County blames health care provider for jail inmate’s injuries

Sheriff: Officers used “reasonable force” against severely injured inmate at Montgomery County Jail.


The Montgomery County Sheriff’s Office has filed a complaint against the company it uses for health care at the jail, alleging it didn’t provide proper medical care to a homeless veteran who received injuries at the jail that left him wheelchair-bound.

The complaint was filed as part of former inmate Joseph Guglielmo’s federal lawsuit against Sheriff Phil Plummer and the county. In the lawsuit, Guglielmo alleges he was brutally beaten by guards in January 2015 while other officers blocked the view of video cameras.

RELATED: Homeless veteran beaten into coma in jail, lawsuit alleges

But in its legal complaint, the sheriff’s office says NaphCare, which provides medical services at the jail, should be held responsible for any damages Guglielmo suffered.

The complaint alleges Guglielmo entered the jail with head injuries from fighting with Dayton police when he was arrested at a homeless shelter. He suffered additional damage by banging his head against the wall and in a scuffle with corrections officers, who used “reasonable” force, according to the sheriff’s office.

RELATED: Officer cleared for alleged beating of homeless vet, records show

After the altercation, Guglielmo was seen by a NaphCare nurse who gave him an ice pack and had him moved to another cell for closer observation, the sheriff’s complaint says. Guglielmo was later found unresponsive in his cell and taken to the hospital, where he underwent emergency surgery and spent two months in a coma.

“(NaphCare employees) were deliberately indifferent to and/or acted with callous/reckless disregard for those serious medical and mental health needs in failing and/or refusing to provide the necessary medical care, assessment, evaluation, intervention, referral and treatment,” the sheriff’s office complaint says.

SPECIAL REPORT: Justice in the Jailhouse - Lawsuits, accusations plague county jails in the region.

In a response filed with the court, NaphCare’s attorneys wrote that the company provided proper medical care for Guglielmo, and noted that he alleges in his lawsuit that a corrections officer beat him and threw him against a concrete wall to “teach (him) a lesson.”

The company is arguing the complaint should be dismissed because, among other things, Guglielmo didn’t name NaphCare in his lawsuit.

RELATED: Sergeant named in jail assault lawsuit sought demotion

“(The county’s) allegations that NaphCare defendants exhibited deliberate indifference and reckless disregard to Mr. Guglielmo’s medical needs are baseless,” the company’s response says.

Montgomery County last year entered into a contract to pay NaphCare up to $3.55 million a year through 2019 for inmate medical services.

RELATED: Montgomery County Jail health care provider faces discipline

JUSTICE N THE JAILHOUSE

15 lawsuits allege mistreatment of inmates at area jails

Officer who sheriff tried to charge for jail assault claims unfairness (VIDEO)

Jail cameras capture some drama, little detail (VIDEO)

Lawsuits allege deadly neglect of inmates in Butler, Warren counties

Officers spit on, attacked in jails bursting with mentally ill (VIDEO)

More oversight sought for area jails



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Special Forces veteran’s missing dog found safe after crash
Special Forces veteran’s missing dog found safe after crash

A service dog missing for more than two days after he ran off when the vehicle his owner was driving became involved in a crash in Kettering has been found and reunited with his owner. Officials say Zeus, a German short-hair Pointer — two years old, weighing about 60 pounds — and his owner, a Special Forces veteran, were involved in a two-vehicle...
Trees cleared at Centerville site before bat population returns
Trees cleared at Centerville site before bat population returns

A company building a 360-unit housing development in Centerville has cleared about 20 acres of trees for the project, work it needed to finish this month because of rules regarding a bat. Hallmark Campus Communities is developer of the Gateway Lofts – a multi-family development along East Alex-Bell Road near Chardonnay Drive. MORE: Centerville...
Top financial executive at Wright State to retire
Top financial executive at Wright State to retire

Wright State University’s chief financial officer will retire after 28 years at the college. Jeff Ulliman, who has served as CFO and vice president for business and finance since 2015, plans to retire on June 30, said spokesman Seth Bauguess. He is not planning to seek a position at another school or company, Bauguess said. “This was simply...
Brooke Richardson off house arrest, but judge imposes other restrictions
Brooke Richardson off house arrest, but judge imposes other restrictions

A Warren County judge has modified the house arrest restriction placed on a Carlisle teen awaiting trial on aggravated murder charges. Brooke Skylar Richardson’s trial was scheduled to begin April 16, but was cancelled while the 12th District Court of Appeals considers a ruling about medical records. It could take months for that decision, and...
What makes this new Warren County community unique in Ohio
What makes this new Warren County community unique in Ohio

A development that supporters bill as Ohio’s first agri-community will have its grand opening starting at noon on Tuesday as the project known as Aberlin Springs will be introduced to the Warren County area and the region. Set among 141 acres of preserved forests and farmland, this new neighborhood of 139 home sites offers farm-to-table living...
More Stories