UPDATE: Ex-wife, 5 others indicted in 2017 killing of Beavercreek man

Six people have been indicted on charges connected to the August 2017 killing of Robert Caldwell, of Beavercreek, who was killed in Riverside in front of his three children.

One of the man’s children, Jacob Lee Caldwell, is missing and the FBI today announced a $15,000 reward for information leading to his recovery.

UPDATE @ 3 p.m.

Those indicted in connection to Robert Caldwell’s death include Sterling H. Roberts, 34, and Tawnney M. Caldwell, 33, of Centerville, both charged with murder. Also charged are:

  • Chance P. Deakin, 25, of Dayton; 
  • Christopher C. Roberts, 30, of Dayton; 
  • James T. Harmon, 55, of Burlington, Ky.; and
  • Chandra D. Harmon, 54, of Burlington, Ky., according to a media release. 

One of the Caldwell’s children, Jacob Lee Caldwell, is missing. There’s a $15,000 reward to locate Jacob Lee Caldwell. Call 937-310-3200 or visit online at tips.fbi.gov if you have information on his whereabouts.

RELATED: South Carolina officials say Riverside killing suspect’s charges more severe in Ohio

The FBI believes Jacob Lee Caldwell might not be in Ohio, and he may have a new look and identity. They believe someone knows where he is.

Sterling H. Roberts and Tawnney M. Caldwell are charged with death penalty-eligible crimes, according to the FBI.

Tawnney Caldwell is Robert Caldwell’s ex-wife and mother of his three children, who all witnessed the shooting death of their father.

“According to the six-count indictment, from August 1 to August 5, Sterling Roberts cyberstalked Robert Caldwell via cell phone through the assistance of Tawnney Caldwell,” reads the press release.

The firearm used in Robert Caldwell’s murder was possessed illegally by Sterling Roberts, who “traveled interstate to stalk and murder Robert Caldwell,” according to the FBI.

The charges against Tawnney Caldwell, Deakin, Christopher Roberts and James Harmon relate to aiding and abetting the illegal gun possession.

Tawnney Caldwell is also accused of destroying contents and data of a cell phone.

“Tawnney Caldwell and Chandra Harmon also allegedly conspired to intimidate and threaten witnesses related to the case in November 2017,” reads the FBI media release.

Other charges in this crime include stalking, with a potential sentence of up to life in prison; discharging a firearm during and in relation to a crime of violence, death penalty or life in prison; tampering with evidence, up to 20 years in prison; and tampering with a witness by intimidation, up to 20 years in prison.

Sterling H. Roberts has been in custody in South Carolina since August 2017. The others were arrested in late February 2018.


The six individuals, who have not been identified, were indicted by a grand jury, according to the U.S. Department of Justice.

The shooting death happened at the Claypool Building on Linden Avenue on Aug. 19.

Robert Caldwell’s son Jacob Caldwell has been missing in the days following the shooting. Sugarcreek Twp. police had said the boy’s mother had been uncooperative in their investigation.

RELATED: Teen went missing days after seeing father fatally shot in Riverside

The U.S. Department of Justice has announced an afternoon press conference, where additional details are expected to be released.

Reader Comments

Next Up in Local

Santa Claus visits babies at Miami Valley Hospital NICU
Santa Claus visits babies at Miami Valley Hospital NICU

Santa Claus has made another yearly visit to the babies at the Miami Valley Hospital NICU tonight. The early holiday visit started at 5:30 p.m. at the Berry Women’s Center Building. The NICU elves were also there to take a photo of Santa with all 47 babies who wore knitted hats made by the staff. The photos were gifts to the parents. Over the...
City commission OKs townhome development in downtown Springfield
City commission OKs townhome development in downtown Springfield

The city commission Tuesday night approved an ordinance that allows the city to move forward with a downtown redevelopment agreement for 34 townhomes. The city is now allowed to enter into an agreement with Dayton-based Charles V. Simms Development Corp. to build a residential development called Center Street Homes on a site between West Main and West...
Oakwood schools warn parents about attempted abduction
Oakwood schools warn parents about attempted abduction

Oakwood schools warned parents tonight about an attempted abduction in the city. The Oakwood Safety Department at 5:30 p.m. began an investigating after a 12-year-old girl reported she was approached by a man she did not know who asked her to get in his vehicle near the intersection of Shafor Boulevard and Hadley Avenue, according to Oakwood schools...
Dayton Convention Center Task Force presents recommendations for center’s future
Dayton Convention Center Task Force presents recommendations for center’s future

The Dayton Convention Center Task Force finished its list of recommendations for the center’s future. The task force will share its finding with the City Commission during a meeting tomorrow night at City Hall. Dayton leaders created the task force last year, which has operated with a budgetary loss since 2012. Three years ago, Crossroad Consulting...
Car hits pole, then crashes into Perry Twp. house
Car hits pole, then crashes into Perry Twp. house

Speed is a possible factor in a crash that injured two people and knocked out power to four houses tonight after a car struck a pole and then a house near New Lebanon. John Kyser, New Lebanon Fire Department Assistant Chief, said the driver refused treatment and that her child, whose age and gender was not released, was trapped in the vehicle following...
More Stories