Say it ain’t so: This LEGENDARY late-night Ohio eatery may close 


We have a spot of good news and a spot of bad news for fans of late night eats.

>> 2017 Best of Dayton Winners: Food & Dining

The bad-ish news: one of Ohio’s most important (in our Ohio University grads’ humble opinions) eateries is on the market, and will close if new owners are not found.

>> One of Dayton’s most popular drag queens opens up about overcoming addiction

The good news: there is a lot of interest from those who would take it over. 

>> MORE: 10 of Dayton's best Mexican spots

Marla Rutter, the co-owner of The Burrito Buggy in Athens, Ohio with her husband Jimmy, said interest has been strong since she announced the business is up for sale. 

>> FINALLY: Taco Bell’s crispy, cheesy Nacho Fries have landed in Dayton

“I don’t think it going to be a problem,” she said of finding a buyer. “Our Facebook page is blowing up.”

The Rutters bought the buggy in 2010 from Paul Wildeck, a Burrito Buggy original owner. 

>> As Jeopardy contestants bomb “Dayton” question, Alex Trebek says a prayer

Now the owner of two OMG! Rotisserie restaurants in Athens and The Madison on Paint in Chillicothe, Rutter said she and her family are stretched. 

Plans for a fourth restaurant to be located in Chillicothe complicate things even more. 

>> PHOTOS: The Burrito Buggy arrives in Dayton

The decision was made to concentrate on the restaurants which are in fixed spots, Rutter said. It wasn’t an easy call.  

“The Burrito Buggy is extremely successful. That’s what got us started in our restaurants,” Rutter said. “It is like putting my first born up for sale.”  

>> ‘Change it back’: Snapchat users not happy about latest update

 The buggy sells some of the world’s tastiest burritos (a biased opinion from OU grads) and other late-night grub near the corner of Court and Union Streets in Athens. 

In recent years, its spot was moved to a side of the street that makes it harder to park. 

>> ‘Famous for Pizza’: Casey’s General Store planned for Huber Heights

An Ohio University student rite of passage since 1984,  Rutter said she started eating at the Burrito Buggy her freshman year of college at OU and loved it. 

Some prospective buyers have expressed interest in  moving the buggy to Columbus and elsewhere. Rutter said she would hate to see that happen.   

“Athens would not be the same without the Burrito Buggy,” she said. “I would really be happy if an alum got it, someone who has as much passion as we have.”

>> 7 places to eat breakfast for dinner in Dayton 

The buggy has a large Dayton following. It has “invaded” Dayton the past three years as part of events at Dayton Beer Company in support of Ohio University Alumni Greater Dayton Chapter’s scholarship fund.

As part of the sale, the new owner would get the business name, website, social media accounts, equipment, recipe, a 1984 Otterbacher Custom Concession Trailer, a 1999 Ford Econoline E350 and 40 hours of training. 

The asking price is $65,000 cash, in addition to a $72,000 land contract option. 

The Burrito Buggy on Friday disputed rumors that it would close in a now-removed Facebook post. 

MORE from Dayton.com:

>> ‘What Had Happened Was’ Podcast, Episode 2: Bourbon, Beards and Joe Head 

MORE Best of Dayton 2017 Winners:

>> Dayton.com Best of 2017 Winners: Bars & Nightlife

>> Best of Dayton 2017 Winners: Outdoors, Lifestyle & Recreation

>> Best of Dayton 2017 Winners: Culture, Music & Entertainment

>> Best of Dayton 2017 Winners: Shopping & Services


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Probation or prison? 8 teacher sex crime cases show sentences vary widely
Probation or prison? 8 teacher sex crime cases show sentences vary widely

The latest teacher in this region to be convicted for having sex with a student is set be sentenced Tuesday. The punishment awaiting former Miamisburg Middle School teacher Jessica Langford could range from probation to prison after a jury last month found her guilty of having sex in her classroom with a 14-year-old. A recent investigation by this...
Cloudy with a Chance of Podcast: Joey Picca talks the Storm Prediction Center 
Cloudy with a Chance of Podcast: Joey Picca talks the Storm Prediction Center 

This week on Cloudy with a Chance of Podcast, Joey Picca sits down with Kirstie and McCall to talk about his role at the Storm Prediction Center. The SPC is part of the National Weather Service and is one of nine Centers for Environmental Prediction across the country. The SPC, especially in the spring and summer, is busy producing products that help...
JUST IN: Owners of local, independent bookstore apply for beer & wine license
JUST IN: Owners of local, independent bookstore apply for beer & wine license

A locally owned and independent bookstore and cafe apparently would like to be able to serve something a little stronger than just coffee or tea to its customers on occasion. The owners of the Storybrooke Cafe at 8381 N. Main St. in the Randolph Plaza in Clayton applied last week for licenses to serve beer and wine at the bookstore, according to Ohio...
Local schools win $3 million-plus in federal reading grants
Local schools win $3 million-plus in federal reading grants

Several local school districts will share more than $3 million in federal grant money over three years to help “striving readers” improve their language and literacy development. Northmont City Schools won the largest local stand-alone grant, at $951,000, while three other consortiums of schools working together will share money. RELATED...
Xenia, Middletown buildings top 2 vote-getters in Heritage Ohio’s photo contest
Xenia, Middletown buildings top 2 vote-getters in Heritage Ohio’s photo contest

Photos showcasing empty buildings in Xenia and Middletown are leading the four finalists in Heritage Ohio’s photo contest. Voting continues until May 29 to choose a winner among the four, which are featured on Heritage Ohio’s website. The page has garnered more than 25,000 views since it was launched. To cast your vote, visit the photo...
More Stories