breaking news

Use of dating website led to capture of fugitive soccer coach in Florida

Dutch court refuses to order criminal tobacco investigation


A Dutch appeals court on Thursday refused to order public prosecutors to open a criminal investigation of tobacco companies, in a major setback for anti-smoking activists.

In a written ruling that upheld an earlier decision by prosecutors not to open an investigation, The Hague Appeals Court said that cigarettes aren't illegal because they adhere to European Union regulations, "so there is no criminal behavior" by tobacco companies.

"The fact that cigarettes can have an addictive character and can create health risks changes nothing," the court said.

Dutch lawyer Benedicte Ficq in 2016 sought a criminal prosecution on behalf of ex-smokers and a youth smoking prevention organization. Hospitals, doctors and other groups later joined the call.

Ficq called for the prosecution of Philip Morris, British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco International and Imperial Tobacco Benelux.

Jan Hein Straeter, director of the Dutch cigarette makers association, the VSK, welcomed the ruling.

"The appeal court's decision is no surprise for the VSK, given that the public prosecutor's office already rejected the complaint in February in a strongly worded decision and concluded that tobacco companies adhere to the law," Straeter said.

Ficq's complaint alleged that the tobacco companies were liable because of "the large-scale, decades-long and ongoing production and sale of addictive tobacco products in the Netherlands." It also alleged that tobacco companies deliberately misled laboratory tests to gauge levels of tar, nicotine and carbon monoxide.

____

The story corrects an earlier version to show that the appeal court ruling upholds prosecutors' earlier decision not to launch an investigation, not a lower court decision.


Reader Comments


Next Up in Nation & World

California farm tied to romaine lettuce E. coli outbreak, recalls more lettuce
California farm tied to romaine lettuce E. coli outbreak, recalls more lettuce

A California farm tied to a recent outbreak of E. coli bacteria in romaine lettuce is recalling more lettuce, as well as other vegetables.  >> Read more trending news  Adam Bros. Farming is recalling red and green leaf lettuce and cauliflower harvested between Nov. 27 and Nov. 30 because it might be contaminated with E. coli bacteria...
Year’s brightest comet flies by Earth this weekend
Year’s brightest comet flies by Earth this weekend

Backyard astronomers will get a visual feast this weekend when a comet that orbits between Jupiter and the Sun will be closest to Earth.  >> Read more trending news  Comet Wirtanen reaches its closest approach to Earth, a mere 7.1 million miles, Sunday evening and early into Monday, making it one of the 10 closest flybys in 70...
Priest’s suicide homily, ‘bully’ coach add to family’s grief at son’s funeral
Priest’s suicide homily, ‘bully’ coach add to family’s grief at son’s funeral

Maison Hullibarger was a straight-A student and a tremendous athlete who ended his own life earlier this month.  The tragic loss was devastating and the difficulty of burying their son was made harder by a priest’s homily with myriad references to suicide and the unwelcome attendance of a hard-nosed football coach who had bullied the 18-year-old...
Florida mother disappears day after Thanksgiving, community rallies to find her
Florida mother disappears day after Thanksgiving, community rallies to find her

Family members of a mother say she disappeared the day after Thanksgiving and was never heard from again.  >> Read more trending news  Tiffany Wells, 35, has two young children and had just started working at the ULTA in the St. Johns Town Center Action News Jax obtained a missing person’s report that says Tiffany Wells never...
Cardi B's husband Offset begs her to come back, says it's all he wants for birthday
Cardi B's husband Offset begs her to come back, says it's all he wants for birthday

Offset only wants one thing for his birthday — Cardi B.    » RELATED: Cardi B announces split with husband Offset  Just one week after the “Bodak Yellow” rapper, 26, announced she and her husband, 26, are calling it quits after a year of marriage, Offset shared a lengthy apology on Instagram Friday...
More Stories