Attorney: Homicide charge discussed against Dayton woman in deadly police chase


A homicide charge is being discussed for a Dayton woman accused of prompting a deadly high-speed Moraine police chase in Miami Twp. last month, according to her attorney.

The Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office is considering that count against Alyssa Irwin-Debraux after the Sept. 11 fatal crash on Ohio 741 involving Officer Matt Barrie and a Lebanon Realtor not involved in the pursuit, said defense attorney Travis Kane.

Mary Taulbee was pronounced dead after the Carnation Road collision that ended Barrie’s chase for a Jeep reported stolen minutes earlier.

RELATED: Prosecutors in woman’s rape claim in deadly police chase: ‘Evidence will come out’

Kane said he spoke Thursday with a prosecutor while his client remains in the Montgomery County Jail, where she has been in custody on a $25,000 cash bond, records show.

“That investigation will take some time and they’ll make the decision if they want to go forward with that,” Kane said. “In the event there are homicide charges filed then that will definitely cause a change in circumstances.”

Irwin-Debraux, 18, was indicted last month on grand theft in connection with the stolen Jeep. A judge last week entered a not guilty plea for her. Her next court date is Oct. 15.

RELATED: Driver in deadly police chase says she stole Jeep to avoid rape

Irwin-Debraux said she stole the Jeep to escape a rape, according to witness statements made in a Miami Twp. police report obtained by this news organization through a public records request.

Kane declined to comment on the rape claim. But prosecutors said they have “considerably different” information than what witnesses said Irwin-Debraux told them after she crashed the Jeep near the Dayton Mall after the fatal crash.

Asked to comment on the validity of the reported claim by Irwin-Debraux, prosecutor’s office Spokesman Greg Flannagan responded, “The information you have is considerably different than the information that we have.”

When asked to elaborate, Flannagan added in an email, “The evidence will come out when this case proceeds to trial.”

RELATED: NEW REPORT: Driver in deadly police chase had drugs in system, no license

The owner of the Jeep reported it stolen from Harrison Twp. just after 6 p.m. Sept. 11 and said she was tracking it on GPS when it entered Moraine, records show.

Before the theft, the owner’s fiancee said he left keys in the Jeep as he exited it to talk to a co-worker. About 15 minutes later, the fiancee said, the vehicle was gone.

Information about the stolen vehicle was relayed to Moraine police and, minutes later, Barrie said he spotted a vehicle matching the Jeep’s description.

Records show Barrie sought to perform a traffic stop on Ohio 741 in Moraine and the Jeep fled. Barrie received permission to pursue, recording speeds up to 80 miles per hour southbound into Miami Twp., according to police documents.

RELATED: Dayton theft suspect in police chase that led to deadly crash in court

As the Jeep and the police cruiser approached Carnation Road, a Hyundai driven by Taulbee, 57, and a Chrysler driven by Brandon Miller, 32, of Centerville, were both heading north on Ohio 741, according to the Ohio State Highway Patrol.

The Chrysler swerved to avoid the Jeep and struck the Hyundai. Taulbee’s car then “spun out of control, crossed the center line and into the path” of the Moraine patrol car, according to the state report.

Taulbee – a Realtor in Dayton, Englewood, Lebanon, Miamisburg, Springboro and Washington Twp. – was pronounced dead at Kettering Hospital.

-MORE COVERAGE ON THIS ISSUE:

RELATED: NEW DETAILS: Police chase reached 80 mph just before a collision killing area Realtor

RELATED: Stolen Jeep owner: Police officer’s life changed, ‘and a woman’s gone’

RELATED: Services for area Realtor who died from collision in police chase

RELATED: NEW DETAILS: What happened in the minutes before a fatal police pursuit crash

RELATED: Moraine cop involved in fatal pursuit crash was city’s officer of the year

RELATED: Longtime Realtor struck and killed in high-speed police chase

RELATED: NEW DETAILS: Lebanon woman’s car was pushed into Moraine cruiser’s path

RELATED: Woman killed in Moraine police chase of reported stolen car



Reader Comments


Next Up in Local

Richmond school shooting: ‘It sounded like a pistol,’ fifth-grader says of gunshots
Richmond school shooting: ‘It sounded like a pistol,’ fifth-grader says of gunshots

It started as a normal morning today at Dennis Intermediate School, but ended with the suicide of a 14-year-old who shot his way into the school. “It was calm until they said it was a lockdown. Everybody thought it was a drill until they said it again really fast,” said fifth-grader Jayla Henderson. Then, moments later, Jayla said she and...
Driver arraigned in crash that injured Northwestern school board member, killed husband
Driver arraigned in crash that injured Northwestern school board member, killed husband

A Sidney man pleaded not guilty this week to misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter in a June 30, three-vehicle crash that injured a Northwestern school board member and killed her husband. Charles Robbins 61, appeared in Miami County Municipal Court. He is free without bail. A pretrial hearing was scheduled for Jan. 17. Miami County Sheriff’s deputies...
Ohio Gov. John Kasich says he has no regrets after 8 years in office
Ohio Gov. John Kasich says he has no regrets after 8 years in office

Republican Gov. John Kasich, who leaves office next month, put it all on the record Thursday at a lunch meeting with the press. Here is what we learned: 1. No Regrets. “I’m totally thrilled with the eight years. It was a great time,” he said. “There is one little regret I’m not going to tell you. I’m really...
Study finds heavy metals in popular baby food brands
Study finds heavy metals in popular baby food brands

A recent Consumer Reports study revealed the presence of heavy metals in popular baby foods. Dan Snyder would do anything for his son Austin. So when he found out his son’s baby food was listed on Consumer Reports’ heavy metals list, he was concerned. “We were shocked to see how many baby foods out there that are on the market that...
Partial government shutdown possible: Here’s what it means for Wright-Patt
Partial government shutdown possible: Here’s what it means for Wright-Patt

A quarter of the federal government could shut down just before Christmas if lawmakers don’t agree on a spending bill, but the area’s largest federal employer should escape closing. Wright-Patterson Air Force Base is not expected to close if President Donald Trump continues his threat to force a partial government shutdown if Congress does...
More Stories