Trial starts for Logan County superintendents in child rape case


The trial against two local superintendents charged in connection with child sexual abuse allegations started Tuesday.

Patrick O’Donnell, former superintendent at Indian Lake Schools, and Heather O’Donnell, superintendent at the Midwest Regional Educational Service Center, appeared in Logan County Common Pleas Court, where attorneys asked a room full of potential jurors questions in an attempt to seat a jury.

READ: Trial this week for superintendents charged in sex abuse case

Patrick O’Donnell faces felony charges that include rape-child under 13, sexual battery and gross sexual imposition. He’s pleaded not guilty to the charges. The Indian Lake Local Schools fired him from his position in November. The alleged victim in the case wasn’t a student at the district.

His wife, Heather O’Donnell, is charged with two counts of child endangering. Washington Twp. Police Chief Rick Core said in an affidavit that the girl told Heather O’Donnell about the alleged abuse and she allegedly didn’t report it to authorities.

Heather O’Donnell has pleaded not guilty. She has been placed on paid leave from her job, pending outcome of the case.

Attorney Sam Shamansky, representing Patrick O’Donnell, asked potential jurors if they agree with the American judicial system and whether they would be able to give Patrick O’Donnell a fair trial.

EXTRA: Logan County superintendent in child sex case sues district

“Do you believe if there is smoke, there is fire?” Shamansky asked a potential juror.

Just because the O’Donnells have been charged, he said, doesn’t mean they’re guilty.

“I have to be able to trust you are willing to do the right thing,” he said to the jury pool.

Logan County Prosecutor Eric Stewart also asked the potential jurors whether they can be fair.

MORE: Trial dates set for Logan County superintendents in rape case

He also questioned them about whether jurors can accept a victim’s testimony if that victim didn’t report the crime immediately. He asked jurors if their kids have ever lied or not been completely truthful.

Defense attorney Dennis Pergram, representing Heather O’Donnell, asked jurors if they have heard of the case and asked jurors not to rely on media reports but what is said and testified to in court.

The trial is taking place in the basement of the Bellefontaine Masonic Lodge due to ongoing repairs at the Logan County courthouse. Opening arguments are expected Wednesday.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Meghan Markle’s coat of arms released: what does the emblem mean?
Meghan Markle’s coat of arms released: what does the emblem mean?

Less than a week after becoming the Duchess of Sussex, Meghan Markle has received an official coat of arms approved by Queen Elizabeth II. According to Kensington Palace, the Duchess of Sussex is represented in the emblem by a songbird, with its wings elevated as if it is flying. The bird also has an open beak, with three quills that represent communication...
94-year-old pastor plans regional youth center in Fairborn
94-year-old pastor plans regional youth center in Fairborn

Plans are underway to reopen a former church in Fairborn as a youth and family center to serve residents in Greene, Clark and Montgomery counties. A rent-to-purchase contract has been signed with California-based CDF Holdings LLC, the owners of the former Emanuel Ministries property, 206 W. Dayton-Yellow Springs Road, according to the buyer, Pastor...
Apartments evacuated after air conditioner catches fire in Riverside
Apartments evacuated after air conditioner catches fire in Riverside

A Riverside apartment building has been evacuated after smoke from an air conditioner filled up a unit, according to firefighters. Crews were dispatched to the complex in the 4600 block of Penn Avenue around 3:10 p.m. after an air conditioner unit caught fire.  Officials said they are working to determine if the fire has spread to other parts...
License plates could cost drivers more in Miami County
License plates could cost drivers more in Miami County

A new $5 license tax may be coming to Miami County soon. The Miami County commissioners agreed this week to hold public hearings June 19 and 26 on a request by the county engineer to implement a $5 supplemental license tax to generate more money for county road maintenance. The hearings will be held at 9:10 a.m. both days in the commissioners hearing...
FREE CONCERT TICKETS: If you live in Huber Heights, the Rose is offering a special deal
FREE CONCERT TICKETS: If you live in Huber Heights, the Rose is offering a special deal

As part of their appreciation week, Rose Music Center will be giving away two tickets for two concerts this summer.  Beginning Tuesday, May 29, at 11 a.m. through Saturday, June 2 at 2 p.m. residents will have access to two free tickets to each of these shows:  JUNE 7 — Postmodern Jukebox JUNE 28 — Kenny G...
More Stories