the death knell of the Humanities. By my reckoning, they’ve been dying longer than most first-year college students have been alive. Pundits tell us the cost of higher education is so high and the return on investment of an English, philosophy, history, language, or classics degree is so...
OPINION: Alt-right’s despicability doesn’t make ‘antifa’ the good guys

Fighting Nazis is a good thing, but fighting Nazis doesn’t necessarily make you or your cause good. By my lights this is simply an obvious fact. The greatest Nazi-killer of the 20th century was Josef Stalin. He also killed millions of his own people and terrorized, oppressed, enslaved or brutalized tens of millions more. The fact that he killed...
Commentary: Supporting students who want to stay here

This is the season when students are returning to university campuses across Ohio, including the University of Dayton and the Miami Valley region, to learn from their academic communities, and to advance communities far beyond them with their passion and innovation. As a former university administrator and now as a professor, I respectfully ask for...
More Stories