LATEST NEWS:

Chicago Mercy Hospital shooting: What we know about the victims

Judge won’t put the brakes on New Miami speed camera case


The five-year-old New Miami speed camera case will proceed to a judgment for the estimated 33,000 speeders who say they are owed $3.2 million due to the unconstitutional program.

Judge Michael Oster announced today, after a two-hour hearing, that he was unswayed by recent decisions in other court jurisdictions and denied the village’s request that he reconsider a previous decision that found the program trampled speeders’ rights to due process.

MORE: West Chester warehouse may be opened so victims of moving scam can get belongings

New Miami’s lawyers had argued the landscape of speed camera litigation had changed since retired Judge Michael Sage issued his ruling in 2014. But Oster wouldn’t disturb his predecessor’s finding.

“We think we’ve been right on the law and facts of this case from the very beginning,” said Mike Allen, one of the attorneys for the speeders. “We’re looking forward to some kind of final resolution to this so we can put some money back into the pockets of the people who had to pay those tickets.”

The village did win in one regard with the judge, who ruled a financial watchdog is unwarranted and not allowed under the law.

“I don’t think it would be necessary…,” Oster said of the request by the speeders’ attorneys to have someone safeguard money to satisfy a judgment. “I believe it would be expensive. I believe it could do the opposite of what is being requested from this court.”

RELATED: Decisions delayed in $3.2 million New Miami speed camera case

The case has been limping along since 2013 and it is far from over. Oster said he needs some time to consider a motion by the village to pay the judgment out over a 10-year period and the speeders’ request for prejudgment interest that stands at almost $400,000.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Vote today on speed limits, truck route traffic changes in Austin area
Vote today on speed limits, truck route traffic changes in Austin area

A plan to increase safety on several area roads – including many in Austin Landing - is set to be considered tonight. Miamisburg City Council is scheduled to discuss a plan to lower speed limits and restrict large truck access. The changes were requested by Miami Twp. through the Austin Center Joint Economic Development District agreement. The...
Middletown Schools’ first on-campus clinic now open to all students
Middletown Schools’ first on-campus clinic now open to all students

Middletown Schools opened the first, on-campus medical clinic in its history Monday and school officials said healthier students will help improve student learning. The 4,200-square-foot Primary Health Solutions health center — located on the backside of the recently renovated Middletown High School — will provide medical, dental, vision...
Dayton wants to give City Hall a makeover
Dayton wants to give City Hall a makeover

The city of Dayton is looking for firms to remodel the 110-year-old City Hall. The facility at 101 W. Third St., which originally opened as a YMCA in 1908, is home to about 200 employees, or about 10 percent of the city’s workforce. The remodeling project is expected to take place in phases over several years. City Hall, which the city acquired...
Full-time deputies considered to beef up Miami County building entrances
Full-time deputies considered to beef up Miami County building entrances

A committee formed by Miami County commissioners more than a year ago to make security recommendations for the county Safety Building and historic Courthouse has proposed using full-time deputies to staff screening locations at one public entrance at each building. The recommendations were part of a report by the committee that included Sheriff Dave...
Reports: Occupants flee after crash on Cornell Drive in Dayton
Reports: Occupants flee after crash on Cornell Drive in Dayton

Police are looking for at least one person who fled from the scene of a crash near the intersection of Wesleyan Road and Cornell Drive in Dayton, according to initial reports.  The crash involved at least two vehicles and was first reported around 8:10 a.m. Tuesday. At least two people ran from one of the vehicles involved, but one was taken into...
More Stories