Judge: Middletown boy too young to understand gun charges against him


The case against a 9-year-old Middletown boy who allegedly brought a loaded gun to school has been dismissed.

A Butler County juvenile judge ruled Thursday that the third-grader was too young to understand the charges against him.

“He appears to be a bright young man, but he is just too young to understand,” Butler County Juvenile Court Judge Kathleen Romans said, adding that she only knew of two times charges have been filed against a 9-year-old child.

The Rosa Parks Elementary student was charged with illegal conveyance of a deadly weapon in a school safety zone and felonious assault in October after a teacher found a gun and extra bullets in his pocket, according to police.

MORE: Boy accused of bringing loaded gun to Middletown elementary released

The boy spent 10 days in the Butler County Juvenile Detention Center before being released to a family member in late October.

Romans asked the boy a battery of questions, including what a lawyer does, and what a trial is. She also quizzed him on whether he knew the meaning of felonious assault.

“No,” the boy said and shook his head.

But he did tell the judge he knew why he was in her courtroom.

“Because I brought a gun to school,” he said, adding that he found the gun in a drawer while “snooping.”

MORE: Mom’s boyfriend charged after child brings loaded gun to Middletown school

The judge asked the boy if he was willing to go to counseling, and he answered, “yes.”

“Son, you can never be around guns. Do you know what can happen?” Romans asked the boy.

In a small but clear voice, the boy said, “someone could get killed.”




Next Up in Local

Hamilton, Middletown populations barely budge, but leaders working to be competitive
Hamilton, Middletown populations barely budge, but leaders working to be competitive

Population in Butler County increased by an estimated 2,671 people, according to the latest the U.S. Census Bureau estimates. That rise between July 1, 2016, and July 1, 2017, was mainly fueled by growth in West Chester, Liberty, Oxford, Lemon and Fairfield townships, as well as the cities of Monroe, Oxford and Trenton, the data shows. The counties...
Local sports celebrity arrested in Dayton ATV incident
Local sports celebrity arrested in Dayton ATV incident

Robert Martin Jr., 30, known as the “legless football player” who gained national attention in 2005 for playing defense at Colonel White High School in Dayton, was booked into Montgomery County Jail Sunday morning for failing to comply with officers. According to a Dayton police report, Martin was driving one of the eight...
McCrabb: Medal of Honor recipient was ‘mad man with machine gun’
McCrabb: Medal of Honor recipient was ‘mad man with machine gun’

When Robert Kessler Jr. drives down South Main Street or through Woodside Cemetery and Arboretum in Middletown, his mind flashes back to 1944 and the heroic actions of his uncle, Pfc. Patrick L. Kessler of Middletown. MORE: Memorial Day events in Butler County There are two somber reminders of his uncle and his gallant efforts during World War II:...
Student of the Week Triad High School
Student of the Week Triad High School

Name: Ryland Smiles School: Triad High School Grade: 9 Age: 15 Extra-curricular: Golf Claim to fame/honors: Jesus Christ and whatever glorifies him Words you live by: “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me.” Philippians 4:13 Toughest challenge: Stressing about things I can’t control Biggest influence: Sylvester Stallone...
Driver tells police he was just hired to install speakers in truck, knows nothing about drugs found in it
Driver tells police he was just hired to install speakers in truck, knows nothing about drugs found in it

A vehicle stopped on College Corner Pike for operating without taillights brought the driver several traffic and drug charges. During the traffic stop at 1:55 a.m. May 17, the driver got out of the Chevrolet Malibu and then back into it as the officer was calling in the stop, despite being told to stand outside the vehicle. The officer requested the...
More Stories