Deadly police shooting: 6 things about Dayton man’s death, court case


The family of a Dayton man who died in police-officer involved shooting last fall is suing Moraine law enforcement.

The federal lawsuit filed last week in Dayton follows the fatal shooting of Jamarco McShann by Moraine police Oct. 20 and a subsequent state investigation into the actions involving the shooting by officers John Howard and Jerry Knight.

Here are six things to know the case:

RELATED: Mom whose son was killed by officers speaks out after lawsuit

•The defendants in the lawsuit. Aside from Howard and Knight, the suit names Michael Cornely, Justin Eller, Brian O’Neal, “and unnamed officers” defendants. It does not name the city of Moraine or the Moraine Police Division.

•The lawsuit alleges conspiracy, wrongful death. “The defendant officers otherwise acted both willfully, wantonly, recklessly, negligently, intentionally, and with malice and willful indifference in committing the acts alleged in this complaint, which resulted in the wrongful death of Jamarco McShann.”

RELATED: Lawsuit: Police conspired in Dayton man’s shooting death

It also claims the defendants “together with their unnamed co-conspirators, reached an understanding, engaged and continue to engage in a course of conduct, and otherwise jointly acted and/or conspired among and between themselves to unreasonably stop, seize, shoot, and kill Jamarco McShann in violation of his constitutional rights…”

•How McShann died. McShann died from “multiple shotgun and gunshot wounds,” suffered Oct. 20, according to the Montgomery County Coroner’s Office.

RELATED: Group rallies for man shot, killed by Moraine police

Police said Howard and Knight fired 10 shots after telling McShann to drop his gun when they confronted him in his car after a report of a suspicious vehicle at Valleyview Apartments on Pinnacle Road just before dawn.

•Conflicting accounts. Police said McShann was pointing a Ruger semi-automatic pistol with a high-capacity magazine and a bullet in the chamber. They said he refused to drop it before Howard and Knight fired shots.

RELATED: No timeframe set for return of officers in fatal shooting

The suit claims Howard and Knight “without cause or provocation, fired multiple bullets into the parked” 2003 Pontiac Grand Am McShann was in.

•Officers returned to work last year. Howard and Knight were placed on paid administrative leave – standard procedure in police shootings – following McShann’s death. They returned to administrative duty Nov. 20, according to Police Chief Craig Richardson.

RELATED: An in-depth look at Moraine officers in fatal shooting

Richardson said Howard and Knight “passed a ‘fitness for duty’ psychological exam and were ready to return to duty” and by the first week of December, they had returned to full duty.

•What’s next? The Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation, which oversaw the criminal aspect of the case at the request of the Moraine Police Department, has completed its investigation. The Montgomery County Prosecutor’s Office said that the criminal case has not yet been presented to a grand jury.

RELATED: Young officer won praise before deadly shooting



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

At least 13 dead in duck boat accident on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, officials say
At least 13 dead in duck boat accident on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, officials say

At least 13 people were killed and several others injured after a duck boat carrying tourists capsized Thursday night on Table Rock Lake in Branson, Missouri, according to authorities. >> Read more trending news  Update 10:25 a.m. EDT July 20: Stone County Sheriff Doug Rader said divers are going back in the water Friday in search of...
Clark County Municipal Court cases
Clark County Municipal Court cases

CASES CALLED WEDNESDAY INCLUDED: Scottie L. Cochran, 23, of 1220 Texas Ave., menacing, guilty, 30 days jail with 30 days suspended, fine and cost due Sept. 16, fined $50. William G. Dufner Jr., 33, of 1530 N. Belmont Ave., violation of temporary protection order, guilty, 60 days jail with 60 days suspended; violation of temporary protection order,...
Centerville boy found wandering alone for second time in a week
Centerville boy found wandering alone for second time in a week

For the second time in a week the same 10-year-old boy was found wandering alone around the city of Centerville and the boy's father could be facing additional charges for the latest incident, according to Centerville Police.  Officers were contacted around 6 a.m. Thursday after someone spotted the boy alone near Stingley Elementary School off...
Here’s why birds are being painted along downtown Dayton bridge 
Here’s why birds are being painted along downtown Dayton bridge 

Jes McMillan’s plan is going up with the birds. The owner of Crane Studio Market and founder of the nonprofit Mosaic Institute of Greater Dayton along with a crew that includes Vincent Detrick, Ileana Del Campo-Gray, Kate Edmondson and Amy Dallis are painting a mural on the train overpass near the intersection...
Full circle: Man spending retirement where he once lived as an orphan
Full circle: Man spending retirement where he once lived as an orphan

The way Lynn Weber maneuvers his motorized wheelchair around the Otterbein Senior Life campus, stopping just long enough to greet every resident and staff member, you get the feeling he’s right at home. He should be. His residence has come full circle. He’s like a NASCAR driver who kept turning left until he ended up right where he started...
More Stories