Baby born on I-75 in Dayton

Should tax cuts mean lower electric bills? DP&L and others say no

Federal tax cuts may not mean lower electric bills, at least not right away, if the joint stance of Ohio utilities is any indication.

Dayton Power & Light and other Ohio electric utilities are jointly arguing against a Public Utilities Commission of Ohio order calling for an investigation into whether the utilities should lower rates in the wake of the recent federal tax cut and reform package.

RELATEDDP&L has given hints of financial stresses

In a Jan. 10 order, the PUCO said it wanted to examine whether power companies could “pass benefits resulting from the legislation (the tax package) on to rate payers.”

The companies jointly replied last week, asking that the PUCO clarify its intentions.

RELATEDDP&L owner to cut 160 jobs and appoint new CEO

“As a legal and practical matter, the commission (PUCO) should affirmatively declare that the accounting directive is without prejudice to the outcome of this proceeding as well as any other rider or rate-making proceeding,” the utilities said in their joint filing.

The filing went on to marshal a number of legal arguments against the investigation, drawing a response from the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel.

“DP&L and other electric utilities have filed at the PUCO to prevent or limit reducing their rates to share federal corporate tax cuts with Ohio consumers,” the office said in a statement Tuesday. “Once again, the utilities are attempting to use Ohio’s 2008 energy law to favor themselves over consumers in the rate-setting process.”

RELATEDOpponents say Senate bill would raise DP&L rates

The consumer counsel’s office thinks utility consumers should see reduced charges as a result of the federal corporate tax cuts.

One objection the utilities — DP&L, FirstEnergy, American Electric Power and Duke Energy — are raising in their PUCO filing is that lowering rates now would amount to “retroactive rate-making.”

Also citing a 2008 state law on “electric security plans,” they argue that the PUCO cannot reduce rates without the companies’ consent.

Though “electric security plans” were formed to protect utilities’ financial position in what was meant to be a more competitive environment, Bruce Weston, Ohio consumers’ counsel, has asked legislators to consider getting rid of them altogether.

In a statement, a spokeswoman for DP&L said the company has prices that are “currently the lowest in the state.”

“Ohio utilities cannot raise or lower rates without approval through a formal regulatory process,” DP&L’s statement said. “We are committed to working with Ohio regulators to seek out the most effective way for our customers to realize any savings resulting from the new tax law.”

A spokesman for Duke Energy, which serves customers in Warren County, said the PUCO’s Jan. 10 order demands clarity and a transparent process.

“From Duke Energy’s perspective, we remain committed to working with our Ohio regulators to determine the most practical way for our customers to realize the savings from the new tax law,” Duke spokesman Lee Freedman said in an email. “There are many ways to incorporate the savings, from decreasing rates to mitigating the impact of future increases.

“Like any changes to our rates, we must gain formal regulatory approval before implementing any customer savings from the new tax law,” he added.

“You would be solving a lot of problems and doing a lot of good for Ohioans by reforming the 2008 law to eliminate electric security plans,” Weston testified before the Ohio House Public Utilities Committee last month.

A message seeking comment was left with a spokesman for the PUCO. 

Reader Comments

Next Up in Business

City buys riverfront land for new ‘entertainment district’
City buys riverfront land for new ‘entertainment district’

Another piece in a long-planned “entertainment district” along the Great Miami River appears to have fallen in place. Property records are showing that the city of West Carrollton has bought riverfront property along Marina Drive for the potential district. The city picked up about a half-acre of former auto dealership property at 5649...
Tech firm wins $100K to work on AFRL data
Tech firm wins $100K to work on AFRL data

A Miamisburg technology firm, Ignyte Assurance Platform —which last summer changed its name from MAFAZO LLC — has received Ohio Third Frontier funding to work with the Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL) , based at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base. The company was awarded $100,000 to develop and integrate cybersecurity technology from the...
Tech firm to move into renovated historic downtown  building
Tech firm to move into renovated historic downtown  building

A start-up software company has been identified as the first tenant in a new Woodard Development project. The cyber-physical software company Tangram Flex will occupy nearly 7,000 square feet of the fifth floor of the building located at 607 E Third St. beginning in April 2019. MORE: Why optimism has fled the auto industry The company is expected...
Why optimism has fled the auto industry
Why optimism has fled the auto industry

Auto dealers today are no longer optimistic about market conditions, a new survey has found. The Q4 2018 Cox Automotive Dealer Sentiment Index takes measure of how U.S. auto dealers, both franchised and independent, are feeling about the auto business and vehicle sales. The survey was taken between Oct. 24 and Nov. 6, 2018, with questions focused on...
Dayton Air Show leader inducted into national hall of fame
Dayton Air Show leader inducted into national hall of fame

Dayton Air Show Executive Director Terry Grevious has been inducted into the National Air Show Hall of Fame. Grevious was inducted into the hall of fame over the weekend at the International Council of Air Shows Annual Conference in Las Vegas. He has spent more than 40 years in the air show industry, managing the Flint Bishop Air Show, Muskegon Air...
More Stories