Police: Getaway driver left suspects behind carrying stolen guns in sporting goods store break-in


The three Middletown residents who allegedly broke into a sporting goods store and stole numerous guns had their cases bound over to the Butler County Grand Jury.

One of the three, John Johnson, 32 — charged with theft, theft of firearms and breaking and entering into Roberson’s Sporting Goods in Madison Twp. on Jan. 28 — waived his right to a preliminary hearing Monday afternoon in Middletown Municipal Court. His attorney, Chris Atkins, asked Judge James Sherron to lower his client’s $35,000 bond. Instead, Sherron raised it to $60,000 and allowed Johnson to post 10 percent if he were able.

RELATED: 3 caught after allegedly stealing guns from sporting goods store

Sherron sent the cases involving Simuel Albin Jr., 25, charged with theft, theft of firearms and breaking and entering, and Natasha Harrison, 25, charged with complicity to theft, complicity to breaking and entering and for four warrants, to the Grand Jury.

Albin’s bond remained at $100,000 and Harrison’s $40,000. She will appear again this week on falsification and drug paraphernalia charges, according to court records.

Detective Joe Nerlinger from the Butler County Sheriff’s Office testified during the preliminary hearing that witnesses called police and reported that two men were seen leaving Roberson’s around 10:30 a.m. on Jan. 28 with “a handful” of guns. Nerlinger said the two men were wearing masks and gloves at the time of the alleged theft.

RELATED: Callers reported suspects with ‘armful of guns’ in sporting goods store break-in

Harrison told police that Albin taped over the license plates of his black Saturn that she used as a get-away car. But after she heard the alarm inside the store, Harrison allegedly drove off, leaving Albin and Johnson behind, police said.

At least two people called 911 to report seeing two men leaving the store with guns, Nerlinger said.

Harrison was arrested a short time later, and Albin and Johnson were apprehended the same day, police said. After Johnson was arrested, police issued a search warrant and found Albin hiding in a Middletown apartment, Nerlinger said. He said all three suspects were taken into custody without incident.

Nerlinger said police recovered about seven weapons, though they believe about 15 were stolen. Informants told police the guns were going to be sold in the area.

When questioned by police after his arrest, Albin told them he “had nothing to do” with the gun theft, Nerlinger testified.

Albin and Johnson allegedly used a hammer to smash out a glass window and break into Roberson’s Sporting Goods.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Dayton duplex fire considered suspicious, officials say
Dayton duplex fire considered suspicious, officials say

UPDATE @ 1:45 a.m: The fire that occurred at a duplex on Kammer Avenue Monday morning is being investigated as suspicious, Dayton fire officials say. Crews responded to the structure fire in the 300 block around 12:20 a.m. with heavy fire coming from the first floor.  The residence where the fire occurred was occupied by two adults and two...
WPAFB Monday Weather: Warm temperatures, rain chances continue
WPAFB Monday Weather: Warm temperatures, rain chances continue

WRIGHT PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE— A dry day is expected with temperatures nearing 90 degrees. A shower or storm can’t be ruled out, however, they’re expected to be isolated.  Rain chances continue into Tuesday due to Alberto remnants. An overall hot day is expected with mostly sunny skies and 90 degree temperatures.
Crews respond to stabbing reported on Ferguson Ave. in Dayton
Crews respond to stabbing reported on Ferguson Ave. in Dayton

Crews are on scene of a reported stabbing that occurred on Ferguson Avenue late Sunday night. Initial reports indicate officials responded to the incident in the 900 block around 11 p.m.  We’re working to learn more details and will continue to update this story. 
Spectrum hiring locally as it expands workforce by 20 percent
Spectrum hiring locally as it expands workforce by 20 percent

Spectrum is looking to expand its local workforce. The company, which offers cable, internet and phone service, serves 45 states and employs more than 95,000 people. It’s looking to fill as many as 20 local positions for direct sales representatives. Top representatives earn more than $100,000 a year, according to the company. MORE: Global health...
Dayton man jailed in child rape case
Dayton man jailed in child rape case

A 39-year-old Dayton man remains jailed in connection to a child rape case. Chay Carmi Lane was arrested around 7 p.m. Saturday by Dayton police at the Kettering Police Department, 3600 Shroyer Road. He was then booked into the Montgomery County Jail, where he is being held without bond on suspicion of three counts of rape of a child younger than 10...
More Stories