breaking news

Ohio closer to allowing dogs on restaurant patios statewide

Judge denies new trial in 1985 slayings

Man goes back to Death Row for killing five


A Montgomery County judge has denied Samuel Moreland’s bid for a new trial 18 years after he was convicted and sentenced to death in one of Dayton’s most notorious mass killings.

The decision puts Moreland back on track for execution for the fatal shootings of three children and two adults Nov. 1, 1985, in a house on South Ardmore Avenue.

The dead included Moreland’s girlfriend, Glenna Green, 46; her daughter, Lana Green, 23; and Glenna Green’s three grandchildren — Daytrin Talbott, 7; Datwan Talbott, 6, and Voliana Green, 6. Other children were wounded, but survived the rampage.

An 11-year-old boy, Dayron Talbott, testified at Moreland’s trial that he awoke on a couch as Moreland was pointing a gun at his grandmother, Glenna Green. She threw a bottle at Moreland as he shot her, the boy told the three-judge panel that convicted Moreland.

Judge Michael Tucker’s sevenpage decision, filed Dec. 23, wrapped up a four-year-old, postconviction appeal that included a bizarre hearing Sept. 20, 2002, at which Moreland challenged prosecutors to take a lie-detector test about the truthfulness of his legal challenge.

Tucker said Moreland failed to overcome his burden of proof in showing he did not knowingly and intelligently waive his right to a jury trial. Moreland’s attorneys, believing a jury would be overcome by testimony and photos of the carnage, said they had urged Moreland to opt for a three-judge panel. However, the three judges voted unanimously for execution. Moreland contended he was never told that choosing the three-judge panel meant forfeiting his right to have both a jury and the trial judge concur separately on execution, a two-stage penalty phase.

Moreland’s attorney, Gregory Meyers, senior assistant Ohio public defender, was not available for comment. Carley Ingram, chief of Montgomery County Prosecutor Mathias H. Heck Jr.’s appellate division, said, “We are pleased with the outcome.”

Complicating Tucker’s decision, no record of the required, open-court proceeding —


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Summer feeding program helps children eat a free meal
Summer feeding program helps children eat a free meal

Children that struggle to eat during the summer months now have a summer school feeding program that gives them places to go to get food. The Summer Food Service Program, sponsored by the State of Ohio, is coming to Trotwood starting June 4 to help feed students while school is out for the summer, according to News Center 7's Caroline Reinwald. ...
Animal advocates for more than a century
Animal advocates for more than a century

The areas longest-serving agency aiding animals, the Humane Society of Greater Dayton, got its start 116 years ago caring for animals – and humans. Here are 9 things to know about the history of the organization according to their research and Dayton Daily News archives: 1. First Established. The Humane Society of Greater Dayton was officially...
Turner: HHS should release groundwater contamination study
Turner: HHS should release groundwater contamination study

A Dayton congressman has called on the head of the U.S. Health and Human Services to release a toxicology report that could recommend lower threshold levels for exposure to chemicals found in groundwater after the top leader at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency said it was not responsible for its release. U.S. Rep. Mike Turner, R-Dayton, urged...
Kil-Kare rezoning vote results change, but recount awaits
Kil-Kare rezoning vote results change, but recount awaits

Results are still too close to call from the May 8 election on the Kil-Kare Speedway rezoning request referendum in Xenia Twp. After more ballots were counted, results show voters supporting the zoning change 617 to 614, according to Greene County Elections Director Llyn McCoy. That’s a different result from election night when the final, unofficial...
Police apprehend 1 of 2 juveniles accused of taking car, cell phone, purse at gunpoint
Police apprehend 1 of 2 juveniles accused of taking car, cell phone, purse at gunpoint

One of two juveniles accused of taking a car at gunpoint is in custody after an alert Dayton police detective chased him down.  The foot pursuit occurred Tuesday afternoon in the area of Burwood Avenue and Germantown Street, Sgt. Creigee S. Coleman said, when the detective saw the two juveniles and the car that was stolen earlier in the day. ...
More Stories