You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks


Welcome to

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on

Caution urged in redistricting congressional seats

Members of Congress warn of unintended consequences.

Ohio Gov. John Kasich argues that the current process for redrawing congressional districts should be relegated to the “dustbin of history.”

That’s all well and good, say lawmakers serving in Congress, but the details of such a proposal are important.

“It’s time to take a look at it, but it’s super-complicated and we have to make sure it’s thought through,” said Rep. Steve Stivers, R-Upper Arlington. “Because I’d rather make sure what we do has intended consequences and not unintended consequences.”

Ohio lost two congressional seats after the lines were redrawn following the 2010 Census, which also made some toss-up districts lean Republican and some safe Republican districts even safer. Since Republicans controlled the process, critics found plenty not to like in how the new districts were carved out.

But Democrats weren’t the only ones put in tricky situations.

Rep. Mike Turner, R-Dayton, and former Rep. Steve Austria, R-Beavercreek, had their districts largely combined. The same phenomenon occurred in northwest Ohio, where Rep. Marcy Kaptur, D-Toledo, found herself pitted against former Rep. Dennis Kucinich, D-Cleveland.

Kucinich ran against Kaptur and lost, while Austria chose not to run in a redrawn district that included all of Montgomery County, Turner’s home county.

Six years later, Turner admits the process “certainly was tumultuous,” but he says he’s hesitant to weigh in on Kasich’s comments until he says something more definitive.

But he does have one firm opinion on the process: Communities should be kept whole.

“The problem with gerrymandering either for political gain or enhanced competitiveness is you end up dividing a community,” he said.

In some cases, making a district more competitive might mean splitting a city in half. Turner said doing this confuses voters, who don’t know who represents them.

It’s better, he said, to have a lawmaker represent one community, regardless of whether it’s residents have like-minded political views or not.

“If you end up with communities like Dayton or Cincinnati or even the northern counties being divided, then you weaken their voice,” he said. “They don’t have one representative to go to and hold accountable for their performance.”

Last November Ohio voters overwhelmingly approved a plan to change the way legislative districts are drawn, but congressional district reform was left out of the ballot issue. The Ohio House and Senate — both dominated by Republicans — control congressional redistricting, which occurs every 10 years to adjust to changes in the Census.

Ohio could lose at least additional congressional seat because of population changes by the 2020 Census.

Members of Congress say they have little control over how their district boundaries are drawn. For example, when the lines were redrawn after the 2010 Census, Stivers said he wanted two things: to keep Union County and downtown Columbus.

He got neither.

Downtown Columbus went to Democratic Rep. Joyce Beatty, while Union County went to Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Urbana.

Overall, Republicans have 12 congressional districts in Ohio and Democrats have four. As with some others, Stivers’ district became more solidly Republican when the final map was approved.

“I got nothing I asked for,” he said. “I did get a better district even though I didn’t ask for a more Republican district.”

Another suburban Columbus Republican, Rep. Pat Tiberi, R-Genoa Twp., said he has talked with Kasich about the congressional redistricting process, and they share similar concerns.

Kasich, he said, “hasn’t communicated a prescriptive plan on it. He’s communicated the idea that the process needs to be more balanced. I wouldn’t disagree with that.”

Tiberi said there is no silver bullet that will make campaigns and districts fair and take the partisanship out of politics.

In fact, he said, some states have tried to take the politics out of the process and seen it become more political. He said that’s the case in Arizona, which has some of the most liberal and conservative districts in the nation.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

State softens plan to punish employers for not allowing guns on sites
State softens plan to punish employers for not allowing guns on sites

On Wednesday, the Ohio legislature reversed a plan to allow lawsuits for monetary damages if businesses violate a new law allowing concealed carry permit holders to bring guns onto other people’s property. After an outcry from business groups, the provision was changed in the state budget. The budget now goes to Ohio Gov. John Kasich. Last week...
VP Mike Pence in Cleveland promises replacement of ‘Obamacare’
VP Mike Pence in Cleveland promises replacement of ‘Obamacare’

Vice President Mike Pence said the administration is still working to pull Ohio Senator Rob Portman from “no” to “yes” on President Trump’s healthcare overhaul, which failed to receive a vote after Majority Leader Mitch McConnell pulled it Tuesday for lack of Republican support. Pence was visiting Cleveland...
A council member's solution to his Ohio town's overdose problem: Let addicts die
A council member's solution to his Ohio town's overdose problem: Let addicts die

Under a plan by a city council member in Ohio, people who dial 911 seeking help for someone who's overdosing on opioids may start hearing something new from dispatchers: "No." In response to the opioid epidemic that swept the nation - including the small city of Middletown, population 50,000 - Council member Dan Picard has floated an idea...
Ohio Senate passes Judy’s Law, day after burn victim dies
Ohio Senate passes Judy’s Law, day after burn victim dies

The day after Judy Malinowski died, the Ohio Senate voted to toughen penalties for people who disfigure crime victims. Malinowski was set on fire by her ex-boyfriend and had been hospitalized for nearly two years. The bill, which would allow longer prison sentences for crimes that disfigure victims, now heads to Gov. John Kasich. Franklin County Prosecutor...
Lawmakers pass freeze on new Medicaid signups, sets up showdown with governor
Lawmakers pass freeze on new Medicaid signups, sets up showdown with governor

A Medicaid enrollment freeze included in the state budget approved on Wednesday by the Ohio legislature could cause more than 500,000 Ohioans to lose coverage under expanded Medicaid rules in place since 2014, according to Ohio Gov. John Kasich’s Office of Health Transformation. The legislature voted along party lines for the $133 billion 2018-2019...
More Stories