With primary elections coming soon, some wonder if they’re worth it

Feb. 7 is the filing deadline for the 2018 primary elections, and both Butler County Republicans and Democrats will have choices to make.

There are potentially four GOP primary races in which voters will decide who will run for election in November. There’s only one contested primary race on the Democratic Party side.

RELATED: Reformer says Republican plan wouldn’t end gerrymandering

On the Republican side:

  • Four likely Republicans — Matthew Taggart, Greg Jolivette, David T. Davidson and Sara Carruthers — are considering a challenge of incumbent Ohio Rep. Wes Retherford, R-Hamilton, for his 51st Ohio House District seat.
  • Just one primary challenger — Roshawn Lavelle Jenkins — has pulled petitions to challenge incumbent Ohio Rep. Candice Keller, R-Middletown, for her 53rd Ohio House District seat.
  • West Chester Twp. Trustee Lee Wong is also challenging Butler County Commissioner Cindy Carpenter.
  • Congressman Warren Davidson, of Troy, may have a challenger in Zach Smith, of Trenton.

On the Democratic Party side, the only primary challenge will be a four-way race for Ohio’s 8th Congressional District seat: William Ebben, of West Chester Twp.; Morton Meier, of Hamilton; Vanessa Enoch, of West Chester Twp.; and Ted Jones, of Piqua.

In most cases in Butler County, incumbent candidates go uncontested in a primary election. There are about several dozen Butler County-specific primaries set for the May 8 primary for Republicans and Democrats.

“Contested primaries are a source of vitality,” said University of Cincinnati political science professor David Niven. He said such races are when “new voices” and “new activists” are born.

“In strong party counties, primaries help keep the party responsive. There are some wasted dollars and some hurt feelings, but the party comes out ahead in the end,” he said. “In competitive counties, on the other hand, primaries really do represent the loss of vital resources and a threat to November success.”

RELATED: Trump rips Kasich at GOP dinner in Washington

Political parties, however, don’t want to see a contested primary, said Xavier University political science professor Mack Mariani.

In contested primaries, candidates spend a lot of political capital and campaign finances on a partisan opponent and will have to rebuild that momentum for a run in the general election in November.

But he said “primaries are valuable” because they allow candidates to be vetted, and the strongest candidate, in theory, advances to the general election. With primaries, you can avoid sedning on an unexpectedly weak candidate, or a candidate who has problems.

“You don’t want to find out your candidate is terrible on the campaign trail in November,” Mariani said.

“Vetting your candidates is critical. (Parties are) not going to investigate their own candidates, though, with the same enthusiasm as your (general election) opponents. The smart way is to investigate your candidate with the same amount of rigor (as a general election opponent).”

Miami University political science professor Christopher Kelley would like to see the primary system abandoned and political parties pick their own nominees.

RELATED: Trump honors Cincinnati man held by N. Korea during State of the Union

That would reduce the financial burden of the county and state, as taxpayers foot the bill for political parties to nominate a candidate for the general election, he said. In most cases, primary candidates run unopposed or against a weak opponent.

“And primaries have such low turnout, so you get the most extreme turnout and you have a lopsided result,” he said.

Hundreds of thousands of dollars are spent on elections each year in the county, and some of that could be saved without holding local and state race primaries.

However, Kelley said when parties did have control over their choice of nominees, “that meant minorities, women and working-class people rarely, or never in many cases, were selected by the party bosses to run (for office).”


Here are who’s considering a run for this year’s primary and general election races, as of Feb. 2:

8th Ohio House District Representative


Ohio Rep. Warren Davidson, of Troy

Zach Smith, of Trenton


William Ebben, of West Chester Twp.

Morton Meier, of Hamilton

Vanessa Enoch, of West Chester Twp.

Ted Jones, of Piqua

51st Ohio House


Ohio Rep. Wes Retherford, of Hamilton

Matthew Taggart, of Hamilton

Greg Jolivette, of Hamilton

Sara Carruthers, of Hamilton

David Davidson, of Hamilton


Susan Vaughn, of Hamilton

52nd Ohio House


Ohio Rep. George Lang, of West Chester Twp.


Kathy Wyenandt, of Liberty Twp.

53rd Ohio House


Ohio Rep. Candice Keller, of Middletown

Roshawn Lavelle Jenkins, of Monroe

Butler County Commissioner


Butler County Commissioner Cindy Carpenter, of Oxford

West Chester Twp. Trustee Lee Wong, of West Chester


NAACP Middletown President Dora Bronston, of Middletown

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Wright-Patt training exercise sets off booms
Wright-Patt training exercise sets off booms

If you heard a loud noise today at Wright-Patterson, it was all part of training, a base spokesman says. The Dayton Daily News and News Center 7 were contacted by residents inquiring what was the cause of the explosion. A Wright-Patterson Explosive Ordnance Disposal bomb squad was scheduled to set off three explosions between noon and 4 p.m. Wednesday...
Kettering substitute accused of sex with students ruled competent to stand trial
Kettering substitute accused of sex with students ruled competent to stand trial

A judge has ruled the Kettering Fairmont High School substitute teacher accused of having sex with two students in a Big Lots and apartment complex parking lot is competent to stand trial, officials said. Madeline J. Marx, 23, is charged with sexual battery. A 17-year-old student told police he was given oral sex by a teacher July 19 in the parking...
Illegal immigrants dealt kilos of fentanyl in Miami County, feds say
Illegal immigrants dealt kilos of fentanyl in Miami County, feds say

Two illegal immigrants from Mexico have been charged with intent to distribute several kilograms worth of fentanyl in Miami County, according to court documents. Nabor Zapeda-Ibarria, 23, and Jesus Mayorga Gonzalez, 40, have been charged with possession and intent to distribute more than 400 grams of fentanyl in Dayton’s U.S. District Court....
New Miami asks Ohio Supreme Court to stop $3M speed camera lawsuit. The speeders’ response: Stop stalling.
New Miami asks Ohio Supreme Court to stop $3M speed camera lawsuit. The speeders’ response: Stop stalling.

The New Miami speed camera case will continue, this time to Columbus and the Ohio Supreme Court. The village’s outside counsel James Englert confirmed it will take the case to the high court now that the 12th District Court of Appeals sided with the speeders in the $3 million-plus case. The village will ask Ohio’s high court to rule that...
First of two men convicted of killing mother in front of her child sentenced to prison
First of two men convicted of killing mother in front of her child sentenced to prison

One of two men convicted of killing Brittany Russell was sentenced in court Wednesday.  Curtis Howard Burdette, 39, of Dayton was sentenced to the maximum sentence of 25 years in prison Wednesday, according to a release from the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office.  Burdette was found guilty in March 2017 on charges of involuntary...
More Stories