Warren County judge rejects transgender child’s name change; family appeals


A Mason family has appealed a Warren County judge’s rejection of their motion to change their child’s name from Heidi Clare Whitaker to Elliott John Whitaker.

Stephanie and Kylen Whitaker filed for the name change on April 24 in Warren County Juvenile Court on behalf of their 15-year-old child.

“The child picked a name to suit gender identity,” Stephanie Whitaker said in the motion.

MORE: Warren County challenges transgender protections in Obamacare 

On June 22, Judge Joe Kirby ruled the motion was “not well taken” and denied the name change.

“Mother wishes to change the child’s name from Heidi Claire Whitaker to a male name, Elliott John Whitaker, because the child identifies herself as a transgender male. The child was born female,” Kirby wrote in the motion.

Kirby said the change was not “reasonable and proper and in the child’s best interest at this time.”’

The judge said Elliott has been in therapy for about a year. Diagnosed with Gender Dysphoria, he is in counseling and undergoing medical treatment.

MORE: Legal battles concern Clark county family of transgender 7-year-old

“She first realized she was transgender in the spring of 2017 and started to cut her hair and wear boy clothes,” Kirby wrote.

The child was to begin getting testosterone treatments that “will artificially put her body through male puberty,” according to the decision.

MORE: Community meets on Troy transgender policy

The judge wrote: “Heidi is aware that some of the hormonal therapies are permanent in nature and are irreversible. She realizes that she is already called Elliott, but there are some instances in which her birth name Heidi is and will be used: her school still uses her birth name on their official rosters and yearbooks, substitute teachers call her by her birth name, her driver’s license will have her birth name once she applies for one, and any future passport applications and college applications she makes will have her birth name as well.”

While acknowledging the name change would “resolve some of the feelings of distress,” Kirby said the court “must consider the best interest of the child.”

MORE: Transgender teen killed on I-71 left suicide note

Noting the child’s age, Kirby concluded, “In essence, the court isn’t saying ‘no’ to the name change. The court is simply saying ‘not yet’.”

On Monday, Stephanie Whitaker appealed Kirby’s decision.

Got a tip? Call our monitored 24-hour line, 937-259-2237, or send it to newsdesk@cmgohio.com




Next Up in Local

Multiple jurisdictions respond to reported house fire in Sidney
Multiple jurisdictions respond to reported house fire in Sidney

Firefighters have responded to reports of a house fire on Oak Avenue in Sidney Monday morning.  Crews responded to the 500 block of Oak Avenue before 7:50 a.m. after the fire was reported.  Multiple units from surrounding departments have also been dispatched to the scene, according to emergency scanner traffic. It was not immediately known...
New Outback Steakhouse restaurant’s opening will come with a price
New Outback Steakhouse restaurant’s opening will come with a price

The opening of a new Outback Steakhouse this fall adjacent to the Dayton Mall with come with a price: the closing of another Outback location. But the new restaurant will create more jobs, and seat more diners, than its predecessor, according to its franchise owner. The Outback Steakhouse restaurant that has operated for more than 22 years at the Cross...
Spooky Nook to include second-largest convention space in region
Spooky Nook to include second-largest convention space in region

People shouldn’t think of the proposed Spooky Nook at Champion Mill gigantic indoor sports complex as only an athletic facility, City Manager Joshua Smith told an audience Thursday at his ninth annual State of the City speech. Here’s another way to view it, he suggested: When completed in 2021, it will contain the region’s second-largest...
New bus route connects workers to jobs along I-75

A new bus service that runs from south of Dayton to Hamilton and stops in between transports riders to jobs along the Interstate 75 corridor as efforts continue to connect workers to employment opportunities. The WorkLink route began operation on Sept. 11 as an effort among the cities of Middletown and Monroe, Atrium Medical Center and the Butler County...
Oxford considers measures to preserve and protect trees
Oxford considers measures to preserve and protect trees

Measures to preserve and protect trees are the focus of an ordinance proposed by the city’s Environmental Commission and discussed by City Council at a Tuesday work session prior to their regular meeting. The Environmental Commission had submitted its proposed ordinance to Planning Commission in January of this year and that commission reviewed...
More Stories