Dunbar vs. OHSAA: The 5 biggest takeaways from Tuesday’s court battle


Less than a week after Dunbar High School was kicked out of the state basketball tournament, they are back in the hunt for a title.

Montgomery County Common Pleas Court Judge Michael Krumholtz overruled the Ohio High School Athletic Association on Tuesday, saying that OHSAA made a mistake in booting Dunbar from the tournament for violations of state regulations.

RELATED: Step-by-step look at Dunbar case, from Jan. 10 to lawsuit

Here are the five biggest takeaways from Tuesday’s court battle and decision.

1. It’s almost game time

There’s nothing like cutting it close as the tournament game, originally scheduled for Sunday, was rescheduled for 9:30 p.m. today. In the game, which serves as a sectional final, Dunbar will take on Middletown Fenwick.

OHSAA had previously disqualified Dunbar from the tournament, saying the team used an ineligible player in its Feb. 23 tournament opener. Another Dayton Public School, Thurgood Marshall, was put in Dunbar’s place and has been practicing in case they got a shot.

The decision means the team at Thurgood Marshall is back out of the tournament.

RELATED: OHSAA calls handling of Dunbar issue “puzzling”

2. OHSAA won’t appeal

While OHSAA is not planning to appeal the judge’s decision, they did have some harsh criticism for Dayton Public Schools on Tuesday.

OHSAA official Tim Stried released a statement after the judge’s rulling. In the statement he said that the “highest levels” of the DPS administration failed to take responsibility for the incident.

“The OHSAA is disappointed in the outcome of the court’s decision today, but will not pursue an appeal,” Stried said in a prepared statement. “Despite the court’s decision to allow Dunbar High School back into the tournament, it is clear that violations of OHSAA regulations took place.”

3. DPS attorney claims it was retaliation

DPS faced allegations of wrongdoing during a football game on Oct. 28, 2016 and OHSAA placed all Dayton Public Schools athletics teams on a three-year probation. The district was also fined $10,000.

DPS’s attorney on Tuesday claimed that OHSAA’s move to kick Dunbar out of the state tournament was retaliation for the football incident.

APRIL 2017: All DPS schools get 3 years of OHSAA probation

“We know what’s going on here: OHSAA has it out for DPS because of a football game a year ago,” DPS attorney Brian Wildermuth said.

Steven Craig, OHSAA’s attorney shot back, saying “to say we’re doing this because we’re out to get them is offensive.”

4. No word on discipline for DPS staff

The judge’s decision was of course the one acting DPS superintendent Elizabeth Lolli wanted to hear, she said on Tuesday.

But, Lolli would not say whether athletic director Mark Baker or any other staff had been disciplined as a result of the case. This news organization has filed public records requests regarding DPS’ investigation into the situation.

“We want to make sure we send a strong message about accountability and responsibility. We expect that our administrators and our ADs at all levels follow the rules and know the rules, and make sure that we enforce the rules because we only hurt our student athletes if we do not,” Lolli said.

TRENDING: Kettering’s highest paid employees in 2017: I-Team Payroll Project

5. It all came down to one thing

The case essentially hinged on whether one player left the bench area during a Jan. 10 game fight against Thurgood Marshall.

Leaving the team bench during a fight is a violation of national and OHSAA rules, triggering a two-game suspension. The player would be ineligible until he has served the two-game suspension.

Both sides agreed that the player in question participated in that Jan. 10 JV game, never served a suspension tied to that game, and later appeared in Dunbar’s postseason tournament opener.

If the player —a juvenile whom this news outlet is naming only as “John Doe”—played in a tournament game while ineligible, Dunbar would be removed from the tournament, as they were last week.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Dog warden testifies: ‘Worst emaciated dog that was still alive’
Dog warden testifies: ‘Worst emaciated dog that was still alive’

A Hamilton man charged with animal cruelty had his day in court, stating fleas and separation anxiety may have led to significant weight loss for his dogs, but not a lack of nutrition. Brian Trauthwein, 42, of Franklin St., was issued misdemeanor citations on March 23, a day after he called 911 asking for a dog warden to come pick up “stray dogs&rdquo...
Showers, storms could bring heavy downpours & gusty winds
Showers, storms could bring heavy downpours & gusty winds

Few showers and storms this morning More showers and storms this afternoon/evening Strong storms possible Friday TODAY: More showers and storms are likely at times today. There will be breaks for some dry time, but periodically through the day we will have showers and storms move through, including the evening commute home.  &ldquo...
Woman crashes after driving wrong-way onto I-675 ramp in Miami Twp. 
Woman crashes after driving wrong-way onto I-675 ramp in Miami Twp. 

A woman crashed her vehicle after entering an I-675 on ramp going the wrong direction early Thursday morning. Officials responded to the area of southbound I-75 at the northbound 675 on ramp in Miami Twp. around 12:25 a.m. on reports of a crash, initial reports indicate. Authorities say the area is a construction zone with only one lane, which could...
1 dead, 1 suffers life-threatening injuries after shooting in Dayton 
1 dead, 1 suffers life-threatening injuries after shooting in Dayton 

One person has died and another is at an area hospital with life-threatening injuries after a shooting on Norman Avenue early Thursday morning. Officials say the two victims, only described as a male and female in their 40s, were found with gunshot wounds in the 30 block of Norman Avenue around 1:15 a.m. The female victim was pronounced dead on scene...
Semi drivers getting stuck at U.S. 127 road closure in Preble County
Semi drivers getting stuck at U.S. 127 road closure in Preble County

People living near a road construction project along U.S. 127 say drivers are ignoring road closed signs. There are dozens of signs along U.S. 127, including one in Eaton that gives a 4-mile warning of the road closure ahead. Shelly Rowland’s house is just behind some railroad tracks, where her family shares a quiet street with a half dozen other...
More Stories