Smart home security systems credited for helping decrease in false alarm calls


Tougher rules and stiffer penalties have been partly credited with helping with a dramatic decrease in false burglar alarms in the Dayton area, which according to the Dayton Police Department, is one of the biggest drains on police resources.

But a major factor has been the spread of smart home security systems that are far less likely to trigger an unnecessary police response, officials said.

MORE POPULAR STORIES: Dayton airport hasn’t had a hotel in 9 years. Why that might change.

False alarms aren’t just irritating — they take police away from real emergencies, risk lives and make alarm systems less credible, the city said.

“It’s not only the cost of responding — it’s opportunity lost, because what else could you be spending your time on that would contribute to improved safety,” said Dayton police Chief Richard Biehl. “There’s a cost of officers going to something that doesn’t require a police presence.”

Dayton police responded to 2,915 false burglar alarms in 2017. That’s down 6 percent from 2016 and 42 percent from 2013.

In 2001, the police department received about 13,820 burglar alarm calls.

However, officials say alarms still waste a lot of officers’ time. Police have handled about 2,265 false alarms so far this year.

False alarms tie up police resources because it can take up to 20 minutes to respond, investigate and clear each call, said Cara Zinski-Neace, a spokeswoman with the Dayton Police Department.

Police have to check every alarm call to potentially stop criminal activity like burglary or breaking and entering, Zinski-Neace said. Two officers have to respond to every alarm.

Studies suggest only a small fraction of burglar alarms are for real crimes.

MORE POPULAR STORIES: ‘Please report it to us’: Dayton police noticed a change in how people talk about crime, so they posted about it

The Dayton Daily News found about 97 percent of the intruder alarms in 2013 were false alarms, meaning they were caused by something other than criminal activity, like weather, malfunction or human error.

The city fines property owners responsible for multiple false alarms.

Now, fines kick in at $50 when a property has three false alarms in a 12-month period. The fine increases to $250 on the seventh false alarm and Dayton police also stop responding to the address for alarm calls.

More than 140 properties have been put on the police department’s “Do Not Respond” list since 2011.

Fines have definitely helped, but one of the main reasons false alarms have plummeted is because of improved and more affordable technology, said Chief Biehl.

Internet-based security systems have motion detectors that send notifications and alerts to residents and property owners, Biehl said.

People can monitor their homes anywhere using cameras that live stream to their mobile devices.

“People will verify — they have a camera on their phone — whether it’s a person who’s supposed to be there,” Biehl said.

With a click of a button on their phone, people can arm or disarm their home security systems.

They can control their door locks using apps. They can install video doorbells and indoor and outdoor surveillance cameras.

Motion sensors can turn on the lights and activate cameras to record video.

Residents can customize their security systems so they aren’t accidentally triggered by welcome and expected visitors like dog walkers and house or baby sitters.

With many modern security systems, the residents or property owners are responsible for calling the police if they believe a crime is taking place, Biehl said.

In the past, most security systems automatically contacted authorities or notified security company employees when the alarms went off. Some people still pay private security companies to monitor their properties and contact police to respond when they suspect a break in or other crime.

But much of the security technology today adds a layer of screening and verification that didn’t exist in the past, Biehl said.

Security companies for years tried to verify that activated burglar alarms are legitimate by first calling their clients before calling police, but that didn’t get rid of the problem. Some groups advocated for requiring security companies to make two calls to their subscribers before calling police.

But security cameras with decent video quality and live feeds and other tech makes it much easier for citizens and security professionals to determine if an activated device or alarm is genuinely tied to an emergency, officials said.

Technology innovations in the security industry in recent years have made home security systems more affordable, effective and reliable, said Don Erickson, the CEO of the Security Industry Association.

A comprehensive, multi-year study by Rutgers University found intruder alarm systems not only decrease burglaries, but also decrease the overall crime rates in an area, he said.



Reader Comments


Next Up in Local

Wreaths Across America day observed to remember, honor veterans
Wreaths Across America day observed to remember, honor veterans

Wreaths Across America day was observed Saturday at several cemeteries in the Miami Valley. Nearly 300 holiday wreaths were placed on graves of veterans today at the Greenville Union Cemetery in Darke County, according to News Center 7’s Northern Bureau Chief Steve Baker. This program started in 1990, and by 2005 the day was observed nationwide...
I-675 crash causes backup in Beavercreek
I-675 crash causes backup in Beavercreek

The crash was cleared on I-675 southbound in Beavercreek. We are working to learn the cause. A crash on Interstate 675 southbound has caused a backup in Beavercreek Saturday. The crash was reported near the Indian Ripple Road exit sometime after 1 p.m.  It’s not known how many vehicles were involved or if anyone was injured. There was a...
West Chester hotel thief a good tipper
West Chester hotel thief a good tipper

Someone used a fictitious credit card number to rent a room and charge meals at the West Chester Twp. Hilton Garden Inn. More than $2,500 was charged to a fake credit card sometime before 4 p.m. Dec. 3 at the hotel, according to police reports. Township spokeswoman Barb Wilson said the thief was a good tipper. “With the food purchase, the suspect...
Crews respond to camper fire in Logan County
Crews respond to camper fire in Logan County

Crews responded to a camper fire in the 4900 block of State Route 287 in West Liberty Saturday around 12:20 p.m., according to dispatchers. Initial reports indicated there was ammunition and propane at the location. Dispatchers could not confirm if anyone was injured.  We are working to learn more and will update this page as information becomes...
Officer: Books ‘just as vital as Narcan’ for first responders
Officer: Books ‘just as vital as Narcan’ for first responders

It’s hard to know what impact a traumatic event can have on a child, but Jana Gruber has learned a small gift can make a big difference. Gruber is the founder of Books to the Rescue, a Greene County nonprofit organization that is providing children’s books, games and stuffed animals for dozens of police cruisers, fire engines and life squads...
More Stories