Kettering Women’s Med faces possible closure in abortion fight

The attorney for Women’s Med, the Kettering center that provides abortions for women in southwest Ohio, believes a county judge will rule against the clinic in its fight with the state, forcing it to close.

Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Mary Wiseman heard oral arguments Friday afternoon in a case involving the Ohio Department of Health’s effort to close the Women’s Med center.

MORE: The fight over a Kettering abortion clinic goes to court today. Here’s what both sides are arguing.

In 2016, Judge Mary Wiseman allowed Women’s Med to remain open as it fought the state’s effort to take its operating license. The clinic had filed an administrative appeal after the state health director revoked the Women’s Med license for alleged violations of transfer agreement and backup physician rules.

On Friday, Wiseman posed a series of questions to Jennifer Branch, the attorney for Women’s Med, and James Wakley, an attorney with the Ohio Attorney General’s Office representing the Ohio Department of Health.

Restrictions adopted by the Ohio legislature mandate that clinics providing abortions have written transfer agreements with hospitals in case of emergencies, and Wiseman allowed both sides to argue if the center should remain open without a transfer agreement.

MORE: Centerville park tests positive for West Nile, will participate in mosquito spraying

Branch said the judge asked “excellent questions,” but she she fears the outcome won’t be a good one for the center.

“I think she is going to rule against us,” Branch said after the hearing. “If there is not a judge that will keep the clinic open after 35 years of operation, it will have to close its doors and stop providing surgical abortions to women in the tri-state area.”

Co-counsel David Greer said that, if the judge does allow the state to close the clinic then, “the stay that is in place will continue for a 30-day period for a filing of an appeal, so that gives us 30 days to think about what course we want to follow.”

State Rep. Niraj Antani, R-Miamisburg, and Margie Christie, assistant executive director of Dayton Right to Life, were both at the hearing and feel the letter of the law will be followed.

MORE: Premier Health confirms next urgent care locations

“Regardless of what side this judge comes down on, I fully expect an appeal from either side to the appellate court, which will hopefully render a full decision,” Antani said. “Obviously, we believe the state law is strong and the abortion clinic should be closed.”

Wiseman said she would rule expeditiously after a review of the facts presented at Friday’s hearing.

Jaime Miracle, deputy director of NARAL Pro-Choice Ohio, said the inability of Women’s Med to get a transfer agreement is a matter of politics, not about the health of women.

“So, because of the religious nature of some of the hospitals in the area and just federal politics and those kinds of things, the Women’s Med center of Dayton is unable to secure this medically unnecessary transfer agreement and so, the state of Ohio moved to close the facility and that is what brought us to court,” she said. “It’s all politics.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

Sen. Brown: Democrats can win Ohio in 2020 if focus is on workers
Sen. Brown: Democrats can win Ohio in 2020 if focus is on workers

Sen. Sherrod Brown said a Democratic presidential candidate can win Ohio in 2020 if he or she focuses on middle-class people who work hard but “never get ahead” and do not “have the kind of retirement security they should.” Although Brown said he has not decided whether he will seek the Democratic presidential nomination, he...
Butler County native named to head EPA
Butler County native named to head EPA

President Donald Trump tapped Andrew Wheeler to be administrator of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, an agency the Butler County native has been acting head of since July. Trump unexpectedly announced his decision Friday at a White House ceremony where he was awarding the presidential Medal of Freedom to seven honorees. Citing Wheeler&rsquo...
Ohio congresswoman may challenge Nancy Pelosi for speaker of the House
Ohio congresswoman may challenge Nancy Pelosi for speaker of the House

Rep. Marcia Fudge, a Cleveland Democrat who led the Congressional Black Caucus from 2012 to 2014, is considering challenging Nancy Pelosi for speaker of the House. Fudge, whose spokeswoman said she was unavailable for comment Thursday, told late Wednesday she was considering a run for the top leadership position, and a spokeswoman Thursday...
Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown talks about potential presidential run on WHIO Radio
Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown talks about potential presidential run on WHIO Radio

U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown says his message of fighting for workers resonated in his recent election victory and he told WHIO Radio that’s the message he’d push if he decides to run for president in 2020. Right now he says he’s having family discussions about a potential run, but no decision has been made. “I don’t know what...
‘Heartbeat’ abortion bill passes Ohio House
‘Heartbeat’ abortion bill passes Ohio House

After more than an hour of heated debate, a controversial abortion ban that Gov. John Kasich vetoed two years ago passed the Ohio House on Thursday 60-35 and now heads to the Senate where its fate is unclear. The ‘heartbeat bill’ would prohibit abortions once a fetal heartbeat can be detected, which is as early as six weeks into a pregnancy...
More Stories