Judge dismisses open meetings lawsuit against city, schools


A judge on Wednesday dismissed a lawsuit against Dayton’s school board and city commission over potential Open Meetings Act violations related to the groups’ school closing task force.

Local activist David Esrati, acting without an attorney, had sued the parties, claiming that a Feb. 6 task force tour of schools being considered for closure was an illegal public meeting. Outside of the task force members, only a few media representatives were allowed on the tour.

READ HERE: What actually happened on the Feb. 6 bus tour

Montgomery County Common Pleas Court Judge Richard Skelton on Wednesday ruled that the task force was legally a committee of the Dayton Public Schools board of education, and thus subject to Open Meetings law.

But Skelton granted the city and school board’s motion seeking summary judgment and dismissed Esrati’s case with prejudice, writing, “There is no evidence that any deliberations occurred during the bus tour or any discussion of the prospective closing of school buildings.”

Esrati quickly responded on his website Wednesday that “you can’t prove what did or did not happen in a meeting if you can’t enter the room.”

IN MARCH: Judge says task force public, but denies injunction

Within the past two weeks, Esrati had served subpoenas on media and school officials who were part of the bus tour. But court hearings or testimony stemming from those subpoenas had not yet occurred.

Esrati stated on his website that he will appeal Skelton’s ruling.

Reporters for Cox Media Group Ohio — parent company for the Dayton Daily News and WHIO-TV — as well as Esrati, fought for access to the task force’s first scheduled meeting Jan. 9, which the group did not announce to the public. The task force responded by canceling that meeting after task force members had already arrived.

JANUARY: Task force cancels first meeting after legal questions

The task force then made its other primary meetings open to the public, but planned to limit access to the Feb. 6 bus tour. CMG Ohio sought and received access to the tours, agreeing to the school district’s request not to videotape inside schools because of privacy concerns for children but intending to report about what happened on the tours.

That Feb. 6 tour was cut short when Esrati filed for a court injunction stopping the event that morning.

DPS Superintendent Elizabeth Lolli eventually recommended, based in part on the task force’s work, the closure of Valerie Elementary, the small Innovative Learning Center and DPS’ headquarters downtown, with the potential for more closures in future years, depending on enrollment and other factors. The school board unanimously approved those moves.

RELATED: School board approves building closure plan



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Should Ohio schools ban Indian nicknames? Group asks state for help.
Should Ohio schools ban Indian nicknames? Group asks state for help.

A half-dozen speakers urged the state board of education to ban the use of Native American nicknames, logos and mascots for school sports teams, citing negative stereotypes and derogatory images. Nineteen high schools in the region use Native American-related nicknames such as Braves, Indians and Warriors, most with an accompanying Indian-related logo...
Watch: Girl, 7, gives rousing rendition of national anthem before MLS match
Watch: Girl, 7, gives rousing rendition of national anthem before MLS match

There have been many rousing renditions of the national anthem, but a 7-year-old girl who calls herself an “actor, model and anthem girl” turned in a memorable version Sunday. >> Read more trending news  Malea Emma Tjandrawidjaja of Los Angeles won an anthem contest sponsored by Major League Soccer’s LA Galaxy. That allowed...
Time to downsize? Gas prices jump 70 cents from last year
Time to downsize? Gas prices jump 70 cents from last year

Motorists waiting for post-Labor Day gas prices to drop could be waiting awhile, according to some analysts who don’t foresee the cost of a fill-up decreasing any time soon among strong demand and short supply. Gas prices in the region averaged $2.86 today, up from about $2.74 a week ago and 73 cents higher than a year ago at this time, according...
Elwell: Start of fall brings more active weather to area
Elwell: Start of fall brings more active weather to area

Right on cue, fall arrived in the Miami Valley over the weekend. Indeed, it is likely we saw our last 90-degree day for the next 8 months last week. Temperatures dropped almost 40 degrees in just about 36 hours between Thursday to Saturday morning. Such a dramatic change in temperatures can sometimes fuel big storms. While the threat was there last...
Prosecutor to refile rape case, man ‘will have to answer for his conduct’
Prosecutor to refile rape case, man ‘will have to answer for his conduct’

TROY – Miami County Prosecutor Tony Kendell said Monday he would refile a rape case against a Troy man and former Ohio High School Athletic Association official after dismissing the case Friday. Kendell confirmed Friday he would refile the case against Henry Lucas, 53, and would issue a statement Monday. In that brief statement, he said he wanted...
More Stories