Bobblehead tax rears ugly head for Reds


Should you — and the Cincinnati Reds — pay sales tax on that Eugenio Suarez bobblehead?

That’s increasingly the issue for the Reds — or least one of the issues for a team that has finished in last place for the past three years.

The Associated Press has previously noted that the Ohio Supreme Court has agreed to hear arguments in a dispute over promotions offered by the Reds to ticket buyers — including bobbleheads and other items, meant to get fans in the seats at Great American Ballpark.

MOREDying on the job: 164 workers killed in Ohio 

“At issue is whether the Reds are exempt from paying tax on the purchase of the promotional items,” the AP reported.

Attorneys for the Reds say they don’t have to pay tax on the purchase of these sorts of items because they essentially are part of the cost of a fan’s ticket package.

MOREPlumber recovers Trotwood woman’s $30K heirloom ring set

Ohio law exempts companies from paying tax on items they buy to resell.

However, there’s disagreement about that. The state tax commissioner says the promotional items should be taxed because the Reds bought the items as giveaways and they aren’t selling them with tickets.

In a blog post by Jonathan Entin — professor emeritus of law and adjunct professor of political science at Case Western Reserve University — at the web site, The Conversation, he writes that baseball teams maintain that their memorabilia are like “grocery bags or Happy Meals. The Reds say they factor the cost of those items into their ticket prices for every game during the season, so they should not have to pay a separate sales tax when they purchase them to give to fans as promotions.”

OPENING TODAYDowntown Dayton bike shop re-opened

The Ohio tax commissioner has disagreed with that analysis, Entin wrote.

“Upon review of the record before us, however, we conclude that the promotional items given to patrons on specific game days were not ‘resold’ to the patrons as part of the ticket price of admission, but were given away for free, primarily to increase interest in certain targeted games or generally increase interest among a broader audience,” said a June 2017 filing by the Ohio Board of Tax Appeals.

The three-member board unanimously concluded that the appellant (the Reds) “has not provided this board with competent and probative evidence in support of the position that it does not owe the assessed tax.”

The case is now before the Ohio Supreme Court. The Reds moved for an oral argument before the whole court, and that motion was granted Feb. 21. No date for the hearing is on the court docket.

Ohio has a state rate of 5.75 percent and Cincinnati imposes a 0.75 percent levy on top of that, so tens of thousands are at stake, Entin wrote. And maybe more, if the commissioner seeks back taxes.



Reader Comments


Next Up in Business

City buys riverfront land for new ‘entertainment district’
City buys riverfront land for new ‘entertainment district’

Another piece in a long-planned “entertainment district” along the Great Miami River appears to have fallen in place. Property records are showing that the city of West Carrollton has bought riverfront property along Marina Drive for the potential district. The city picked up about a half-acre of former auto dealership property at 5649...
Tech firm wins $100K to work on AFRL data
Tech firm wins $100K to work on AFRL data

A Miamisburg technology firm, Ignyte Assurance Platform —which last summer changed its name from MAFAZO LLC — has received Ohio Third Frontier funding to work with the Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL) , based at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base. The company was awarded $100,000 to develop and integrate cybersecurity technology from the...
Tech firm to move into renovated historic downtown  building
Tech firm to move into renovated historic downtown  building

A start-up software company has been identified as the first tenant in a new Woodard Development project. The cyber-physical software company Tangram Flex will occupy nearly 7,000 square feet of the fifth floor of the building located at 607 E Third St. beginning in April 2019. MORE: Why optimism has fled the auto industry The company is expected...
Why optimism has fled the auto industry
Why optimism has fled the auto industry

Auto dealers today are no longer optimistic about market conditions, a new survey has found. The Q4 2018 Cox Automotive Dealer Sentiment Index takes measure of how U.S. auto dealers, both franchised and independent, are feeling about the auto business and vehicle sales. The survey was taken between Oct. 24 and Nov. 6, 2018, with questions focused on...
Dayton Air Show leader inducted into national hall of fame
Dayton Air Show leader inducted into national hall of fame

Dayton Air Show Executive Director Terry Grevious has been inducted into the National Air Show Hall of Fame. Grevious was inducted into the hall of fame over the weekend at the International Council of Air Shows Annual Conference in Las Vegas. He has spent more than 40 years in the air show industry, managing the Flint Bishop Air Show, Muskegon Air...
More Stories