Good Sam civil rights complaint: 5 things to know


The civil rights complaint about Good Samaritan Hospital closing is being investigated by U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

Here’s five things to know about the story so far and what’s next.

MORE: Health centers plan for future after Good Samaritan Hospital closes

1. The complaint is early in the process of being investigated

When a complaint is filed with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the department’s Office of Civil Rights first reviews whether it has the legal authority to investigate the complaint.

If it does have the authority to look into the particular complaint, an investigator is assigned. This is what just happened with Good Samaritan case.

The investigator will gather information about the complaint. This research can include things like interviews or site visits.

The Office of Civil Rights will eventually issue a decision on whether or not civil rights have been violated. If rights have been violated, the provider being investigated — which in this case is the hospital — would come up with an action that corrects the violation.

2. The complaint says the hospital closing violates the Civil Rights Act and the Affordable Care Act

The group of clergy, which have organized as Clergy Community Coalition, originally filed the complaint with the U.S. in May, which says the closure will “have a discriminatory and separate adverse impact on African Americans and women” in violation of the Civil Rights Act and under the Affordable Care Act.

The Dayton-area residents for whom Good Samaritan is the closest hospital are 75 percent African American, according to the complaint. Some of the concerns include longer travel times to health services, the loss of the ER and the loss of the maternity unit and OB/GYN services.

MORE: Big check means big things for Dayton Gem City Market

Premier Health said in a statement Tuesday afternoon that the hospital network “has been mindful of the community’s concerns from the very beginning of this process and has remained true to its mission throughout this transition.”

“From the beginning, patient safety has been our guiding principle for determining our timeline for the closing. While we will cooperate with any investigation, this week’s timeline remains unchanged,” Premier stated.

3. In the mean time, the hospital is still scheduled to close soon

The ER will close at noon tomorrow, July 19, and the hospital will close its doors for the final time at 12:01 a.m. Monday, July 23.

There’s no timetable yet on the demolition work. Religious artifacts at the Catholic-affiliated hospital will have to be appropriately transferred to new locations and demolition projects have to get certain regulatory approvals. Premier has said it will be a long term process.

4. The investigation prompted the Dayton mayor to weigh in.

Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley has asked Premier Health to delay any demolition of Good Samaritan Hospital to allow time to complete the federal investigation.

“In light of the now opened federal investigation regarding the closing of Good Samaritan Hospital, I call on Premier to commit to not demolish or disable the buildings on the campus until this investigation, all legal proceedings and the community planning process are complete,” Whaley said Tuesday.

MORE: Dayton hospital cuts ER wait times

5. The settlement of another civil rights case over a hospital closing drew criticism

A civil rights complaint with similar concerns was filed in 2009 against University of Pittsburgh Medical Center over the planned closure of a hospital in a primarily black service area.

The hospital never reopened, but after the complaint was filed, an agreement was reached between the hospital and HHS that resulted in support for a transportation service to another facility, and an expansion of primary care services and hours. However, community members have been critical of the plan’s implementation, saying the expanded hours ended after a few years, and those near to the former hospital still have problems with access to health care.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Miami Valley Hospital to build out last of empty floors
Miami Valley Hospital to build out last of empty floors

Miami Valley Hospital is building out the 10th and 11th floors of its southeast tower, which were left empty space in 2010 to leave room for expansion. The Dayton hospital, operated by Premier Health, said in a statement that it just opened an upgraded 36-bed neuroscience advanced care unit on the 10th floor and is set to finish construction next month...
Ohio thieves target these vehicles more than any other
Ohio thieves target these vehicles more than any other

The National Insurance Crime Bureau has released its annual “Hot Wheels” report, identifying the 10 most stolen vehicles in the United States — and in Ohio. The report examines vehicle theft data submitted by law enforcement to the National Crime Information Center and determines the vehicle make, model and model year most reported...
Downtown storage company served the rich and famous
Downtown storage company served the rich and famous

A storage company that the rich and Dayton famous had long entrusted with their art, pianos and silver is still in business today and operates as it did in 1916. Lincoln Storage and Moving’s century-old headquarters at 315 E. First St. is now surrounded by newcomers as new construction and rehabilitation continues to transform the Webster Station...
These Android phones have security defects out of the box
These Android phones have security defects out of the box

At least 25 Android smartphone models — 11 of which are sold by major U.S. carriers — carry vulnerabilities out of the box, making them easy prey for hackers, according to a new study from security researchers. Researchers from the firm Kryptowire found 38 vulnerabilities in 25 Android phones, according to Wired. They range from being able...
Car tech firm is bringing secret weapon to the streets of Sacramento
Car tech firm is bringing secret weapon to the streets of Sacramento

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A Silicon Valley tech company recently posted a video front and center on its website that may startle some Sacramentans. It shows a sleek black car driving across the Tower Bridge … with no one in it. The company, Phantom Auto, is a key player in the emerging world of autonomous vehicles. But the car cruising across...
More Stories