WEATHER ALERT

Ice Storm Warning issued for entire Miami Valley

Officer: Shooting Crawford without giving him time to respond was OK


Beavercreek police Sgt. David Darkow didn’t pull his trigger when he and officer Sean Williams confronted John Crawford III in Walmart on Aug. 5, 2014.

But Darkow testified that, given the information from lone 911 caller Ronald Ritchie, he or Williams could have shot Crawford on site without any instructions to drop the weapon or identifying themselves as police officers. Neither realized Crawford, a 22-year-old from Fairfield, was on his phone, according to the depositions.

RELATED: Officer who fired fatal shots thought Crawford “was about to” point a weapon at him

The depositions of Darkow, Williams, Ritchie and Ritchie’s wife were obtained by the Dayton Daily News from the Crawford family attorneys, who filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Beavercreek and Walmart in late 2014. The city and Walmart have denied claims in the lawsuit.

RELATED: Beavercreek officer who shot John Crawford III back on ‘full duty’

Williams testified that he shot Crawford because he “was about to” point a weapon at him while holding a rifle in a “low ready” position.

Darkow said the information from Ritchie and Beavercreek’s training meant he didn’t have to give any verbal instructions or wait for any response before firing a weapon.

RELATED: Feds won’t charge Beavercreek officer in Walmart shooting

The Crawford family attorneys have estimated that Crawford — who was on his cell phone — had between a third and a half of a second to hear, understand and react to any commands to drop the BB/pellet rifle he picked up from an opened box in the store.

One exchange of questions from plaintiff’s attorney Dennis Mulvihill and answers from Darkow illustrate the Beavercreek sergeant’s mindset:

Q. So if someone is holding a gun and you give them a command that they don’t have time to respond to, it’s OK to shoot them before they have time to respond?

A. Yes.

Q. Do you have any remorse at all that John Crawford is dead?

(Defense attorney objected to the question)

A. I think it’s a tragedy. Absolutely.

Q. Well, that’s different than having remorse. Do you have any remorse?

A. Yeah, you’re right. It is different. I don’t really — I don’t feel remorseful. I think it’s a tragedy that should not have occurred. Absolutely.

Q. Why did you give John a command if you were justified in shooting without?

A. Because that was my instinct. I can’t explain that. I think we were justified to do what we did. We were justified to shoot him without commands, based on our training. Based on our training, we believed that we were headed into an active threat, a potential active shooter situation. We believed that this person was loading an assault rifle, pointing it at people, and had every intention of shooting up Walmart, and we believed that it was our job to go and eliminate that threat.

RELATED: Beavercreek’s legal bill in Crawford case $430,000 and counting

Attorneys for Walmart and for Beavercreek and its officers have not responded to messages seeking comment on the depositions or the case. The company and the city have denied liability in the wrongful death lawsuit.

A Greene County special grand jury cleared Williams of any criminal wrongdoing in September 2014. A federal investigation finished last summer with U.S. Dept. of Justice officials saying the probe “revealed that the evidence is insufficient to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that Officer Williams violated federal civil rights laws.”

RELATED: Williams used force 10 times the department average

The civil lawsuit is ongoing in Dayton’s U.S. District Court. The trial is currently scheduled for Feb. 5.




Next Up in Local

School district will focus on supporting students after teen indicted on sex crime charges
School district will focus on supporting students after teen indicted on sex crime charges

The Logan County 15-year-old accused of assaulting a six-year-old on a Benjamin Logan school bus now faces additional charges after three other potential victims have been identified. Court documents show the teen was indicted Tuesday by a grand jury on two counts of rape and seven counts of gross sexual imposition. The indictment indicates three other...
5 tips for driving on icy roads
5 tips for driving on icy roads

An Ice Storm Warning has been issued for the entire Miami Valley. A Winter Weather Advisory is in effect for the the following counties until noon: Mercer, Auglaize, Shelby, Logan, Darke, Miami, Champaign and Clark. With slick roads in parts of the region, it’s important to drive with caution if you hit ice. Here are five tips for driving...
Request to rename street after Medal of Honor recipient sparks closer look at policy
Request to rename street after Medal of Honor recipient sparks closer look at policy

A veteran and former police officer advocating that Middletown’s only Medal of Honor winner be recognized by naming a park or street named after him continues his efforts as the city considers its policy on such efforts. MORE: Middletown may rename street, park after city’s only Medal of Honor recipient Last month, David Shortt and Deb...
CMA Awards 2018: Keith Urban, Chris Stapleton, Kacey Musgraves score big
CMA Awards 2018: Keith Urban, Chris Stapleton, Kacey Musgraves score big

For only the second time in his career, Keith Urban walked away from the Country Music Association Awards cradling the most notable award – entertainer of the year. The gracious musician, who earlier in the show blasted through his sexy funk jam, “Never Comin’ Down,” reacted with genuine shock, likely assuming that the...
CMA Awards 2018: Backstage with Keith Urban, Carrie Underwood, Garth Brooks and more
CMA Awards 2018: Backstage with Keith Urban, Carrie Underwood, Garth Brooks and more

Unlike other award shows, the CMAs usually deliver the biggest winners of the night to the media center backstage. Some pop in during the telecast – as Garth Brooks, Brothers Osborne and Old Dominion did – while others, usually the major names nominated in later categories, swing through after the show. This year, the press room ...
More Stories