The judge Trump disparaged as ‘Mexican’ will preside over an important border wall case

Trump attacked the federal judge for his race while the judge presided over a fraud case against Trump University.


The federal judge whom President Donald Trump disparaged as a "Mexican" during his campaign will preside over a case brought against one of the president's most highly touted initiatives: the U.S-Mexico border wall. 

District Judge Gonzalo Curiel, who was targeted by the president while he was the judge of a class-action lawsuit against the president's now-defunct Trump University, will on Friday hear the case brought by the state of California, some environmental groups and Rep. Raúl Grijalva , D-Ariz. It challenges waivers that were given to the federal branch more than 10 years ago to bypass some federal and state laws for border security. 

The case, which was initially three separate lawsuits before being consolidated by Curiel, represents a substantial legal challenge to the construction of Trump's potential border wall. 

Andrew Gordon, a former Department of Homeland Security lawyer during the Obama administration, told McClatchy, which first reported the story, that a ruling against the administration could slow plans for construction along the U.S.-Mexico border, even if the ruling is later overturned. 

"This is a very significant case," Gordon told the news service. 

The groups that have brought the lawsuit have a significant legal burden to meet. The waivers they challenge were granted in 1996 and 2005 to allow the federal government to bypass some federal and state laws, including environmental statutes, in the name of border security. 

Brian Segee, a lawyer with the Center for Biological Diversity, one of the plaintiffs, told McClatchy that a key debate will be whether Congress meant to waive these laws into the distant future or only for specific projects ongoing at the time the waivers were issued. 

California has argued that the construction of a border wall could do "irreparable harm," to its wildlife. Grijalva's suit maintains that previous environmental analyses are out of date and did not take into account updated border-security measures, including the potential construction of a border wall. 

It is yet another showdown in federal court over Trump's immigration policies. The lawsuit also brings Curiel, whose court is in San Diego, back into the national spotlight on a case about a topic that is nearly as synonymous with the president as his defunct university. 

The last time, as Curiel served as the judge over the case on some of the lawsuits which alleged fraud against Trump University, Trump began to attack him, when the candidate was still considered by most to be a longshot for the presidency though he had secured the GOP nomination. 

Perhaps most jarring was Trump's continued use of Curiel's ethnicity as a means to attack the federal judge's impartiality. Trump falsely asserted that Curiel was a "Mexican," - Curiel was born in Indiana - and other times said that he was "Hispanic," and "Spanish," seemingly as an attempt to argue that the judge was biased because of Trump's sharply conservative immigration ideas, including of course, the wall proposal. 

"Look, he's proud of his heritage, OK? I'm building a wall," Trump said of Curiel in June 2016 to CNN anchor Jake Tapper. "He's a Mexican. We're building a wall between here and Mexico." 

Trump's remarks, which he repeated at various points for months, drew some rebukes from his own party - even Paul Ryan called the remarks "racist" - and prompted the candidate to issue a statement that argued that his comments were being misconstrued. 

Curiel, whose parents were immigrants from Mexico, did not respond publicly to Trump's attacks. The fraud lawsuits ended in a $25 million settlement Trump agreed to pay out shortly after the election. 

Though Trump insisted during his campaign that Mexico would pay for the wall, Congress has sought to secure funding from American taxpayers. The amount of money for the project is currently a subject of ongoing budget negotiations that have already shut the federal government down once.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

U.S. may put tarriffs on China, other steel-producing countries
U.S. may put tarriffs on China, other steel-producing countries

U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross on Friday urged President Donald Trump to impose steep tariffs on China and other steel-producing countries, contending they are illegally dumping steel into U.S. markets. In a 262-page report that was praised by many Ohio lawmakers, Ross charged that imported steel products are priced “substantially lower&rdquo...
The new Hamilton fire chief has many to thank for his career, including his mother-in-law
The new Hamilton fire chief has many to thank for his career, including his mother-in-law

Some people, when they’re sworn in to a new city government position, bring a few family members with them. When new Hamilton Fire Chief Mark Mercer was sworn in on Wednesday, he brought a few … and a few more. They all gathered at the front of Hamilton City Council Chambers for the swearing-in ceremony. There was even one from New York...
Springboro to spend $200,000 on land for new park
Springboro to spend $200,000 on land for new park

The Springboro City Council authorized the city manager to pay $190,000 for 5.8 acres of residential property on Lytle-Five Points Road and shift $200,000 in city funds to pay for the land. The votes during Thursday’s council meeting came on two legislative items added to the agenda and approved on first readings. Supporters say the new park...
President Trump to visit Florida school shooting area today
President Trump to visit Florida school shooting area today

President Donald Trump says he leaves for Florida Friday to “meet with some of the bravest people.” Trump’s tweet did not elaborate on his plans. But White House officials are working to arrange a visit to Florida in the wake of this week’s deadly school shooting. Trump writes that he’ll meet with “people whose lives...
With McCain’s retreat, some look to Romney to carry traditional GOP torch
With McCain’s retreat, some look to Romney to carry traditional GOP torch

In more ways than one, followers of traditional Republican orthodoxy are facing an emotional inflection point this week.  Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., at home battling an aggressive form of brain cancer, will not attend this weekend's Munich Security Conference, an annual gathering of foreign policy leaders from NATO nations that has become a central...
More Stories