Sports Today: Baseball writers get it right on Hall of Fame, for now


I have to concur with the esteemed Hal McCoy in regards to the Baseball Hall of Fame voting: The BBWAA did a nice job this year in choosing Chipper Jones, Vladimir Guerrero, Jim Those and Trevor Hoffman. 

Jones was a great all-around player on some great teams, Guerrero was one of the game’s great talents, Thome hit 600 home runs and Hoffman was one of the premier closers ever. He also helped establish the ethos of cool that comes with being the guy brought in to slam the door in the ninth inning (even though one-inning closers are kind of overrated in general). 

READ MORE at Hal’s blog

I would not vote for Edgar Martinez because he was pretty much exclusively a DH, but it won’t be the end of the world if guys like him and David Ortiz eventually get in. 

I am surprised Scott Rolen only got a little more than 10 percent of the vote, but perhaps he will gain some steam as the years advance. Of course, he’s certainly not a first-ballot HOFer anyway. 

The only real complaint I would have is erstwhile Daytonian Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds got more than 50 percent of the vote, which is 100 percent more than they deserve (although Bud Selig getting in is a far bigger travesty than it would be if they did).

I know not all of the artificial body-builders got caught and the hall is already home to some unsavory characters, but that doesn’t mean those guys get a pass. 

The Steroid Era was ultimately bad for baseball, a temporary sugar rush is still being paid for today. 

RELATED: 5 ways to make baseball even better

Those who can be confidently judged to have juiced should not get into the hall. 

(That’s why Manny Ramirez, as great a hitter as he was, shouldn’t get in, either. Ditto Alex Rodriguez.) 

JOE MORGAN to HOF voters: Don’t admit PED users

The great fears of the steroid era were that players would be tempted to poison themselves to keep up and the records that have always bound together the eras would be ruined. 

Both of those things happened. 

(Case in point: How did the fanfare for Albert Pujols’ joining the 600-home run club last season compare to previous players to do it?) 

The numbers of Bonds and Clemens shouldn’t be stricken from the record book or adorned with an asterisk, but they shouldn’t be afforded the ultimate honor for playing the game, either… 

Another sign baseball is right around the corner? 

The Cincinnati Reds winter caravan kicks off tonight with four different groups going in four different directions. 

The northern leg will be a the Air Force Museum beginning at 11 a.m. Saturday and go to the Parrish Auditorium in Hamilton after that. 

It begins tonight in Columbus at the Polaris mall. 

This was where Reds owner Bob Castellini talked about Brandon Phillips’ future (he was eventually traded to the Braves) and declared he wants Billy Hamilton to be a Red forever. 

The big boss isn’t on this trip this year, but the group as a whole is pretty interesting: Jeff Brantley and Jim Day, pitcher Amir Garrett, former Dragons catcher Tyler Stephenson, former Reds first baseman Todd Benzinger and GM Dick Williams… 

Did the Dayton women’s basketball team win last night? 

Well, did they play? 

Then yes. 

The Flyers improved to 8-0 in the Atlantic 10 with a 66-59 win at Richmond on Wednesday night

Is this program rolling or what? 

Jayla Scaife led five Flyers in double figures in scoring with 15 points while JaVonna Layfield added 10 points and 15 rebounds. 

Dayton held the Spiders to 29.7 percent shooting for the game and won the battle of the boards while overcoming 20 turnovers. 

The Flyers remain on the road Saturday when they play at Davidson. 

Dayton was 60th in the RPI heading into last night, one spot behind Duquesne. The Dukes, who are also undefeated in league play, visit UD Arena next Wednesday night… 

Lastly, congratulations go out to Wayne for topping Springfield in an overtime thriller in Huber Heights

In the first of two matchups this regular season, the top-ranked Warriors held serve, remaining unbeaten and handing the Wildcats their first loss, 65-62. 

Deshone Parker led Wayne with 15 points while future Ohio State football player Blue Smith added 13. 

RaHeim Moss scored 25 for the Wildcats while Leonard Taylor added 10 on a night lots of notable people were in attendance. 

Among the sellout crowd were college football coaches from the University of Cincinnati, Louisville and Kentucky, all to see uncommitted Leonard Taylor of Springfield. There were plenty of high-profile alums mixing about, too, including the Landers brothers, Wayne grads Trey (Dayton basketball) and Robert (Ohio State football), and Wayne grad Marcus Freeman, a Cincinnati defensive coordinator who huddled with Taylor afterward.

Coach Isaiah Carson’s Springfield squad gets another shot at Wayne on Feb. 9. 

“We ain’t got nothin’ to hang our heads over,” Carson said. “We lost to a good team. We’ll get better for it. We played our hearts out and had our chances. We just came up a little bit short.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Wayne, Trotwood finish top 5 in final state polls
Wayne, Trotwood finish top 5 in final state polls

GWOC reps Wayne and Trotwood-Madison finished among the top 10 in their respective divisions of the final Associated Press boys state basketball polls that were released on Tuesday. No. 1 most of the season, Wayne (20-1) finished No. 3 in D-I. Trotwood (19-3) was No. 5 in D-II. Both are top seeds in their sectionals. Two Midwest Athletic Conference...
7 things to know about Urbana University football
7 things to know about Urbana University football

The Miami Valley offers no shortage of options when it comes to furthering a football career after high school.  Tyler Haines wants to make sure area players know Urbana University is one.  Here are seven things to know about the Blue Knights: After winning two games his first season and three in his second, Haines led the Blue Knights to...
Reds pitcher making strides with help from teammate

Cody Reed’s obvious talents have yet to lead to major-league success. That’s where fellow pitcher Michael Lorenzen enters the picture. Lorenzen’s locker is a few feet from Reed’s and the two talk a lot. It appears Lorenzen has been able to turn the light switch on for Reed, who does not want to be remembered as the guy the Reds...
5 things to know about Wright State’s win against Cleveland State
5 things to know about Wright State’s win against Cleveland State

For the fifth time this season Wright State rallied from at least eight points down to win, beating Cleveland State 72-63 Monday night to remain tied with Northern Kentucky for first place in the Horizon League. The win sets up a three-team weekend showdown between the Raiders, NKU and UIC to determine the regular-season champion and No....
State swimming: Fairmont’s Berning confident heading to Canton
State swimming: Fairmont’s Berning confident heading to Canton

Margaret Berning’s swimming career has taken her to places like Mesa, Ariz., San Antonio, Minneapolis and Orlando. The next destination? The Fairmont High School senior hopes to visit the top of the podium at the Division I swimming and diving state championships Saturday in Canton. Berning makes her fourth state appearance at the C.T. Branin...
More Stories