First brother on trial in Greene County double murder: ‘It’s surprising here.’


Jury selection is expected to take about two weeks in the trial of a man accused of killing two people just outside Yellow Springs.

The capital murder trial of 27-year-old Dustin Michael Merrick started on Tuesday in Greene County Common Pleas Court in Judge Michael Buckwalter’s courtroom.

RELATED: Greene County double-murder defendant not initially considered a suspect

Merrick is charged with aggravated murder and could face the death penalty if convicted in the shooting deaths of 44-year-old William “Skip” Brown and 63-year-old Sherri Mendenhall in Bath Twp. The two victims were friends and neighbors.

Their bodies were found Jan. 15, 2017, at the duplex where they lived in separate apartments on East Enon Road.

Dustin’s brother, 26-year-old Bret Sterling Merrick, is also charged with aggravated murder. His trial is scheduled to begin in October.

Both brothers are being held in the Greene County Jail in lieu of $5 million bonds.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys are in the process of selecting a jury of 12, with four alternates, out of 348 potential candidates, said Dennis McManes, logistics coordinator for Buckwalter.

He said the potential jurors are being asked to fill out a questionnaire, and their answers will be reviewed and evaluated by attorneys on both sides.

RELATED: Key evidence challenged in Greene County capital murder case

“It’s a more in-depth process because it’s a capital murder case,” he said.

McManes said opening statements by the prosecution and defense are not expected to happen until the week of Sept. 17.

Brown was the owner of Legendary Roofing Company and maintained a gallery of his great grandfather’s works, renowned photographer Axel Bahnsen.

During a February 2017 hearing for probable cause in the case, investigators testified that Dustin Merrick worked for Brown and was unhappy with his work hours. Dustin Merrick’s attorney at the time, Tom Collins, argued the evidence does not put his client at the scene when the shooting occurred.

Yellow Springs resident Joe Ayres said he was a friend to Brown and knew his father and grandfather. Ayres became emotional as he recalled the crime and asked, “Why would you do that?”

“I used to run on the squad. I’ve seen murder here before. It doesn’t happen very often … It shouldn’t happen anywhere, but it’s surprising here,” Ayres said.

MORE: Dayton’s Belmont H.S. tries turnaround via bullhorn-using principal

Kathy Sanders lives a few doors down from where Brown and Mendenhall lived and where their bodies were discovered. Sanders said Brown had been at her homes about two weeks before he was killed. Brown was going to be doing some work for her, she said.

“I generally turn left because when I go right then I’m always brought back to that day when it happened,” Sanders said of her routine of no longer driving by the victims’ former apartments. “I tend to avoid going that direction. It just kind of shakes your reality when something that horrific happens so close to you. Those kinds of things can happen to anybody, but you just don’t think about it and then it becomes a real reality when it actually does.”

STAY CONNECTED: Greene County News on Facebook

Dustin Merrick is currently being represented by Gregory Meyers and Kirk McVay. The attorneys could not be reached for comment.




Next Up in Local

Public greets Dayton schools turnaround goals with hope, frustration
Public greets Dayton schools turnaround goals with hope, frustration

EDITOR’S NOTE: As part of our initiative, The Path Forward, the Dayton Daily News is seeking solutions to problems that keep the region from reaching its full potential. Dayton Public Schools is the region’s largest district and responsible for preparing more than 12,000 students to become productive citizens. But its continued struggles...
Dayton's Gem City Market receives $150,000 from USCM, Wells Fargo 
Dayton's Gem City Market receives $150,000 from USCM, Wells Fargo 

The Greater Dayton Union Cooperative Initiative (GDUCI) was awarded $150,000 for its work to fund the first cooperative enterprise, Gem City Market, a community-centered full-service grocery store.  2018 Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley, the U.S. Conference of Mayors (USCM) and Wells Fargo joined together to celebrate the CommunityWINS (Working/Investing...
Patient: Indicted cardiologist sends bill, but she still can’t get medical records
Patient: Indicted cardiologist sends bill, but she still can’t get medical records

The former patient of a cardiologist facing federal health care fraud charges said she was surprised to get a bill on Monday. This, when she still can’t access her medical records after the office, the Ohio Institute of Cardiac Care, was shut down. Dr. Salim Dahdah and his wife, Cindy, are accused of fraud, according to an affidavit filed in...
Dayton residence shot into with mother, 3 sons inside
Dayton residence shot into with mother, 3 sons inside

Dayton police were dispatched to the 200 block of Fountain Avenue Monday night on reports of a shooting into a habitation, according to a report. A woman told police she was upstairs with her 16-year-old son when their house was struck by several bullets. They then noticed a black 4-door Honda Civic-style vehicle with dark tinted windows traveling...
Adult learning center opens in Englewood, hopes to help the community
Adult learning center opens in Englewood, hopes to help the community

A new adult learning facility, Empowered Community Services, just finished building on Union Road with focus on helping people with disabilities in the area find work. News Center 7’s Malik Perkins was at the center today to see why people in the community think it’s a good idea. Empowered Community Services CEO Joe Kowalski says they want...
More Stories