Champaign County 8th-grade murder suspect could be tried as adult


Champaign County prosecutors have requested to try the eighth-grade student accused of killing his dad’s girlfriend as an adult.

Prosecutors considered the seriousness of the alleged crimes of Donovan Nicholas, 14, as well as “the deliberate and premeditated nature of the offenses alleged and the available sanctions and penalties available in the juvenile system,” according to a statement from Prosecutor Kevin Talebi.

Nicholas has been charged with both murder and aggravated murder for the killing of 40-year-old Heidi Fay Taylor, according to court documents. He appeared in court on Wednesday for a pre-trial hearing.

He’s accused of stabbing and shooting Taylor, records show. It’s believed the teen would have attempted to flee the scene if not for a leg injury, Talebi has said.

RELATED: 8th-grade murder suspect’s revealing 9-1-1 call: Read full transcript

Nicholas stabbed himself in the leg during the struggle with Taylor, court records say.

In a 911 call to the Champaign County Sheriff’s Office, Nicholas blames the killing on an alternate personality named Jeff.

“This is going to be really hard to explain, but I kind of have another person inside me,” Nicholas can be heard saying in the call. “…I swear it wasn’t me. It was Jeff. Jeff is inside me.”

The teen’s attorney, Darrell Heckman, said he will resist the prosecutor’s request to bind the case over to adult court. He previously requested a competency evaluation to determine if Nicholas is able to stand trial.

“There are mental health issues in this case, and that’s just being thorough,” Heckman said.

Nicholas has no medical history of mental health issues, he said.

RELATED: Prosecutor alleges Champaign County 8th grader planned murder

“I can say that Donovan has never had any mental health issues that have required treatment prior to this time,” he said.

A doctor is scheduled to meet and evaluate Nicholas on Thursday, Champaign County Juvenile Court Judge Lori Reisinger said in court.

Multiple hearings will be held to determine if Nicholas’ case will be bound over, Talebi said. It’s ultimately the juvenile court judge’s decision.

Talebi also has met with the victim’s family members and deputies, he said.

“I’ve spoken to [Taylor’s] two adult children and…they’re obviously very concerned and they’re obviously very upset about having lost their mother,” Talebi said. “And they want to be involved in the process, and I expect them to continue to be involved in the process.”

Talebi said he hasn’t met Nicholas, but, “I don’t have any information to suggest he would be found incompetent. That’s all I can say at this point,” he said.

Nicholas is scheduled to appear in court again on June 15.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Madison Local Schools board votes to allow arming of teachers, staff
Madison Local Schools board votes to allow arming of teachers, staff

The Madison Local School District board voted unanimously Tuesday night to allow district teachers and staff to carry weapons to be "prepared and equipped to defend and to protect students," according to an ordinance that passed. According to the ordinance, any staff members who want to carry a deadly weapon must be approved and receive written...
Use these colors for an invigorating spring home
Use these colors for an invigorating spring home

Looking for interesting colors to use this spring? Here are some of our top spring color tips. USE RED Red is one of the most versatile colors. In nature, found anywhere from flowers to birds, red is an ideal color to signal the return of spring. CONSIDER USING A COMBINATION OF CITRUS COLORS When looking for interesting spring colors to pair, you won&rsquo...
Put bee-friendly flowers anywhere with portable pollinator gardens
Put bee-friendly flowers anywhere with portable pollinator gardens

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — To bees, size doesn’t matter. They don’t care how much space a landscape may cover. These pollinators prefer to focus on flowers. And they will find them. On patios or decks, in window boxes or wine barrels, bees will come buzzing if they discover something they like in bloom. “When we talk about pollinators...
The best and worst paint colors for every room
The best and worst paint colors for every room

Colors have a proven psychological effect on our moods. And the colors we choose for our homes have a proven influence on our overall quality of life. Using color psychology, we can create a home that relaxes, energizes and focuses us where and when we need it most. It just takes knowing which colors to use in which room — and which colors to...
The 5 best smart appliances for your kitchen
The 5 best smart appliances for your kitchen

If you’re intrigued by smart-home technology but afraid to take the plunge, a smart appliance can be a good first step. Here are five benefits you could reap, whether you’re gearing up for a major remodel or just upgrading an appliance or two. 1. Check for milk from the dairy aisle. The refrigerator is the appliance you interact with the...
More Stories