Man found not guilty in Miamisburg Moose club stabbing case

The Dayton man who went on trial for stabbing two men outside the Miamisburg Moose Lodge in February was acquitted last week by a Montgomery County Common Pleas Court jury.

Thomas E. Murphy Jr., 46, was found not guilty on four counts of felonious assault and one count of public indecency. Murphy admitted to the Feb. 4, 2017 stabbing but claimed self defense.

Montgomery County public defender Michael Dailey thanked the jury in a statement to this news organization.

RELATED: Man indicted in stabbings at Miamisburg Moose Lodge

“There are no winners in this case. It is a tragedy that anyone was hurt,” Dailey said. “However, Thomas was placed in the unwanted position of having to use his pocket knife against those two guys whose sole intentions were to violently attack my client.

Dailey said lodge surveillance video shows Murphy backing up during a confrontation with Walter Steele and Christopher White outside the members-only establishment at 2110 E. Central Ave.

MORE: Read other stories from Mark Gokavi

“Thomas was asked to leave the bar,” Dailey said. “He walked out, and was waiting for his roommate so that they could leave (after the roommate collected Murphy’s coat, phone, etc.).”

Dailey said White had confronted Murphy inside the bar regarding an incident between Murphy and White’s wife. Dailey said Steele and White “advanced on Thomas while Thomas was backing up, and violently attacked Thomas between the vehicles.”

A statement of facts filed in Miamisburg Municipal Court said Murphy stabbed the men with an orange camouflage folding knife.

SOCIAL MEDIA: Follow Mark Gokavi on Twitter or Facebook

Dailey said his client has a bad back and was repeatedly kicked by Steele, White and White’s wife.

“The police arrived and had to pull Thomas off the ground,” Dailey said, adding that his client was supposed to get his knife back soon. “The jury found Thomas lawfully used deadly force to stop the attack.”

One man required stitches on his left front thigh area and the other’s wounds included a punctured diaphragm, spleen and three broken ribs, according to the statement of facts.

“While we believe there was sufficient evidence to prove the defendant unjustifiably assaulted and seriously injured the victims, the jury returned a not guilty verdict,” Montgomery County assistant prosecutor Kimberly Melnick said in a statement from the prosecutor’s office. “While the verdict is disappointing, all the available evidence was presented to the jury.”


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

United Airlines has another pet-related glitch 
United Airlines has another pet-related glitch 

United Airlines acknowledged its third animal-related mistake in a week, as a flight from Newark to St. Louis was diverted to Akron, Ohio when a pet was loaded onto the flight by mistake, CNN reported. United is already under scrutiny after one dog died in an overhead bin and another was accidentally flown to Japan. On Friday, the airline...
Winter weather advisory until noon Saturday
Winter weather advisory until noon Saturday

A winter weather advisory continues until noon across the Miami Valley. A wintry mix of freezing rain, sleet and snow will fall this morning. Roads will become icy, especially in elevated surfaces like bridges and overpasses. Temperatures will slowly climb and precipitation will change to rain showers by late morning with improving conditions in the...
Police: Woman stole 1969 Preakness Cup from South Florida storage unit
Police: Woman stole 1969 Preakness Cup from South Florida storage unit

The 1969 Preakness Cup trophy, the prize of a major thoroughbred horse race won by a stallion that nearly landed a Triple Crown, was among the items an alleged looter grabbed from a storage unit in South Florida, police said. Alicia Elaine Murphy, 59, of Boca Raton, faces several charges of burglary and grand theft. Investigators said she cut...
Millennials replacing engagement rings with diamonds embedded in fingers
Millennials replacing engagement rings with diamonds embedded in fingers

Millennials are spurning traditional engagement rings and replacing them with diamonds embedded into fingers, WCBS reported. “We notice lately a lot of people coming looking for that,” said Sam Abbas, who owns NYC Ink Studio in Manhattan. “I think it looks nice, but if you really think what it’s doing to the body &ndash...
Gold flies out of overloaded Russian plane
Gold flies out of overloaded Russian plane

Siberia was the site of a golden runway Thursday, as the cargo door of a Russian plane flew open, scattering tons of gold bars on the ground, The Guardian reported. The Antonov plane was taking off after refueling at Yakutsk when its cargo door opened. Nearly 200 bars from the Kupol gold mine tumbled onto the runway. Officials said the total weight...
More Stories