Judge dismisses open meetings lawsuit against city, schools


A judge on Wednesday dismissed a lawsuit against Dayton’s school board and city commission over potential Open Meetings Act violations related to the groups’ school closing task force.

Local activist David Esrati, acting without an attorney, had sued the parties, claiming that a Feb. 6 task force tour of schools being considered for closure was an illegal public meeting. Outside of the task force members, only a few media representatives were allowed on the tour.

READ HERE: What actually happened on the Feb. 6 bus tour

Montgomery County Common Pleas Court Judge Richard Skelton on Wednesday ruled that the task force was legally a committee of the Dayton Public Schools board of education, and thus subject to Open Meetings law.

But Skelton granted the city and school board’s motion seeking summary judgment and dismissed Esrati’s case with prejudice, writing, “There is no evidence that any deliberations occurred during the bus tour or any discussion of the prospective closing of school buildings.”

Esrati quickly responded on his website Wednesday that “you can’t prove what did or did not happen in a meeting if you can’t enter the room.”

IN MARCH: Judge says task force public, but denies injunction

Within the past two weeks, Esrati had served subpoenas on media and school officials who were part of the bus tour. But court hearings or testimony stemming from those subpoenas had not yet occurred.

Esrati stated on his website that he will appeal Skelton’s ruling.

Reporters for Cox Media Group Ohio — parent company for the Dayton Daily News and WHIO-TV — as well as Esrati, fought for access to the task force’s first scheduled meeting Jan. 9, which the group did not announce to the public. The task force responded by canceling that meeting after task force members had already arrived.

JANUARY: Task force cancels first meeting after legal questions

The task force then made its other primary meetings open to the public, but planned to limit access to the Feb. 6 bus tour. CMG Ohio sought and received access to the tours, agreeing to the school district’s request not to videotape inside schools because of privacy concerns for children but intending to report about what happened on the tours.

That Feb. 6 tour was cut short when Esrati filed for a court injunction stopping the event that morning.

DPS Superintendent Elizabeth Lolli eventually recommended, based in part on the task force’s work, the closure of Valerie Elementary, the small Innovative Learning Center and DPS’ headquarters downtown, with the potential for more closures in future years, depending on enrollment and other factors. The school board unanimously approved those moves.

RELATED: School board approves building closure plan



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Middletown police warn of impersonators pulling people over
Middletown police warn of impersonators pulling people over

Middletown police are warning residents about a group of teens pulling people over impersonating police officers. Police made the public warning on its Facebook page on Sunday evening. Police said four white teens are driving around Middletown in a blue or gray convertible that has a light on the dashboard as well as a loud speaker and air horn. Anyone...
New Ronald McDonald Family Room opens inside Dayton Children's Hospital
New Ronald McDonald Family Room opens inside Dayton Children's Hospital

The Ronald McDonald House now has a new family room after a ribbon-cutting ceremony Sunday afternoon. The new and spacious family room opened up inside the Dayton Children’s Hospital, according to a release. The room is in the west wing of the hospital and has computers, napping pods, a kitchen, laundry, and shower facilities. It’s also...
2 businesses granted request to become part of Middletown
2 businesses granted request to become part of Middletown

Middletown grew by about three acres Tuesday after City Council approved an annexation request. Council approved an emergency ordinance to approve the annexation request of property owners Crown East Ltd. and DKD LLC for about 3.089 acres in Franklin Twp., located near 4501 South Dixie Highway, 6962 Coles Road, and Talton Driv. A gas station/convenience...
Kettering Medical Center hosts reunion for NICU babies and families
Kettering Medical Center hosts reunion for NICU babies and families

More than 300 people celebrated a reunion for children born in a NICU and their families Sunday afternoon in the Nelson Conference Center located at 3535 Southern Blvd.  Kettering Health Network hosted their third reunion for children who were patients in the hospital’s Level III B Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU), according to a release...
Guest speaker Judge Hatchett spoke about Women’s Day at church in Dayton
Guest speaker Judge Hatchett spoke about Women’s Day at church in Dayton

News Center 7’s Letitia Perry introduced TV personality Judge Glenda Hatchett Sunday morning as a guest speaker at St. Luke Missionary Baptist Church located at 2262 N. Gettysburg Avenue.  This service was the culmination of a month’s long celebration of activities focused on women called, “The Queen in You.” &ldquo...
More Stories