Springboro man seeks insanity defense on child sex charges


A Springboro man remains in the Warren County Jail almost eight months after he was arrested on charges accusing him of sexually abusing two young girls in incidents six years apart in Springboro and Lebanon.

Brian M. Jones has been in the county jail since April 18, when he was arrested at the Springboro Police Department, according to police reports, jail and court records.

He is charged with two counts of gross sexual imposition and single counts of rape and sexual battery. Bond is set at $200,000 cash.

Police reports show the case came to light as result of a reported domestic violence incident involving the alleged victim’s mother and grandmother at an apartment in Springboro.

During interviews by a Springboro detective, the grandmother said the alleged victim told her “Brian and his imaginary friend Bad Charlie from the closet would sometimes touch her when ‘they’ gave her a bath. Brian then would tell (her) demons made him do it,” Detective Dustin Christian wrote in a police report.

MORE: Man charged with child sex abuse 7 years ago

Jones is accused of sexually abusing one girl in April in Springboro, the other in Lebanon in 2011, according to the indictment.

Jones is pleading not guilty by reason of insanity, but he has been found competent to stand trial and assist in his defense.

Rather than the Warren County Prosecutor’s Office, an appointed prosecutor from Hamilton County is handling the case.

Jones is scheduled for a five-day trial, set to begin on Jan. 8.

After Jones’ indictment in May, Warren County Prosecutor David Fornshell filed an application for special prosecutor because he “believes neither he nor any member of his staff should be involved.”

MORE: Judge will not recuse himself from highway slaying case

Fornshell did not respond to a request for an explanation about the reason for the appointment.

Amy Tranter, the assistant in the Hamilton County Prosecutor’s Office handling the case, declined to comment on the pending case. The two offices cover each other’s appointments at no cost.

Jones’ Butler County-based lawyer, Joseph Auciello Jr., could not be reached for comment. Auciello was appointed on May 15, the same day lawyer Martin Hubbell withdrew, citing an “unavoidable conflict.”

Hubbell said he withdrew because another lawyer in his law firm represented people involved in the criminal case in a custody case in the local juvenile court.

MORE: $338 Million Powerball winner accused of child sex abuse

On June 21, Auciello filed with the court for a competency evaluation and filed notice that he expected to seek a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict.

“Mr. Jones may have a mental disease or defect that made him unable to understand the wrongfulness of his acts at the time of his offense, unable to fully comprehend the proceedings in this court at this time, and/or unable to assist counsel in the preparation and defense of this case,” Auciello said in the motion.

Follow Lawrence Budd on Twitter

Judge Timothy Tepe found Jones competent to stand trial on Sept. 22, citing his evaluation by Dr. Robert Kurzhals.

“Based on the evidence, the Court finds the Defendant is capable of understanding the nature of the charges, the objective of the proceedings and is able to assist in his own offense,” Tepe said in an order filed on Sept. 22 in Warren County Common Pleas Court.




Next Up in Local

Man accused of walking too close to Old Faithful arrested in Cheyenne
Man accused of walking too close to Old Faithful arrested in Cheyenne

A Colorado man accused of walking too close to the Old Faithful geyser in Yellowstone National Park last week faces more charges after he led police on a chase in Cheyenne, Wyoming, the Billings Gazette reported. >> Read more trending news  Gabriel Villalva, 27, of Greeley, Colorado, was arrested in Wyoming’s capital city Wednesday...
Help Fairborn police identity robbery suspect
Help Fairborn police identity robbery suspect

Fairborn police are asking for the public’s help to identify a robbery suspect from an incident that occurred on Aug. 13. The suspect has facial hair and was possibly driving a silver Nissan Altima. Anyone with information about the suspect or incident, please call the Fairborn Police Department at 937-754-3000.
Cash bond set at $10,000 for Piqua man charged with sex offenses against minor
Cash bond set at $10,000 for Piqua man charged with sex offenses against minor

A Piqua man entered pleas of not guilty Friday morning to charges of disseminating matter harmful to a juvenile and importuning involving a Piqua juvenile younger than 16. Ryan M. Draving, 33, was arraigned via video from the Miami County Jail in Miami County Municipal.  The incident reportedly happened on Sept.19 in Piqua.  Judge Gary Nasal...
Man who killed Colts linebacker, Uber driver in crash gets 16 years in prison
Man who killed Colts linebacker, Uber driver in crash gets 16 years in prison

The man accused of killing Indianapolis Colts linebacker Edwin Jackson and an Uber driver during a crash in February was sentenced to 16 years in prison, WXIN reported.  >> Read more trending news  Manuel Orrego-Savala -- a 37-year-old Guatemalan man who was living illegally in Indiana, according to police -- was charged with four...
Pulse nightclub memorial could span 3 city blocks
Pulse nightclub memorial could span 3 city blocks

Planning for a permanent memorial and museum honoring the victims of the 2016 Pulse nightclub attack has been in the works for more than a year. >> Read more trending news  WFTV obtained renderings Friday of what the memorial could look like and learned that it could span three city blocks. The Orlando Tourist Development Council on...
More Stories